Convenience Stores near Otisville, NY

23 locations found near Otisville

“Having been in a wheelchair for the last few months from an accident, Jose, the Mgr comes out and pumps my gas, and when I come in the store with my walker, he or another employee will bring my coffee out to my car for me. I loved the previous Mgr and had doubts on Jose, but this experience has shown me that their customer service skills extend above and beyond. AWESOME job Stewart's!!!”

4.1 Good45 Reviews

“If your from NYC you know this place is a gem! Living upstate you don’t find many of these. The owners are amazing! Stop by for some coffee, a bagel or sandwich you won’t be disappointed!”

5 Superb6 Reviews

“The staff is exceptionally hard working. Especially the gentleman with glasses on the night shift, he is always fast and efficient while always managing to be certious”

3.9 Good75 Reviews

“I used to be committed to the deli next door till they started cutting everything: my last few sandwiches had no more than 6 slices of meat. I took my business here and it was well worth it! Full sandwiches, nice service, no card fee. I'm done with that quick start nonsense...”

4.4 Superb38 Reviews

“Great deli great family owed very kind people will always help even when your a little short on cash the say just pay me next time you come in it’s great feels good to have trust with the community”

4.3 Superb28 Reviews

“What can I say about a gas stationthere is gas said that you could buy for your car is a little market where you could buy yourself little snacks and drinks and then you go on your Merry”

4.1 Good54 Reviews

“It's a gas station ⛽ nothing I like more than paying super high gas prices thanks to Joe Biden. Pumps even have stickers with him pointing out the price and saying I did this. Very accurate statement. But it looks like someone who voted for this idiot tried to take it off, no worries though, I put another one ????”

3.9 Good33 Reviews

“It won't let me edit my first review, but it's letting me leave another one. So: Perhaps management saw my first review where I said the guys were not friendly or helpful because now they are the opposite - always very nice, greating hello and goodbye, attentive, not on their phones. That's nice, and I don't want to say they overdo it, but maybe a little lol. Otherwise, still the best collection of only junk food in town, and better drink selection than across the street. The Dunkin - it actually seems to be better than your average Dunkin.”

3.8 Good68 Reviews

“Great job to the new owners they have made this place into a better environment and the food selection is amazing I love getting my subs from here they are always amazing and fresh thank you to the new owner for putting new life into this place!!”

3.9 Good31 Reviews

“We ordered fruit cocktails? they were well prepare. It had pineapple, mango, papaya, pepino, melon, uvas, & fresas topped with chamoy & Tajin. (No jicama here) it also had a Bandera, traditional Mexican candy.The chicharrón preparado was delicious too.Came with pickle cueritos, cabbage, sliced tomato, salsa valentina, sour cream, and grated cheese. Delicious ?Lastly, my elote which to my taste was a little dry, but not bad in flavor.As I waited for my order I noticed a nice selection of Mexican products, they also offer a vast variety of heros. The place is clean & the overall ambiance is great!!!”

4.6 Superb11 Reviews

“I'm a disabled woman who cannot walk and the guys here take very good care of me. I come in and O'Neal and Josh come outside and fill my truck up for me very much appreciated.”

4 Good40 Reviews

“They have the cheapest gas on Dolsen Ave.! Also inside they have a huge selection of drinks, food, snacks and the service is great. They are always able to address any questions you have on the products they sell behind the counter as well as what is popular and bestselling. The gas prices make it worth it!!”

3.8 Good21 Reviews

“Friendly staff very good prices they make amazing sandwiches you can get all your stuff here except for gas but it’s still a good feeling when u have gone to a store for so many years that they treat you like family”

4.8 Superb10 Reviews

“Owner is great. Staff is great all around, helpful and friendly. Hard working team of people. I come here almost daily because the location is so convenient and the staff so friendly.”

3.7 Good44 Reviews

“They have a great selection of local produce. The ribeye hamburger meat that they sell is well worth the price! The house made sausages and brats are great! Good bread and pastry from the bakery. Staff is always friendly.”

3.5 Good48 Reviews

“Its a good spot in the middle of nowhere if you get lucky to get Sam you will have everything done right from breakfast to lunch to other. Sam is definetly the backbone of this deli and she is one of the most friendly and hard working people there”

3.5 Good33 Reviews

“this place has some delicious sandwiches, the staff are kind and engaging, and anyone rating gas stations on their bathrooms should get a life. who the hell travels to make a gas station bathroom the center of a review? if u want to have a bathroom up to your standard 24/7, stay home!”

3.4 Good33 Reviews

“Absolutely delicious homemade chicken curry.I haven’t had anything so culturally rich ever… this far from NYC.Go in at lunch and you’ll see for yourself. I’m sorry I have no picture. And I was going to get the beef stew….. whew.”

3.7 Good20 Reviews

“This gas station is a perfect quick stop for food, snacks or gas and many other quick items you might need. I stopped here to grab some gas because it was close by the house. There has never been a lie or any kid of wait to get gas and I appreciate that. Sometimes you just want to run in and out real quick and get home.I havent tried any food yet, but I see they have a bunch of choices. I may get something one of these days just to see if its good.”

3.8 Good18 Reviews

“Excellent location on the corner of two main streets in Middletown (East Main St. & Carpenter Ave.). This is the cheapest gas in Middletown (and surrounding areas all the way to Monroe) 9 times out of 10, especially if you're using their SmartPay perks card! The employees at this location are nice and helpful and get you in and out quickly. They keep the store very clean and stocked, inside and out. There are three entrances and exits to the road so you are not waiting in line when you're leaving.. And I can't stress enough how good the smart pay perks card is to have. You get $.10 off a gallon every single time no matter if you have unleaded or diesel or anything in between. There is an app to go with the card so you don't need the card itself. You pay for the gas on your app without even stepping foot into the store or swiping a card. The app tracks everything you buy in store or at the pump and it gives you tons of perks rewards. And sometimes it gives you free stuff for no reason. And they usually expire in like one month. Even without the smartpay card, Their coffee is already super cheap $.99 for any size. Their food is better than going to Dunkin, I think and probably cheaper.. In store, they have a lot of offers all the time like buy something specific get something else for free or at a cheaper price (soda and candy, water and gum, etc...) I am a huge fan of Cumberland Farms now. I say "now" because I used to HATE them A few years back before all the recent changes.. but they have really stepped their game up and it shows. Team Cumbys!! Lol”

3 Average49 Reviews

“Despite the frigid temperatures and the bathroom being located around the side of the bldg, I was pleasantly surprised to find they have heat in the bathroom and it's kept on full blast. Thank you.”

2.9 Average21 Reviews