Grocery Stores in New Hyde Park, NY

9 locations found near New Hyde Park
View Map

“After seeing a couple of posts on Instagram, we decided to check out Sansone Market in Garden City Park. While it's not a huge space it is loaded with lots of Italian products. Everything from packages of sweets to canned goods to fresh cheese and meat to pizzas. The back of the store has a long deli counter that has a bunch of made to order sandwiches to choose from along with some premade food. There is even a cheese counter with tons of options. Their freezer section includes items like pizza, ravioli and even bake your own sfogliatelle. Then you come upon the pizza counter. Fresh made 12" pizza is available Wednesday through Sunday. We brought a Marinara pizza home, the crust was lovely and the sauce had a great freshness to it. They also had a bunch of items premade that we couldn't pass up on. The Picante Stromboli was divine. Filled with grilled chicken, broccoli rabe and spicy peppers. It was so delicious. The zucchini pie was sort of a frittata and it was heavenly. They also offer coffee and a small display of baked items like cookies and cannoli. The front of the store has some tables where you can enjoy your purchases if you wish. Sansone Market is a little slice of Italy right on Jericho Turnpike.”

4.3 Superb60 Reviews

“I walked into the store when they first opened their doors and had the pleasure of meeting Dhira, the new store owner! So helpful and knowledgeable about products and totally not a pushy salesman! Have met two other young men that work there and they too were so helpful and knowledgeable! The thing I find most impressive is that they always remember me when I walk in and I have always been greeted with a smile upon my entry! Loyal customer forever! Thank you! ?”

5 Superb20 Reviews

“Clean and modern, but struggled to find shredded provolone, only a mix with mozzarella was available. Deli and bakery sections at Stop & Shop are hidden gems, adding a delightful touch to shopping trips. Despite a chaotic parking lot, the store is well-stocked with everything at reasonable prices.”

3.9 Good61 Reviews

“Old world beautiful Polish deli. Very fresh hot dogs and kielbasa. Fresh bread delivered daily. And the frozen perogies are good. These are the items we buy there in bulk every few months and they freeze very well. Hey, its the last surviving Polish deli in a very Polish area. Better get there soon.”

4.9 Superb10 Reviews

“Only grocery store in the area open 24 hrs. I feel Shop Rite is still the best value for the dollar compared to other chain stores. The NHP store is stocked well but like every where right now it's spotty. Overnight is like having the store to yourself but, they only have 1 register open, get stuck behind me you'll be there a while...shop from home using the app is a great time saver.”

3.4 Good68 Reviews

“I like having this as a smaller local supermarket. They prices are good and the store and bathroom are clean.Good produce, bakery goods and other items. I would like if they had deli and bakery counters. The bakery has self serve glass displays but anything I've tried is yummy.I love their...I don't know what they call that section but it has gadgets, clothes, seasonal stuff like decorations and related cookies candies. They have some internatinal foods. Their plant and fresh flower section is nice and really affordable.Staff interaction is EH, some seem annoyed or maybe tired with the exception of one or two familiar faces who always recognize me, as well.My only complaint: I don't mind using the app but there should be an option to send the receipt to the app. I hate paper (I lose everything all the time), it's a waste and if you make a return without the receipt you only get a store credit.”

3.2 Average53 Reviews

“I like this place that there’s no live slaughter animal section :) it feels a lot more peaceful here , and it feels like the fusion of Indian and Chinese culture kind of supermarket :)”

3 Average26 Reviews

Related Categories