Thrift Stores near Port Jefferson Station, NY

13 locations found near Port Jefferson Station

“Local hidden treasure! The employees are warm, helpful and hilarious. Shopping and a show! You’ll find old and new items of every category for reasonable prices. There is something for everyone. I can’t wait to go back.”

4.3 Superb32 Reviews

“Dropped off clothing and blankets and bedding. Friendly service. I didn't get to go inside but it looks like they offer a lot. Glad to see things go to where they can help”

4 Good12 Reviews

“The two guys who were working there when I went were so nice. The atmosphere was well organized. Vintage antiques from 60s-2000s. Also some international finds. A little pricey but overall great experience.”

4.9 Superb111 Reviews

“One of the best antique/thrift stores I’ve ever been too!! I’m from the city (NY) and I’ve never seen such a beautiful variety of trinkets, clothing, vintage DVDS and more! My favorite was finding the most unique and exquisite “my precious moments” figurines. To describe what this meant to my childhood and my heart & soul would take too many words. Joel, the owner is as sweet as he is kind and generous. Instant connection and instant fun.
Come check this place out for all your pre-loved but still lovable condition items!
And
Thank you for the salad Joel! ;) Hope to be back very soon!”

4.6 Superb88 Reviews

“Where's the entrance? I'll tell you where! It is located on the left side of the building with a blue awning over the entrance that's where As for handicap friendly NOPE. You can not go through this entire store without some large road blocks in their isles. Their merch was meh but went day b4 mothers day and lots of customers were picking up their previous purchases. I sure this place has a very large turn over of stuff.”

4.3 Superb132 Reviews

“Best thrift store I've been in. The place is small but Everytime I've gone in there, I've found amazing deals. The owner is very friendly as well. I plan to be a regular here.”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“It is super good, they sell the clothes by the pound, the pound costs $3 dollars, the place is small but there are clothes in very good condition and new, among other things, such as shoes, bags, etc., I highly recommend it.”

3 Average4 Reviews

“This place is selling very expensive things, and it is supposed to be a place to help the community. We are going through times of an economy that is not good, so one seeks help buying used things, but they often have them at store prices. .”

3.5 Good10 Reviews

“Finally, a savers who fairly prices their stuff and doesn’t sift through all the good brands. Generally a good place to go for thrifting. Unfortunately though their men’s items are way more expensive than the women’s items. Seems unfair. 4/5 stars.”

3.7 Good122 Reviews

“This thrift store has a lot of cool stuff and the prices are really reasonable and if you go on Wednesdays, they have their big sale six color tickets that are 50% off. I picked up some really great deals, I’ll definitely be back.”

3 Average174 Reviews

“I recently stopped by Island Thrift in Medford and was genuinely impressed by the entire experience. It is rare to find a thrift store that is kept this clean and organized; the layout made it incredibly easy to browse without feeling overwhelmed, and the attention to tidiness really speaks to the management's standards. Beyond the environment, the prices were fantastic—definitely some of the best value I’ve seen in the area.
What really set this visit apart, however, was the customer service. The staff wasn't just professional; they were warm, polite, and genuinely friendly, making me feel welcome the moment I walked through the door. It’s a pleasure to support a business that treats its customers so well. I will absolutely be returning soon to see what other treasures I can find!”

2.8 Average138 Reviews