Thrift Stores near New Windsor, NY

“What an amount of product in a small space! Gianni was great to work with and had a great knowledge of what he had. I got a few cool collectibles that I haven't seen anywhere else.I'll definitely be back!”

“Went here today Thursday March 7th 2024 to drop off 2 bags of donation clothes because i did some "spring cleaning" and cleaned out my closet. Easy donation process where one just puts them in the blue bins that are inside. Unlike others that have posted here, 3 people offered to help carry the bags inside for us- so maybe one just encountered others on a bad day. lots of parking is available in the parking lot, as it shares with a shopping center and other stores. Easy donation dropoff process, and there is a tax form that you can fill out if one needs. Then, looked around the clothing section because i wanted a sweater for work, and to look. found some cute stuff. as they say, Another person's trash is someone else's treasure! and it is relatively new stuff that is 6.00 each, and colors are discounted too! (believe this week was red!) I don't normally shop in thrift stores, but this is an excellent deal! Also to note that all of the clothes that are out on the sales floor, look really clean with no rips or imperfections. Also like how they have a fitting room so that one can try things on like i did! Besides clothes, they also have a home section, bags, accesseries, and media like books and dvds. They also have mens clothes and kids clothes, but alot more choices in the womens section. Definetely will be back next time for more donations, and to check the store out maybe more! Also, cashier was very nice and friendly, paid $36.00 for 6 items. They don't charge for using a credit card, and paid via that. Also duly note: the reciept says Vails Gate, NY, and this says New Windsor. It's the same location, looks like it's on the borderline of both.”

“The cleanest thrift store I’ve ever been too, and I’ve probably been to hundreds at this point . The home now turned thrift is very well organized, there isn’t just stuff everywhere. 3 floors plus the basement . Highly recommended!”

“Okay slay, this place has rejuvinated my soul. I never thought I'd find anything other than clothes at a thrift store and how wrong I was, not only did I find a copy of the grinch (2018), where Tyler the creator worked on the soundtrack, but I also found this really cute guinea pig looking fellow. Sometimes I can hear it skittering and panting at night. It walks to the window. It yearns.The employee's were very friendly and helpful!Yeehaw!I hope you check out this store, the hog yearns eternally.”

“I stopped by here in October while on business. It's a cute little shop and the 2 ladies are lovely. Bought some salt and pepper shakers to add to my husbands collection. It's small and you have to dig, but the have a little bit of everything. The two ladies alone are worth the trip. This is old school care and customer service. Would go again and again if I am ever in Fishkil.”

“Such a great little place, with lots of little treasures to find. You can't beat the prices and all of it goes to help the kitties there in the store that are available to adopt, and they also help a bunch of local colonies. Such a hidden gem for you thrifters out there.”

“So I read a few reviews before posting and I have to say that the bad ones seems to be ppl that cant be pleased.I have an ebay store as well but covid did a number on my business. This guy took a look at some of my things and gave me fair pricing overall.Extremely friendly and professional.And come on ppl he has a sweet little dog in his store. Dog ppl are good ppl lol.Great store and merchandise as well btw”

“I'm usually pretty bored by ReStores; it's all furniture and old appliances. This one is a little different! They have a pretty cool selection up front of weird CDs which usually keeps me busy for the whole time my fiancee is wandering around looking at her genre of stuff. I usually walk out with a handful of things for under $5, which is all it takes to make me happy.”

“Dropping off my donations of electronics, and clothing, and odds and ends. So easy to do. I just drove up to the donations door and barely had myself out of the vehicle when Michael came to assist. He brought a shopping cart and before you know it, not two minutes, went by when everything was out of the vehicle. Michael was a real angel”