Gift Shops near Setauket- East Setauket, NY

18 locations found near Setauket- East Setauket
View Map

“This store is adorable and has some great gems. The staff is kind and helpful. We went in for one item and ended up getting lots of fun and funny local items. It’s a great place to get a unique gift especially if you find yourself in a pinch. Great local store! Highly recommend!”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“My friends surprised me with a reservation here last Sunday as a early birthday brunch. Because I don't live in the area I was unfamiliar with the place and pleasantly surprised. Very quaint Victorian decor, every color of pastel from floor to ceiling, even the bathroom was decorated like something from another era. The attention was not limited to the decor, as the menu was very much high tea with choices of tea towers (which looked massive) scones of the day with fresh cream and jam, variety of inventive small sandwiches (loved the French onion roastbeef sandwich and Turkey Brie Jam Croissant) and of course- a substantial list of teas from English breakfast and Darjeeling to more exotic teas like chocolate and marshmallow. Our service was excellent and the small place filled quickly as they have limited hours. I bought 5 different hand lotions in the gift shop on the way out I would love to return again as this place is quite unique (though the lack of parking is typical in any busy town on Long Island, especially one featuring many small businesses near the shore) I would love to bring back some of my tea loving friends in the future after this top notch experience.”

4.9 Superb57 Reviews

“Simple Good always has something special, whether it's a gift for someone else, or a personal treat. The pieces I have from this store make me feel elegant and professional, unlike anything else I own. The staff is very friendly and approachable. It also feels good knowing that the store mitigates problematic consumerism by focusing on a mission of eco-friendly and sustainably sourced goods. Highly recommend.”

5 Superb21 Reviews

“Found this adorable store when we were going to dinner one night and were early for our reservation. Within 5 feet of walking in I already had 3 things in my hand! If we had more time I could’ve spent a fortune! It’s very well organized! Good parking. Woman was very friendly and sweet! Will definitely be back for holiday shopping! 5 stars all around!”

4.8 Superb12 Reviews

“It's a nice store there is plenty of room to move freely. I stop in and get a few scratchers from time to time I got a 20 dollar scratch and one 200 last week ?good times”

4.7 Superb15 Reviews

“The owner is a sweetheart. I looked all over for special little gifts for my daughter’s bridal shower but couldn’t find what I wanted anywhere. I came into her shop and just fell in love with so many little unique gifts. It’s great to know when I need something special this will be my go to place.”

4.9 Superb8 Reviews

“Hey George, I’m happy to see you’re still around running East Coast Psychedlics. I miss seeing ya back in Commack all these yrs ago now. I hope all is well. You treated me very well as customer and a fellow human being. Was in the area today for work and saw this place pop up on Google Maps, hyped!! Gotta check out this new location and say hi again sometime!”

5 Superb6 Reviews

“This store has a lot of cute stuff❣️❣️ They have also a lot of accessary which is cute and reasonable price !! all of the objects were good in the price and pretty ?”

4.6 Superb9 Reviews

“Lots of cool unique items from artists all over the island & country. It smells so good when you walk in and the vibes are just immaculate ? they have everything from glass, to clothes, Grateful Dead merch, incense, oils, plants, tarot cards, crystals, books, lamps, you name it. Great spot to find a gift”

4.4 Superb14 Reviews

“Great service! Had to put a plush animal toy on hold for a few days for a pick up. Item was confirmed and placed on hold. Picked it up last evening. My Mom is obsessed with her gift!”

3.8 Good6 Reviews

“I always find something I want here, and as a minimalist, take that for what it is. While I find the books overpriced, everything else is actually a good deal, and a very curated collection of oddities but not usually creepy ones (except those scorpions). Always a great selection of essential oils and beautiful little jewelry pieces. This time I walked away with one roll-on perfume, one essential oil blend, a beautiful pair of delicate sterling silver earrings, and a big lunar moth ring.”

3.8 Good12 Reviews

“Jay was a pleasure to work with, I came in was indecisive as to what to get for the staff at Tutor Time. But Jay took the time and gave me some options and suggestions and made it easy for me. He was super patient as well and accommodating…I will continue to visit this location for future orders thanks so much!”

3.8 Good22 Reviews

“I visited my favorite store Lavender Fields today. Lori has a beautiful heart outside her shop. A photo back drop. I waited to take a pic. Everyone was loving she did this. Always thinking of people walking around PJ n letting them enjoy her store. She has such unique pieces. I leave with bags. Her interior design background helps me style my house with her pieces. The customer service I receive is rare these days. She appreciates your business, which is why I forever will shop here. I want one of everything.”

3.8 Good42 Reviews

“This is by far my favorite Edible Arrangements. The customer service is always great. It's always clean and always accommodating. I can call very last minute and they will accommodate you. Fruit is always fresh and have no problems honoring coupon codes.”

3.5 Good8 Reviews

“The one star reviews are completely wrong, the store was the complete opposite. The employees were both very helpful and friendly, and I had a great overall experience.”

3.4 Good10 Reviews

“Hands down the nicest staff! I always order from here for local pick up or deliveries they have the freshest fruit and cleanest store location I’ve experienced. Highly recommend this location!”

3 Average13 Reviews

“Excellent personal shopping experience. Small boutique_gift shop for a hostess gift, friends birthday, or new home by water. Gorgeous dish towels,candles,pictures, chimes, lights, lamps, lighthouses, real lights Beautiful hidden delight steps away from Port Jefferson ferry at an affordable price and value”

2.7 Average12 Reviews

“Thank you Shazia you did a wonderful job of turning a bad experience into a great one. I really appreciate your help and dedication to what I was trying to accomplish due to the circumstances I would recommend your business to everyone in the local area and beyond you are a great help in the time of need and accomplished everything that I wanted to get done I give you all a five star rating just because of your personal service to me and I’m located in Florida and the delivery was for New York who is the person that I care deeply about and wanted to send some thing special to them and you accomplished that. Once again, thank you to you and your staff and I could have nothing less than five stars.”

2.6 Average19 Reviews