Grocery Stores in Montauk, NY

3 locations found near Montauk

“Small supermarket in Montauk, with friendly staff,
It's always amusing for a European when, as an almost 50-year-old, you have to show ID to buy a can of beer.”

4.2 Good111 Reviews

“Open late on a Sunday! Score!!

Lots of quality options for dry goods and condiments. Big butcher selection. Can't go wrong here.

I recommend”

4.3 Superb40 Reviews

“First time trying this place and so glad we did!Nice clean Market located right in the heart of town.Got sandwiches here for lunch one day and came back the next day for breakfast. Everything we ordered was great and not too long of a wait.$16 for 2 egg sandwiches is a little steep. $26 for and Italian Hero and ham and american on a roll and didn't even come with a pickle or a little container of potato or mac salad. Oh well, It is what it is. Food was great and we'll definitely be back.FYI this place makes a WAY better egg sandwich than the MTK Bake Shoppe and less of a wait.”

2.3 Poor13 Reviews