Liquor Stores near Port Jefferson, NY

29 locations found near Port Jefferson

“Great wine shop, everyone is warm and friendly ? Lisa was so welcoming and helpful, she really took the time to listen and find the right product for me. I appreciate the kindness and will definitely be back”

4.3 Superb55 Reviews

“Came here last minute before they closed last night and the owner made the experience 10/10. Super nice guy, very helpful and also funny. I live in Bay Shore but I’ll definitely be back again when I’m in the area. Best liquor store around!”

5 Superb52 Reviews

“Nice relaxed atmosphere with a big selection of cigars, pipes and hookahs, plus some beverages and lotto as well. The owner is cool too, even has a big couch with a TV if you want to chill and smoke a cigar. Would recommend for all your smoking needs.”

4.9 Superb24 Reviews

“Great selection, prices are more than reasonable/competitive and the owners are just great friendly people. It's become my new place to stop AND they offer free local delivery, which I love!”

5 Superb13 Reviews

“Have been buying from Russ for a long time and he never ceases to amaze with his vast knowledge of all the collections and vintages from hard liquor to wines… always a pleasure talking shop with him … he is truly a gentlemen and a scholar … there are many good people in business but his customer service is bar none”

4.7 Superb92 Reviews

“I love this place!!! They have everything. Store has changed a lot in the past year for the best looks amazing and have a huge selection to chose from, even items you won’t find anywhere else. I recommend Figaris to anyone and everyone. Staff is super friendly and help Erica, Nick, and Peter are amazing!!!”

4.7 Superb98 Reviews

“The best liquor store I’ve been to on LI by far. It’s a really clean and cozy store design, and everything is organized neatly so you can find exactly what you’re looking for. The best part of this liquor store is the owners. The knowledge they have on the products they sell is why I come back here. Every time I come I ask for their recommendations on a new bottle to try and it has always been amazing. There’s nothing worse than getting a bad bottle of booze, I shop here with confidence knowing I’m getting good liquor at good prices.”

5 Superb36 Reviews

“Love this little store. They have great prices and a nice selection. The owner is so nice (he always carries out the box to my car) and his staff (who I think might be family) are super nice. Welcome to the neighborhood!”

5 Superb31 Reviews

“Absolutely the best liquor store around, since moving to sound beach I tried the rest when I moved in and this is the only one I came back to.

Nicest staff, always straight up in with pricing being labeled on each bottle, never had an issue! Barbara is a gem of a person and has given me wonderful experiences each time I need help.

In regard to a previous review I saw: Imagine giving a store a bad review because they wouldn’t spot you a couple bucks; SAD.”

4.8 Superb72 Reviews

“Here is the only store in Suffolk area where I can find reasonably priced Yamazaki Whiskey. The price is unbelievable among bricks and mortar. The owner is a very nice person. If you like whiskey, you will not be disappointed.”

4.7 Superb34 Reviews

“I love this Bevy. They have the best selection on the entire Island. Bruce, George and Mikey are complete gentlemen and make sure the store is a friendly and safe place to shop. I would recommend their selection of Polish beers!”

4.8 Superb64 Reviews

“It's a very easy shopping experience. The guys are friendly and helpful, the prices are more than fair (my Dad actually thought liquor stores made bank... not really), and they never once attempted an upsell. They care about their customers and even if it seems counter-intuitive encourage both responsible drinking and spending. If you needed a go-to Liquor store, I'd strongly recommend this one.”

4.9 Superb47 Reviews

“Outstanding selection, price, and service. Online orders are great they’re quick to fill the order and very responsive when it comes to ordering custom engravings. 10/10 would recommend”

4.6 Superb136 Reviews

“I ordered a case of a specific port wine to be delivered to a friend in Maryland. The service I received could not have been better. I highly recommend this store.”

4.7 Superb62 Reviews

“The owner was so accommodating. He ordered my favorite rum from Guyana, El Dorado - 15 years old. I also got good prices on the staple Don Julio and a case of wine. Great service and great prices. Check them out.”

5 Superb7 Reviews

“Looking for a particular Tequila drink in a can. Nobody else had it! Good selection of wine & liquor. Prices seemed reasonable. Staff friendly and helpful. Plenty of parking.”

5 Superb12 Reviews

“Although I do not drink alcohol, I do work as a promo model and serve alcohol in liquor stores across the Island. I had the pleasure of working here and must say " WOW!" The store is huge, beautiful, kept very clean, has a huge selection, and has many repeat customers. The owners work hard at cleaning the store, stocking the shelves, and making sure that they help the customers select the correct product for their event. Michelle was kind, knowledgeable, friendly, helpful, and had great customer service skills. The customers were a delight and I got to share many laughs throughout the day. I highly recommend stopping by JM for all of your alcohol needs. Remember to drink responsibly.”

4.7 Superb25 Reviews

“Always greeted by friendly staff behind the counter. Great selection across the store. Carries good variety and the prices are really good. They bring in new items but also keep bestsellers in stock!”

4.8 Superb45 Reviews

“Went there for the first time the other day, everyone went out of their way to provide good customer service and they have a great selection. They have a high rating for good reason. Go and give them your business.”

4.9 Superb46 Reviews

“I had the pleasure to work in this store to do tastings of wine and spirits! The owner and his family are so nice. They are very helpful to all their customers!”

4.8 Superb22 Reviews

“Great selection and competitive prices. The staff are there to help if you want to purchase unfamiliar beverages or mixers. Parking out front for a short walk with other small shops for food and such.”

4.8 Superb49 Reviews

“Great selection and great staff. Whether you want good bourbon, low calorie wine, sake, or the single serve Beatbox cartons they keep in the fridge for when you feel like a bum, they have it all.”

4.6 Superb36 Reviews

“As soon as we walked through the door we were assisted with finding several bottles. The manager saw that my wife was buying a bottle of Hampton Water and asked if she was a Bon Jovi fan. She professed her love for him and he came back from the office with a signed bottle. Love the over and above service.”

4.5 Superb155 Reviews

“Very honest owners here! Came in during a thunderstorm, and the woman at the register accidentally overcharged me by ~$80. I didn't notice at the time and they could have 100% gotten away with it without me ever noticing. As I'm getting in my car in the pouring rain, the lady at the register comes running through the rain without an umbrella to tell me about the overcharge and to give me a refund.Beyond the owners, it's of course a liquor store like any other. Clean with a lot of choices. 5 Stars”

4.9 Superb19 Reviews

“Nice liquor store with exceptional knowledge from the owner and the manager. Very friendly environment. Will definitely return to give this 5 star store my business.”

4.6 Superb43 Reviews

“This place is back to being my go to liquor store! Several years ago I started going somewhere else because it started going down hill (rude staff, not helpful, didn't seem like they were keeping up with appearance, etc.) , but I recently remembered this place is under new ownership the last few years, and I really like the location of the store, so I started going back again to give it another try. What a difference! The store is very clean and it's easy to find what you're looking for. The staff are always friendly and helpful! They offer good recommendations when you need them, but also know how to leave you alone when you're just browsing. A lot of people I know say they have good sales too. Personally I don't often pay attention to them because I usually already know what I want. There is a decent wine selection and the prices for everything are very fair.”

4.7 Superb39 Reviews

“Pope wine and liquor store is just plain awesome. I've been going here for years. The selection is huge, from the most popular brands to that obscure something you've always wanted to try they have it, or can get it. The loyalty club is great and we'll worth joining. The pricing here is better then any place around. They even deliver, not that I've tried that part, so I don't know the requirements or restrictions. It's totally worth the trip. Just try it you'll be happy toy did and you'll go back for sure.”

4.5 Superb104 Reviews

“My favorite liquor store! Asked for a specific brand of bourbon, and they had it in stock the next week at a very affordable price. I've been coming here for years! They're also on the drizly app, which is supper convenient.”

4.5 Superb77 Reviews