-
March 2024 by John Darden
One of the best places in the Sackets Harbor area. Great pizza, great service and a great time.
-
March 2024 by David Scott
My favorite dishes weren’t as delicious as they usually are. Still good but pizza was undercooked and bruschetta (their version is my absolute favorite) not as tasty. Service was outstanding as always. It’s still my favorite restaurant in Sackets and I’ll definitely return because 90% of the time, it’s 5 stars. No one can be ‘A game’ every day, especially in winter.
-
February 2024 by Kelly Lewis
Split Good Fellows salad ?Ate pizza specialBrick oven
-
February 2024 by Stephanie Gates
Called tonight to place a to go order. A guy answered and I had him on speaker to place my order. When I hung up my son made the comments that the guy who took my order was rude. I ordered what I usually order and when to oick it up. I waited at the front while the hostess and the guy who to my order continued to talk fro 12 minutes and then looked at me and said did you need something? Well actually yes after 12 minutes of waiting. Then my order was wrong I asked for linguine pasta and did not get it. The hostess then got annoyed with me because the pasta was wrong. I ended up leaving the money and taking the meal they made since the hostess was so rude. I've tried and tried and tried. We have always loved Goddfellos until lately
-
January 2024 by Hunter M
Atmosphere and service was great. Ordered a chicken parm and it was HUGE and tasted great. Highly recommend and would definitely return.
-
January 2024 by James Meylor
I Love going to Good Fellos and it has a great service and great food and everyone goes there and having a great experience?
-
January 2024 by Allisin Millwee-Begue
I highly recommend the Wine Wednesday special and the pizza is delicious.
-
January 2024 by Gabe Laguna
Good food, it can get crowded but it's a good atmosphere, clean bathroom.
-
December 2023 by Andrea Morgia
We had an entree and a pizza, both delicious. Service was speedy and Tracey was very attentive.
-
November 2023 by Joie ann
I'd been dying to go here so this is my honest review.Food 4 stars. We had bruchetta and the Mussolini pizza. The taste was fantastic, but the portion size was disgusting. The 20$ pizza was slightly larger than a personal pan.Service 1 star. Only giving one because we really didn't wait long for our food. Upon coming in, we waited at the door to be seated while two employees snacked and ignored us. We were seating around 3-5 minutes later. Our waitress was horrible. Our wine orders were taken, but never asked if we were ready for anything else. She came back several minutes later, gave us wine and walked away. We flagged her down for water and when she returned asked if we wanted appetizers. We ordered bruchetta and before I could say we were also ready to order she walked away. She had another waiter bring something to us and screamed "thanks baby" to him - assuming that is her partner. She eventually came around to take our food orders. She tended carefully to the large groups next to us but treated us like we were chopped liver. Assuming because we were a young couple and the other were wealthy rich old men. Her service was bad enough that I'd rather not go there again.3 stars for atmosphere. It's very clean and cute. The seating was weird. I sat on a bench and my husband sat on a chair so small it made him the size of a child. You couldn't hear yourself think - so definitely not a good date restaurant. It was very cramped. The music was turned up so loud to drown the talking but just made everything uncomfortable.
-
November 2023 by jon c
Smallest pizza's I've ever seen! Each pie fits on a dinner plate, we ordered 2 pies and a salad for $60+tip and they forgot the Asiago in the salad. The food wasn't bad I've just never seen such tiny portions...anywhere ....ever!
-
October 2023 by Lisa W
I stopped in here to have a glass of wine on a rainy day and glad that I did! I saw some of the pizzas going out to the tables and the pizzas looked so similar to the ones I had when I was in Italy. We decided to come back later and get a pizza to go. So glad we did! It was very similar to the pizzas we had when we were in Italy.
-
October 2023 by Nancy S.
We went on Wednesday wine night and shared a gluten-free pizza. Very tasty. They had a reasonable selection of wines to choose from.
-
October 2023 by Dakota Niswonger
Breath taking, very beautiful inside and out. My fiancé and I’s 5th year anniversary is tomorrow so we decided to celebrate tonight. This was our first time going to Good Fellos. The food was absolutely delicious from the appetizer to the entrée too the dessert. Told my fiancé I want to come back for our Christmas Dinner ♥️
-
October 2023 by Tom DAiuto
Great first experience, thought the brick oven pizza was the attraction and boy it sure was good, Then we noticed all the other dishes coming out, each one looked better than the last! Service was a bit slow, but the drinks kept our patients. Can't wait to go back!
