Convenience Stores near Shelter Island, NY

6 locations found near Shelter Island

“a very well-run 7-Eleven. Well-stocked and extremely friendly staff. I usually go in for coffee in the morning and Munchies in the afternoon. They keep the stuff in the hot case fresh. Unlike some places that leave it there all day turning into a dried out in edible Rock”

3.3 Good32 Reviews

“Very friendly, helpful, clean and always the best fresh coffee. If you cant find something they always ask if you need help. This store has changed in the last year. Thank goodness! Such an amazing improvement. Such a great addition to the beautiful town of Greenport.”

3.1 Average17 Reviews

“428/24 Average CVS, well stocked in tourist items, vitamins, drinks snacks, toiletries and gift items. Prices are average, parking is adequate. Found all I was set out to buy.”

2.2 Poor48 Reviews

“I’ve been in Bridgehampton all summer. Never had a problem. Fast service, transfer great, items easily found, polite staff, small store. On visits I have noticed some very impatient and condescending speaking customers.”

1.7 Poor36 Reviews