Jewelry Stores in New Paltz, NY

8 locations found near New Paltz
View Map

“Stopped in for a non traditional engagement ring and left with a beautiful London Blue Topaz with diamonds plus our wedding bands! The staff was exceptionally informative and made this experience amazing!! Highly recommend visiting their store ❤️”

4.9 Superb115 Reviews

“I have been shopping here for many years and their merchandise is wonderful, artsy, unique and hand crafted. And their customer service is second to none. I couldn't get to the shop so I ordered something online, it arrived missing a piece. I notified them, the owner called me, apologized, asked me if I would prefer a replacement or credit and immediately sent me the correct item with all the pieces and a check for my return postage. So amazing in these time of ordering something from who knows where and struggling to find a human being to speak to if you have a problem.”

4.9 Superb20 Reviews

“A wonderful shop, full with a variety of unique, magical products and gifts. Owner Karen is very genuine, and will eagerly help you find the right item you need. Highly recommend!”

5 Superb12 Reviews

“What a little gem of a place and the sweetest owner! My partner and I were visiting New Paltz and ended our trip making candles with Ingrid. She has so many amazing scents to choose from and beautiful jars and candle toppings and more! The energy in the store is so inviting and cozy. Our candles came out absolutely gorgeous and smell INCREDIBLE! Thank you so much for such a fun ending to our magical weekend making our engagment scent candles and thank you so much for the little gift that was so thoughtful! Dana & Andrew”

4.9 Superb12 Reviews

“This is a GREAT STORE ! They had Everything I Wanted ! The girl behind,the counter,was a Sweetheart...They gave me a,Beautiful,carry out bag...Don't Leave New Paltz,without visiting this Vintage Store...I Loved It ! I was in my,Hippie Glory ! Thank you !”

4.6 Superb31 Reviews

“The perfect place to find the best, most unique and fitting gift. I've loved this store forever. Don't look any further. If you need a gift- for anyone- anyone- it is in this store. And to top it off they beautifully wrap for you. It's always special at Handmade. Treat yourself to something too. Jewelry, pottery, glassware, wooden items, clothing... So many great possibilities.”

5 Superb8 Reviews

“The best selection of jewelry in town at a wide range of prices. You can get NICE earrings for $25, or a gorgeous ring, or find fine gem earrings and necklaces that are more high-end gifts, plus pottery and pretty things. Upstairs there are toy collectibles too.”

5 Superb6 Reviews

“Cutest place in New Paltz to buy in- style clothes and jewelry pieces . I have purchased numerous articles of clothing as well as jewelry from them and they are still in great quality after years of being worn. The owner is very sweet as well! Not sure what the negative reviews are about? She is very kind and helpful and we always have a good conversation .”

4 Good4 Reviews