-
November 2023 by Elisa R.
Excellent customer service with concierge style care. Attention to detail is obvious from entry. They've been here forever! I didn't know. Yellow gold and white gold as well as titanium. The best part is that they can assist for ANY budget. Ladies are helpful when I was selecting for a 19 yr old graduating and 88 yr old who needed something for a function. Parking ample in rear or in cornucopia lot don't let Main rd deter you. They'll also repaired my watch in a good time frame with affordability While other stores have an estimate on watch repair, and this was the most cost-effective method for me.
-
November 2023 by Chris Shaljian
I can't say enough about Dorothy's Jewelers in Sayville. They are so pleasant and knowledgeable. A good friend of mine recommended them and I was not disappointed. They have a great selection and if you want something specific they will create it for you. They also do jewelry repairs and watch batteries.
-
January 2023 by Linda C.
great selection of jewelry here..went in to look at silver bracelets and walked out with earrings, necklace, And bracelet! Very nice atmosphere there. Dorothy and her staff are all very nice.
-
October 2021 by Marion P.
Live this store. Have purchased here. I also trust them when I have repairs. I have never been disappointed! Thanks Dorothy and staff!
-
April 2021 by Tara Steuart
I was so excited when my fiancé got my engagement ring from here and not a box store like Kay jewelers. I loved the ring and everything about it, he made the experience sound perfect. Well today, we went in (after trying to
-
April 2021 by Tara Lynn Steuart
I was so excited when my fiancé got my engagement ring from here and not a box store like Kay jewelers. I loved the ring and everything about it, he made the experience sound perfect. Well today, we went in (after trying to Go there multiple times and they’d be closed early, or a note on the door saying they’re closed Tuesday when their website does not state such..) So we walked in, and asked to get our ring appraised so I can put it on our insurance policy and also if we could size my fiancé for wedding bands and see the wedding band that matches my ring. Well, she did not want to be bothered with us. She told me id need to make an appointment, and she is not taking appraisal appointments. Then continued to tell my fiancé that it didn’t make sense to size his finger if we weren’t getting a ring at the moment.. and didn’t even want to be bothered with showing me the matching wedding band for my ring. Very disappointing, and now we need to find somewhere else to bring our business.
-
April 2021 by Tara J.
I was so excited when my fiancé got my engagement ring from here and not a box store like Kay jewelers. I loved the ring and everything about it, he made the experience sound perfect. Well today, we went in (after trying to Go there multiple times and they'd be closed early, or a note on the door saying they're closed Tuesday when their website does not state such..) So we walked in, and asked to get our ring appraised so I can put it on our insurance policy and also if we could size my fiancé for wedding bands and see the wedding band that matches my ring. Well, she did not want to be bothered with us. She told me id need to make an appointment, and she is not taking appraisal appointments. Then continued to tell my fiancé that it didn't make sense to size his finger if we weren't getting a ring at the moment.. and didn't even want to be bothered with showing me the matching wedding band for my ring. Very disappointing, and now we need to find somewhere else to bring our business. Very upsetting that this family owned business didn't want to stand behind their product.
-
August 2020 by Anthony B.
I've been shopping here for years and will continue to do so! Dorothy and her staff are always pleasant and helpful. No "run of the mill" jewelry here. Dorothy has a knack for picking some beautiful pieces. She also does an amazing job with custom work. Stop down, give them a try, you won't be disappointed!
-
June 2020 by Alix S.
Stopped in here with my then boyfriend looking at engagement rings after going to another jewelry shop in Sayville that I wasn't super happy with. We met with another staff member and Dorothy and I ended up falling in love with a ring that my fiancé ended up going back to get! Everything they had was absolutely gorgeous and we were both super happy with their knowledge and professionalism!
-
January 2020 by Cassandra DiMarco
I had to get my watch repaired and I decided to go with Dorothy's Fine Jewelry to get it repaired. I had a very positive experience with them. Dorothy the owner and the two ladies that helped me, named Kelly and Gina are all very nice and I'm so glad I went with them to fix my watch. It's an old, very good watch that was my Aunts, and was handed down to me in the family when my Aunt passed away. I'm so glad I had it repaired because it's a very good watch, but also it's a memory of my Aunt and now I can wear it since it works again since Dorothy's repaired it.
-
July 2018 by Stacyanne Harris
Had a wonderful experience with Dorothy's Jewelry store. Dorothy sat with us, took the time to answer all of our questions.we never felt rushed, and we found the perfect ring! I recommend Dorothy's Jewelry store for all your jewelry needs!
-
October 2017 by Pat Cavanagh
Needed a watch battery - was treated like I was buying a diamond 👠I like this place
-
August 2016 by Matthew Cuty
I called to inquire about ear piercing, I asking too many questions and woman became sharp and quick with me.
-
October 2014 by Fulvio Capra
What a pleasant and refreshing experience! The staff as well as Dorothy were very polite, knowledgeable and willing to help me find the perfect birthday gift for my wife. I would definitely recommend Dorothy's Fine Jewelry for any of your jewelry needs.
-
July 2013 by Jesse Hirsch
Nice staff helped me find what I was looking for.