Olde Wicker Mill offers a wide variety of interesting and unique items, including clothes, jewelry, greeting cards, and indoor/outdoor ornaments. The store is known for its good selection of jewelry, Vera Bradley bags, and gifts suitable for family and friends, especially during holiday seasons like Christmas. Customers appreciate the helpful and kind staff who assist with specific shopping needs, such as finding baptism outfits or Pandora pieces. While many find the store’s items pretty and entertaining, some mention that prices can be a bit high and note the absence of public restroom facilities. Overall, Olde Wicker Mill is a popular spot for finding distinctive gifts and household items.