-
June 2023 by Aileen Rosin
A friendly, reasonable store with surprisingly fun baby clothes!
-
July 2022 by Max Cohn
Been coming here for the last 10 years with my family and have always had pleasant experiences. The coffee is the arguably the best in New York and I highly recommend getting the chocolate covered s’more. The hamptons wouldn’t be the hamptons without Sylvester’s.
-
April 2022 by Claire Denison
the best coffee in the hamptons !!!!
-
September 2021 by scott osman
This store is the most important store in sag harbor because it has Dreamy Coffee on tap in the back. I’m not even going to tell you what Dreamy is because you should experience it as a surprise. Speaking of surprises - this is a great store for specials gifts.
-
December 2020 by Joseph Cusumano
Just received a private message from this “classy” establishment. Lol. Unbelievable. I won’t repost it. Funny,the visible answers to your bad reviews seem that they almost care about the customer.
-
October 2020 by Deborah G.
Love the store. Lynda the owner is a doll. Very accomodating to her customers.Just great stuff and reasonably priced. Excellent coffee!
-
October 2019 by Olivia Ionescu
I’m sad to write a bad review because I’ve been coming to this beloved spot for 20 years. Two days in a row I showed up at 9am eager and excited for my dreamy coffee that I’ve been waiting for all year (first chance to come out). Saturday didn’t open till 9:15am - I waited and then today at 9:30 it still wasn’t open. Honestly if you’re not planning on opening on time change your times or put a sign that you’ll be opening late. I watched multiple people try to come in and fail. It’s a disappointment for a place I love to visit when I come out here. I couldn’t wait this time because I had to go back to work! Let your fans know what’s up - don’t take us for granted
-
October 2019 by Nancy M.
My favorite go to spot! Perfectly edited with something for everyone. Alway leave happy with the perfect gift or something special for me.
-
July 2019 by theresa mahon
Just spent +7$ on a pint of dreamy coffee at my local farm stand and not one almond in the whole pint. Very disappointed. Won't be buying this ice cream again.
-
July 2019 by Tobi Bear
Overrated overpriced coffee.
-
July 2019 by Cecilia F.
This is a unique store where everything is very well curated and though some items are expensive, there are some that are quite reasonable by local standards. It is also notable for its dog friendly vibe and great coconut coffee, which off season is priced at $1.00!! There's a bi of everything--clothes, hats, floor mats, books, accessories, housewares, and small home furnishings and decorations. It's a very good place to buy a house gift or treat yourself to something tasteful and unusual.
-
July 2019 by Michael Cooper
Great fun place to walk around and great coffee
-
June 2019 by Meredith Hulse
Love the coffee bar!
-
February 2019 by Holly Marie Dunn
A Sag Harbor Main Street mainstay! Such a comfort to walk into this beautiful place amid a rapidly changing Sag Harbor, and enjoy a cup of Dreamy coffee and see familiar faces of friends and locals. Lynda is always bringing in something fresh and new, while keeping around the staples that regulars always hope to find in the shop. The best coffee in town, indulgent sweets and desserts and one of a kind products you can't find anywhere! Fave shop in the Hamptons :)
-
December 2018 by LAS2
Adore a visit to see what's cool
