-
March 2024 by mark jutton
Had apple fritter and my first grape pie. Would recommend to all. Very good. MJ will come back when the weather gets better. ( Feb)
-
November 2023 by Viesha Z.
bought a peach pie from them at the Syracuse mkt. the pie was under cooked and tasteless, but it was only 7. so next time I will try another flavor to see if there is some improvement. if not, wont be buying again..........
-
October 2023 by Bob Citizen
Good pies.
-
October 2023 by Chris Hamilton
Wonderful place to stop every fall for donuts and pie!
-
October 2023 by Tylere Weaver
Always a great place to pick up something tasty.
-
October 2023 by Roxanne Monteleone
I always enjoy going to Colby's. You can smell the baked goods when you walk through the door. The baked goods are delicious. Their pumpkin bread is the best I have had. Nice clean establishment. Great place for pies, donuts, ice cream, bread, and other baked goods.
-
October 2023 by Kevin Whitman
The grape pies sold at the Naples Grape Festival by Colby’s was the worst filling AND crust I’ve ever had — hands down. I highly suggest throwing away the recipe and starting over. Similarly, the pulled pork was very dry and the barbecue sauce barely helped the sandwiches become edible. Overall wasted $90 plus embarrassment from the people I gifted the pies to. Never again!
-
October 2023 by Million Dollar MindX
? Grape pie was very disappointing. The cinnamon overpowered the taste of everything. And the grape filling was like a thick gel (possibly too much cornstarch or something? You would never know it was a grape pie! Customer service is always good though
-
October 2023 by Ian Laird
Good desserts, service and place is fine but not standout - ice cream is way more expensive than other local non-chain joints of similar quality.Not bad, just an average, nice spot.
-
October 2023 by Margaret Secor
Great pies donuts and baked goods! Next time ice cream!
-
September 2023 by Vee Chlebove
Great peanut butter sundae with better brownie batter ice cream. And 6 homemade donuts to go! Great option on a rainy weekend.
-
September 2023 by Wayne Lee
Excellent service by a young man and young woman today. Very personable and friendly!
-
September 2023 by Brenda Richey
Colbys is a slice of heaven! They have an amazing array of fresh ones daily at reasonable rates and twofer sales! Their ice cream is delightful. They also make up home coked meals for one or two that are delicious ?. Colbys also sets up a fun free Halloween interactive display on their large outdoor deck that is fun for all ages and not too scary. They often sell pumpkins , flowers, and other fresh products from time to time. The staff are always upbeat, positive, professional, and highly efficient. It is a lovely honey experience and beautiful family run business in Rush NY. 2 ?? up and a "10" all the way! Stop by as often as you can. You will be happy you did ?
-
August 2023 by Michael N.
This was our first trip to Colby's and it went like this...First off there's plenty of parking and easy entrance...The shop is smallish but very clean and quant like the days of old...There's a lot of ice-cream choices and they all looked so good it was hard to decide on just one...We both had a sundae's, mine was rocky road with strawberries, hot fudge, nut's and whipped cream...My wife had a brown butter bourbon truffle with hot fudge and whipped cream...Both were amazingly tasty...The damage with tip and tax was $16.00, not bad for these giant sundaes...We enjoyed eating our treats on the outside deck overlooking a field of greenery complete with a gentle breeze...It was a very nice experience and we'll be back soon...Give them a try and enjoy a nice visit...
-
August 2023 by Ilona Remenicky
Pies AND ice cream!! Lots of delicious treats and to go dinners available.
