Hotels near Sag Harbor, NY

17 locations found near Sag Harbor

“The staff, service and food were absolutely on point.... oysters Rockefeller, the bone marrow and the lamb chops were a favorite among all our guests... Truly an amazing experience all the way around.... highly recommend the restaurant at the American Hotel in Sag Harbor.”

4.3 Superb251 Reviews

“Stayed for a long weekend break. It was great. Very peaceful with an excellent host, lovely room, wonderful breakfast and a gorgeous dog called Peaches who we loved spending time with. Can fully understand why they have many repeat visitors, we will certainly be backRooms: Well appointed, plenty of towels etc.”

5 Superb37 Reviews

“We always enjoy The Bridge Hampton Inn Restaurant! The staff is so professional! The atmosphere is absolutely charming! The bartender makes awesome drinks! The food is always delicious!”

4.5 Superb186 Reviews

“I recently stayed at The Reform Club Inn in Amagansett, NY. The service was exceptional, with attentive and courteous staff making me feel welcome. The location is fantastic, nestled in the charming village of Amagansett, offering a peaceful retreat.

However, the WiFi was a major letdown. For a place this expensive, I expected reliable internet, but it was extremely flaky, making it hard to stay connected.

Overall, while the service and location are top-notch, the poor WiFi is a significant drawback. If they fix this issue, it would greatly improve the experience.”

4.5 Superb33 Reviews

“Charming resort. Perfect getaway weekend with family just minutes from the ocean. Clean rooms, friendly staff and set in a great location minutes from town center.”

4.3 Superb80 Reviews

“Gorgeous little hotel, fantastic service, and a great area in Greenport! Felecia at the front desk is amazing. We loved raiding the galley late night and how most restaurants/bars were in walking distance. Visit Goldbergs in the AM for breakfast. Ten out of ten!”

4.3 Superb67 Reviews

“This is simply an incredible place to stay in East Hampton...everything is wonderful. We have been staying there for years and years and every time we stay is more special than the last. The service is wonderful and the rooms are impeccable. Of course it is also a great location so close to town, but nothing compares to the people who run the hotel. Don't miss this gem!”

4.4 Superb47 Reviews

“Peaceful and close stroll to town.

Nearby activities: beach, town shops and dining

Safety: safe and private

Walkability: yes

Food & drinks: not many options, I would bring own.

Noteworthy details: cute sitting spaces and activities”

4.2 Good75 Reviews

“Gorgeous accommodations. So pretty, clean, nice pool and seating area. Complimentary coffee station in lobby (with actual good coffee!). Friendly staff! Loved it! Highly recommend staying here.”

4.3 Superb63 Reviews

“I recently stayed at the Tapestry House for a girls overnight and thoroughly enjoyed my stay. Our host Joan, was lovely and extremely accommodating! The decor was beautiful and the house felt very welcoming. We really enjoyed sitting out on the front wrap around porch by the fire feature at night and while having breakfast. I’ll definitely be back!!Walkability: Many shops and restaurants in close proximity.Noteworthy details: Stunning trim work in every room. Beautiful high ceilings and lots of original details. Beautiful flowers adorn the porch.”

4.8 Superb19 Reviews

“I planned on staying one night but ended up staying an additional night. I really liked this place and the staff working here were very kind and helpful. The room was clean and comfortable and parking was easy. I would like to come back in the summer to use the pool. Bbqs are available on the patio as well and there is a large green lawn area. It’s a smaller property but I appreciated that. A quick drive to the beach and town and during the summer you could easily ride a bike to the beach.”

4 Good38 Reviews

“Food & drinks: I had a remarkable fine dining experience here at the Topping Rose House. I was met with great service, coupled with a top of the line brunch. They certainly surpassed my expectations, would come again!

What I enjoyed: lobster roll, pistachio crusted salmon, vegan banana pancakes.”

3.9 Good238 Reviews

“The staff here go above and beyond to cater to their guests. The staff makes you feel like family and it’s a special place. The rooms are spacious and well thought out and very conveniently located. I can’t wait to stay here again.”

3.8 Good76 Reviews

“we come by boat every year by boat for a couple of nights location is fabulous. Property is beautiful staffing owners very accommodating. Our bonus was concert on the lawn right behind our boat on Tuesday night. We had a wonderful time as always highly recommended.”

3.5 Good55 Reviews

“I was sceptical after reading the reviews. BUT, new owners and managers turned it to a stunning top star Hotel. Rooms are tiny, yes, but gorgeous. The service is outstanding. So much detail to high quality products like GHD hair dryer and Steamer in every room. Wonderfully smelling bath products, the food, 5 stars. Can highly recommend. And a Gucci Airstream with FREE coffee. Wow! Just incredible.”

3.4 Good224 Reviews

“My cousin and I stayed here for a little girls getaway. Annie, the manager, was so sweet and kind and helpful. We love the way the rooms are decorated and they are very clean. The pool was my favorite part, but it’s also not too far from the ocean if you prefer going to the beach. Definitely a good location with great staff. I would stay there again.”

3.5 Good195 Reviews

“We Love Harbor Front inn. try to go every year atleast once. The hotel and services are 5 star. So convenient to all. Breakfast is perfect! Rooms are so comfortable!”

3.3 Good59 Reviews