Jewelry Stores near Mount Sinai, NY

25 locations found near Mount Sinai
View Map

“What a amazing establishment! I can’t express how wonderful the women at this store are. Not only do they do incredible work on your jewelry but are also the kindest and most generous women. When I told Laura that I just got engaged but the ring didn’t fit right she fixed it for me right away. I can’t say enough about how amazing their customer service is. I recommend them to everyone! They can meet all of your jewelry needs(repairs or new items) and in a timely manner and at reasonable prices! Please go and see them. I know I will be back and will definitely be getting our wedding bands made here! Thank you for everything Laura you made this special time in my life even better and I’m forever greatful for that!”

5 Superb41 Reviews

“The prices were respectable and frankly I can't complain about them. The service was STELLAR, and almost seemed free if you consider the usual retail prices for silver.TLDR: They shortened a chain to my perfect length, made a bracelet from the spare links, and made a new bail for my pendant, making no fuss about any of it whatsoever throughout the whole process. And I can't emphasize enough how reasonable their prices are if you need any work done.Steve was beyond helpful. (I'm pretty sure Amanda) was lovely and helped me find the perfect chain, but it was way longer than I wanted. Not only did Steve shorten the chain for me, they are also turning the spare length into a bracelet! Steve even measured the chain on me to make sure that the length I wanted matched the length I asked for. On top of that, I have a pendant that's incredibly important that I wanted to put on one of their chains, but the bail was beaten to heck and way too small. They added a new, sturdy bail and attached it for me.All in all, two sterling silver chains, a bail, shortening a chain, and putting a rush on all of it only cost me a couple hundred. STELLAR service, beautiful people, and I intend to go there for ALL of my jewelry needs because of those two. (Not just to purchase, but also maintenance and miscellaneous work)”

4.9 Superb66 Reviews

“Dominique and Vinny were very helpful, friendly and also clear with how they paid for jewelry. I thought Gem Pawnbrokers was fair and honest which is hard to find when selling jewelry.”

4.8 Superb101 Reviews

“Fantastic store! Something for everyone! Lily is always so helpful and goes above and beyond to make sure every gift is perfect! She always has such thoughtful ideas and takes time to wrap everything beautifully.”

5 Superb31 Reviews

“We just purchased our wedding bands from Dave and had a very pleasant experience!! He was able to order us exactly what we pictured and communicated well throughout the whole process. Highly recommend!”

4.9 Superb29 Reviews

“John is a fantastic guy who has been nothing but honest with me from day one. I trust him completely to give me the right information and a very fair price for anything he buys for me. I have nothing but good things to say about him. Plus, he's a dog person, I always trust dog people.”

4.6 Superb73 Reviews

“Great Antique store. There is different vendors inside with tons of Antiques and Collectibles, with toys and household things. Prices vary. But a kool place to get a few things or just browse.”

4.8 Superb26 Reviews

“Every time I come here they always take the best care of me! Especially Jessie and Theresa! Jessie helped get my watch resized in no time and cleaned my jewelry. She was so nice and took such great care of me. Highly recommend Rocky Point Jewelers!”

4.7 Superb27 Reviews

“Exceptional Experience at Jared Jewelers, Lake Grove, NYI recently had the pleasure of visiting Jared Jewelers in Lake Grove, New York, and I must say, the experience was nothing short of extraordinary. My fiancé and I were on the lookout for a unique wedding ring that would stand as an enduring emblem of our love, and we were not disappointed.Our consultant, Gloria, was a key highlight of our visit. Her customer service skills were outstanding, and her knowledge of the craft was impressively vast. Gloria was genuinely interested in our vision and worked tirelessly to help us bring it to life. She was patient, answered all our questions and shared invaluable advice that guided us through the process.The result of her dedication was a custom-made wedding ring that took our breath away. It is, without a doubt, the most beautiful piece of jewelry we have ever seen. Every detail was meticulously crafted, and you could see the love and effort that went into its creation. This ring is not just a piece of jewelry, but a work of art that we will cherish forever.Our experience at Jared Jewelers was beyond satisfactory. We are immensely grateful to Gloria for her exceptional service and for helping us create a symbol of our love that we will treasure for a lifetime. We highly recommend Jared Jewelers in Lake Grove, New York, for anyone in search of high-quality, custom-made jewelry. Their professionalism, quality of work, and dedication to customer satisfaction are truly commendable.”

4.5 Superb62 Reviews

“Banter Jewelry has a variety of jewelry. Gold and silver. I have bought several pieces of jewelry from them. You can purchase warranty on jewelry which I do recommend. A lot of there prices are delicate.”

4.7 Superb24 Reviews

“Just took my 10 year old daughter to get her ears pierced for the first time. She was very nervous but they made her feel so comfortable and made it overall such a special experience. The store itself is beautiful and the women who work there are so kind. Highly recommend for anyone looking to get their child's ears pierced. Will absolutely return for future jewelry purchases.”

5 Superb12 Reviews

“Excellent teachers in a laid-back atmosphere, that encourages creativity and the development of enhanced skills in both Stainglass and Mosaic work. An absolutely wonderful owner run art experience. One of the few remaining on all of Long Island. I drive out from Long Beach, New York regularly to do my work there and to obtain materials.”

4.8 Superb10 Reviews

“This family owned business has been my go to place for jewelry purchases, repairs and to sell no longer wanted items for over 30 years. They take the time needed to educate you thoroughly to ensure you make informed purchase decisions. I highly recommend this business.”

4.5 Superb21 Reviews

“The owner is a sweetheart. I looked all over for special little gifts for my daughter’s bridal shower but couldn’t find what I wanted anywhere. I came into her shop and just fell in love with so many little unique gifts. It’s great to know when I need something special this will be my go to place.”

4.9 Superb8 Reviews

“This store has a lot of cute stuff❣️❣️ They have also a lot of accessary which is cute and reasonable price !! all of the objects were good in the price and pretty ?”

4.6 Superb9 Reviews

“Great place to buy or sell jewelry. Maria is amazing very professional and kind. I will definitely be back! I sold my custom engagement ring very fair on value. I bought a beautiful necklace also. Best experience Thanks so much! Definitely try this jeweler.”

4.4 Superb14 Reviews

“What more can I say about Chris and his jewelry. Chris is such a nice guy and great representation of a local business owner. His prices and selection are incredible. What a hidden gem. Don't leave Port jefferson without stopping in,even just to say hello. My wife and I are repeat customers 10 fold. Thank Chris. P.S. went in to say hi and left with a ring and necklace.”

5 Superb4 Reviews

“I can't say enough great things about The Jewelry Box! I needed my rings resized and cleaned, and saw the great reviews of this place. Trish is just wonderful and so easy to talk to, and she and M do fantastic work! My rings fit perfectly and are gorgeous. And they turned them around so fast I couldn't believe it! Thank you Trish and M for your amazing service! I have found my go-to place, and highly recommend them!”

4.4 Superb13 Reviews

“I cannot say enough good things about the customer service and guidance provided by these folks. They helped me take a diamond charm that my late mother had left me and turned it into a stunning ring. I never felt pressured to spend more, and immediately felt like I'd known them for years. A+”

4.3 Superb12 Reviews

“I was very impressed with the knowledgeable staff at Center Gold. Courtney was extremely helpful with some family pieces of jewelry that had to be resized and cleaned up. She took the time to explain and recommend options to me. I appreciate all the care they took and will definitely be back again!”

4.1 Good49 Reviews

“Just wanted to share a shopping experience and recommendation if your looking for Jewelry. I went into Jared near the mall. I have never been made to feel so uncomfortable in a store in my life. I was told there was nothing there to "meet my budget" and that I should think about "buying something else" for my MIL. I was treated like I had no business being in the store and they had no interest in me as soon as they found out I was not there to spend really big bucks. I left. We were going somewhere in St James and happened to see St James Jewelry Store. From the moment I entered I was treated professionally and everyone was friendly. I was shown a bunch of options in my budget and ultimately chose one. All while having a wonderful conversation with the staff. I truly felt like they was happy I was there shopping in there store. It was a warm and inviting experience. They even wrapped the gift I purchased. I would recommend them over any big box Jewelry store any day.”

4.3 Superb6 Reviews

“I don’t usually shop at the big name stores . I prefer more service and 1 on 1 experience. Not only was the sales rep terrific ! But Valerie the manager took care of my sizing and even price adjusted to an online sale . No questions asked . I will definitely coming back for that type of service ! Ty very much Valerie and team ! Great experience!”

4.1 Good20 Reviews

“The clothes are just amazing. The jewelry there are beautiful. The store has such a welcoming aura and an amazing smell. Although the clothes are pricey, the style of them make it up for the price. I definitely recommend.”

4 Good7 Reviews

“Dropped off clothing and blankets and bedding. Friendly service. I didn't get to go inside but it looks like they offer a lot. Glad to see things go to where they can help”

3.7 Good3 Reviews

“Sara was beyond helpful. She showed me multiple options, listened to my criteria, and was patient while I made my decision. She was very sweet and knowledgeable about the different stones and she helped me find the perfect pair of earrings, ring and necklace for me.”

3.8 Good36 Reviews