Shoe Stores near Setauket- East Setauket, NY

30 locations found near Setauket- East Setauket
View Map

“My boys are runners, and when they started having pain, I knew we needed to go to someone who knew about running shoes. Tiana was wonderful! So very knowledgeable and patient with all my concerns and questions. I trust them to take care of my boys.”

4.8 Superb34 Reviews

“Best redwings I have ever been too. The girls in this store are so smart and personable. I have had this brand of boot for a while now and I have never been more satisfied and comfortable yet. Good job guys and thanks again!”

4.8 Superb51 Reviews

“It was a wonderful experience shopping at New Balance. Steve was very professional and gave us good advice as well as top notch service. Definitely go back again!”

4.7 Superb65 Reviews

“This shoe store is awesome. I highly recommend it for anyone who wants to get the perfect fit. The very sweet young man who was there measured, had us step on a platform that gives an analysis of your foot, weight distribution and your arch. Then he gave us recommendations accordingly. Happy 2024!!! ?✨? Blessed be all ???”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“Love this place!!!!! Tracy and Sidney are the nicest, most attentive women! They know what they are doing when it comes to fashion, trends and looks! Everything is so stylish and quality is something you will not find anywhere else! My favorite place to shop!”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“Boutique shoe store that seems to specialize in very comfortable shoes. Top name brands, and the most comfortable models in those brands. Selection is quite limited, but it's understandable for such a small store. But the selection is still quite impressive, and I'm sure you're going to find at least one pair of shoes that you like. During our first visit we bought four pairs of shoes. Not bad, considering that we only intended to browse the selection. We were so impressed with the high quality service from staff members Tracy and Sophia, that we came back two more times, each time bringing my 83-year-old mother who was just as impressed with the wonderful and attentive service that we received from the staff. So, between the three of us, we wound up buying 11 pairs of shoes in just three visits. Wow! I can't believe it myself considering what a cheapskate I am. LOL ?. We are definitely going to shop here again when we need new shoes ?.”

4.8 Superb26 Reviews

“We knew exactly what we wanted. The salesman was awesome. He went above and beyond. This is then3rd pair of boots my 17 year old bought in the last 18 months. And just now.learning that the store provides free oil on shoes each month and also oiled the boots before we left.”

4.7 Superb34 Reviews

“Once again, after researching boots for weeks, I walked out with something I didn't even consider. Nick and co. Showed me what I wanted to see, but then improved dramatically on what I thought I wanted. I wanted side zip boots. Walked out with the king toe BOA easy dial, and after a week, of wearing these, it's my new favorite thing. These are more comfortable than my last style, and have the ease of keeping them loose while driving and not tripping on my laces when I get out. Grand slam once again Nick. Ty so much.”

4.6 Superb27 Reviews

“The ladies who work here are amazing, friendly, welcoming and will lend a hand if you need help picking out an outfit or are indecisive about figuring out what's right for you. The store always looks nice and neat and is always displayed beautifully.”

4.6 Superb16 Reviews

“Stopped in today for a couple of last minute Christmas gifts for my son.Glenn was extremely helpful, friendly and professional.It was a pleasure to be helped by this gentleman (manager).I found the store to be perfectly stocked with a wonderful assortment of items that suited my needs..Will absolutely return, I look forward to being helped with Glen again!”

4.4 Superb28 Reviews

“I have been going to LICS for years and have always been treated with complete professionalism from Phil. I would highly recommend going here for shoes or compression stockings.”

4.4 Superb19 Reviews

“Large selection of foot wear for everyone in the family. Winter months are the best time of year to start looking for summer sandals in the clearance section. Who doesn't love shoes at a discount.”

4.2 Good44 Reviews

“They always have everything I need for my daughter and work with our local dance studio to ensure tights and shoes are available for comp season. They also occasionally have discounts on cute accessories and dance wear. Their prices are comparable to online sellers and you’re supporting a local small business.”

4.8 Superb6 Reviews

“Love this store! I purchase all of my work apparel here including my pants and dress suits, work accessories, and they always have the latest in colors and styles.”

4.3 Superb15 Reviews

“My son loves this store, yes we like online shopping too but this specific store is our favorite. They're super helpful and patient there! Never had a bad experience and more importantly they always have what we need or want when it comes to shoes or clothes.”

4 Good33 Reviews

“Great shoes, great service! The most comfortable sneakers (Merrill) and helpful people. Gave recommendation for shoe restoration when couldn't fix them - even writing down the information for us. Will be returning!”

5 Superb1 Reviews

“Although my child cried the whole time because she hated to put something on her feet, The gentleman helping us was very knowledgeable about first shoes and gave my little girl a balloon to distract her. It was a bit pricey considering I will be sizing up in 3 months but I'm glad we got supportive shoes that fit her properly.”

4 Good9 Reviews

“Huge selection of shoes for all ages and genders. Nice, clean store that usually has sales running as well. If you sign-up you can accrue points and use those for other coupons and cash rewards as well. Sometimes busy, but staff is helpful and line moves fast. Parking lot is a bit of a mess, but the store is still great and the parking is free.”

3.9 Good33 Reviews

“Love this place, I have a good relationship with the owner and workers. Always have a good selection of shoes from running, basketball, boots, and collectable. They have your favorite brand, Jordan, Nike Air max, Puma, Adidas, timberland, and many more.”

3.9 Good22 Reviews

“Shout out to ki for helping me find everything I needed. I was also greeted with a big smile which was so comforting. Ki you are a star! Thank you for making my family's visit to this store special.”

3.9 Good22 Reviews

“I never had children but needed to buy gifts. I was offered help a few times and declined but got frustrated bc I couldn't find 'anything'. There were three people in the store, and while all were helpful, one in particular, I'm sorry I don't know her name was so positive and pleasant. She helped me find two outfits for each of the 5 kids from 2 to 10 I was looking to buy for. She heard me when I described their body type and mixed and matched the perfect outfits! Without her help, I would have left without getting anything. Thank you!”

3.7 Good9 Reviews

“Best Journeys location! The shoes are very well organized and the staff is very well managed and friendly. Store Manager Logan is a great guy and extremely helpful! 5 STARS.”

3 Average3 Reviews

“Ciara was a pleasure!!! She was super sweet and patient with my piercing and walked me through the entire process!! I don’t typically walk into jewelry stores while in the mall but I’m blown away by this experience. The girls working there were very kind and helpful in helping me locate just what I was looking for.”

3 Average4 Reviews

“Would like to first start off this review by saying how amazing the store looks visually. From the overall lighting of the store, to the LED backdrop on the walls, to the design to of the store, overall the store had an amazing atmosphere and very welcoming vibe. From the moment I walked in I was greeted by one of their staffed and asked if I needed any help finding anything, and on top of that they helped me pick out the pair that I bought, really amazing customer service from their end. I was helped by their manager Jen, definitely had a great shopping experience with her. Her knowledge of their inventory as well as shoes definitely made the shopping experience efficient when trying to find the shoe that I was looking for, and I do have to say with the amount of variety that this store has compared to other stores in the area/within the mall itself, its definitely hard to narrow down 1 shoe that you want. That was one thing that really impressed me, they had shoes from your plain dunks to a whole selection of retros to a wide variety of yeezys. Definitely one of the better variety of shoes/clothing that I have seen in a store in the area. On top of the great variety, I felt like the pricing of their items was very fair. Overall I would definitely recommend this store for anyone looking for a great customer service experience, wide range of sneakers/clothing, and at a very fair price point. Definitely planning on coming back to shop again at this store!”

3.6 Good31 Reviews

“I recently visited the Foot Locker at Smithhaven Mall in NY to pick up a couple of pairs of Air Force 1 Pandas, and I couldn't be more pleased with my experience. From the moment I walked in, the staff was incredibly welcoming and helpful. They were knowledgeable about their products and guided me straight to what I was looking for.The store was well-organized, making it easy to browse through their extensive selection. Despite it being a busy day, I didn't feel rushed or ignored. The staff ensured I got the right size and even offered insights into how to best care for the sneakers to keep them looking fresh.Checkout was a breeze, and the overall atmosphere in the store was very positive. It's clear that customer satisfaction is a top priority at this Foot Locker location. I'm thrilled with my new Air Force 1 Pandas—they're exactly what I was hoping for, and the shopping experience made it all the more enjoyable.Kudos to the team at the Smithhaven Mall Foot Locker for their exceptional service and for making my shoe shopping experience memorable. I will definitely be returning for future purchases and highly recommend this store to anyone looking for great sneakers and even better customer service.”

3.5 Good24 Reviews

“Awesome customer service:)) Morgan, a manager at this location, helped me get a small discount on a purchase because i got a fake (scam) gift card and tried to use it here. She (and two other associates) helped me figure this all out and I’m super happy with how they accommodated for me. Thank you guys <3”

3.5 Good25 Reviews

“Everytime I walk into Steve Madden in lake grove the associates are always so friendly and welcoming. They are very helpful and I'm always leaving there with something in hand. They are my go to place for any occasion.”

3.4 Good17 Reviews

“Full disclosure: I HATE SHOPPING, but, my sweet sis and her hubby took me shopping for my bday.I really needed some new items and we decided to try Mandee.Everything is young, fresh and adorable. I'm usually a small/medium, here I was a Large/XL...and that's fine because it is SO affordable,I can check my ego at the door! LolStaff was very sweet. I would definitely come here for some cute dresses/outfits that won't cost an arm and a leg!”

3.5 Good37 Reviews