Gas Stations near Port Jefferson, NY

30 locations found near Port Jefferson
View Map

“I stopped in one day because my tired pressure was very low. They helped me fill it with air and offered to check it out for me. No was pressed for time. I offered them money for their help but they refused. Two days later, I stopped in again because my pressure was low again. It was clear they were busy, but they checked out my tire and plugged a nail hole. I was so thankful. I didn't have any cash on me and they said I could bring it to them later. I COMPLETELY FORGOT! When I finally remembered, they were so gracious. I felt terrible and they were telling me not to worry.”

4.6 Superb45 Reviews

“Excellent service! Had a crank sensor replaced almost a year ago and part failed again ( not their fault) they replaced it in 2 hours after dropping off fully covered under warranty.”

4.6 Superb43 Reviews

“I thought they ran out of regular gas so i went to let the owner know, turns out the pump I was using had been giving them issues that day. the gentleman came out and pumped my gas for me while asking about my day, when coming home from care taking for a family member with dementia the small kindness made a big difference in my night. thank you for your compassion.”

5 Superb17 Reviews

“I have been taking my car here for 6 years now. Brian Thomas and Little Brian are great at what they do and I've always been Fair with their prices. I have seen different makes and models of cars in The Bays doing various jobs. Pennies has always been trustworthy and reliable with my vehicles I highly recommend”

4.8 Superb20 Reviews

“I'm thrilled to leave a glowing review for North Country Gas Bait and Tackle! This local gem truly stands out – offering the convenience of self-service prices combined with the luxury of full-service treatment. The gas attendants' friendliness and willingness to go above and beyond make every visit a delightful experience. What a relief to find a station on Long Island that provides Ethanol Free Gas – a rare and much-appreciated offering. Kudos to North Country Gas for their outstanding service and commitment to customer satisfaction!”

5 Superb14 Reviews
4.6 Superb20 Reviews

“These guys are great,I highly recommend.I’m a new customer and they fixed 3 of my cars this month.We used to go to the shop on hallock and always felt taken.Services: Vehicle Inspection”

4.4 Superb33 Reviews

“Great neighborhood station with very friendly owners and workers. The gas prices are reasonable and it is also a great coffee and snack stop any time of the day.”

4.3 Superb36 Reviews

“Great place to get gas. Their prices are reasonable. Also, take advantage of Sam's Club store, an awesome place to shop, and I love their quality of meats, produce selection, and baking department.”

4.3 Superb35 Reviews

“Great place to get gas price is rite…. Most importantly the staff are very friendly and helpful. I recommend this place for gas and coffee other convenient on the go delicious snacks..”

4.2 Good45 Reviews

“There’s always a sense of worry when bringing your car to the mechanic but I have never felt that with Brian, he’s quick with his services and honest about his work. We bring all our cars to him and have never had problems. Not to mention that the gas prices are the best around!”

4.2 Good41 Reviews

“Wow, what a wonderful experience. Grabbed a Mountain Dew and had a wonderful conversation with the tall Turkish man with blue eyes. I cant remember if his name was Goku or Gorkem. 10/10!”

4.2 Good39 Reviews

“I dont want to write this review because its already getting very popular and busy. The best prices in town, no doubt. Same price cash or credit. Clean, and surprisingly easy to get in and out, considering the location. Thank you, owner of Conoco Hallock Ave. Your one of the best if not the best.”

4.2 Good39 Reviews

“If you go anywhere else your getting ripped off. I have been going to victor for 5yrs, I have never meet a more dedicated mechanic in my 50years. He is a professional that will get the job done right the first time. Always a phone call away to help you at anytime. The man works till 8pm and later for all your mechanical needs.”

5 Superb8 Reviews

“Good competitive prices around the area and deals change from time to time to keep attracting more customers for gas and convenience stores. Has basic midgrade and premium with a quick stop”

4.4 Superb19 Reviews

“Best lowest process in the area stay away from bp near exit 60RegularExit 60 am aoc/bp 3.09$Nesconset bp by Cumberland lvp ?2.95 for regularSave 14 cents a gallon. 1.40$ every 10 gallons adds up”

4.4 Superb19 Reviews

“Formerly OK Petroleum, this station is now Shell. They still have both Diesel and E85, in addition to the common 87, 89, & 92 octane offerings. The convenience store packs a lot in a small space. I've had the same experience as others, where the clerk is on the phone pretty much every time I come here. Unless you're using cash or shopping in the convenience store, you can just pay at the pump to avoid the feeling of being an interruption. Join Shell's Rewards program, too. Also, as fuel prices change frequently, I highly recommend using Gas Buddy to find the best price in the area. It's saved me hundreds of dollars on fuel, not including in-app discounts.”

4.2 Good36 Reviews

“As far as a gas station goes it usually has one of the best prices around. This location is just north of the long island expressway on Ocean Ave in Fayetteville.”

4.5 Superb14 Reviews

“New Bola Market very nice.Mobil Gas priced priced very competitive.Try and avoid 7am to 9am as Landscapers take over pumps filling cans, equipment, etc.Impossible to park and get into store to buy at the new Tim Hortons location.”

4.1 Good36 Reviews

“Full service is always nice. I come here often but last time I asked the attendant to put 20 dollars in my tank. I was charged 40. Besides that it’s a good station.”

4.6 Superb9 Reviews

“This was the only place I was able to get gas at a decent price late at night, although no one was working at the time the pumps were still on. Seemed a little sketchy but the flowers were a nice touch, lol. Just be careful….”

4.1 Good30 Reviews

“Open 24 hours now. New updated gas pumps. Under new management. Great Customer Service. Lowest gas prices in town for diesel, gas, and E-85. Easy Enter and Exit for TRUCKS and BUSES. Nice big store with lotto, soda, beer, cigarette, coffee, and ice cream. Highly recommend. Friendly staff. A+”

4.2 Good20 Reviews

“Very helpful guys here. Pulled a piece of metal out of my tire and patched the hole for me. A bit pricey, $15, and he tried to tell me that my tires should be up around 80psi, but he was helpful. (It's a Tacoma, and the sidewall says 44psi.)”

4.2 Good19 Reviews

“I went in for gas and decided to get a soda but they didn't have what I was looking for so the clerk wrote it down and said he would let them know to order it. I thought that was really nice”

4 Good48 Reviews