Butchers near Setauket- East Setauket, NY

7 locations found near Setauket- East Setauket

“The price is steep (what isn't these days?) But there's no arguing with the quality and the service. Support a local business and get some top quality meat!”

4.8 Superb18 Reviews

“Absolutely amazing. We catered for 50 for our engagement party and all of our guests were raving over the food! Everyone was asking where it was from, the chicken parm, Mac and cheese & grilled chicken hero were a hit and fan favorite with no leftovers. Can’t wait to return and order it for lunch/dinner one day soon.”

4.9 Superb53 Reviews

“I have never seen a place so beautiful and has everything I need. I was mesmerized by the place and the cleanliness, top notch. I will be back man. In fact this is my place to shop and eat now.”

4.5 Superb204 Reviews

“We ordered a 4-foot hero for a party, half American and half Italian. It was amazing. The guests raved about it. They use Boarshead cold cuts, the toppings were fresh and they were generous with the cheese. Service was also very helpful and efficient. The gentleman helped me carry it out to my car. We will definitely use them again for future parties!”

4.7 Superb71 Reviews

“Absolutely amazing store!!Stuff is great!!!Food is amazing!!! Jay is always recommend something delicious for dinnerAll our family in love with product that they have!!!”

4.1 Good50 Reviews

“Can’t say enough good things about this place. My wife was hospitalized. We had to cancel Friday for sunday pick up, found out late Saturday that she would be coming home for Christmas Eve. Call them up at 5 o’clock no problem and the hero was amazing.”

4 Good45 Reviews

“The gentleman at the meat department are very nice. About 2 weeks ago, I asked about pork loin to make pulled pork and they didn't have much on display. Even though this person was extremely busy, I interrupted him nicely and he made me the most beautiful pork loin. I can't recall if it was 3 lbs but it was under $10!! The one I was going to choose was 5 lb. It had a lot of fat on it and it was $22 and it was lesser quality of pork. I wish I asked for his name. Because I wanted to thank him for his excellent service.”

3.9 Good78 Reviews