Liquor Stores near Middle Island, NY

30 locations found near Middle Island

“Excellent customer service from Ash!! I placed my first online order with the shop earlier this week early Tuesday afternoon. I was looking for a particular wine from the Azores and they were one of the few shops that had it. Ash took the time to reach out to me that same day to let me know there was a vintage variation and to ask me if it was ok to substitute. That was fantastic since I had asked for an overnight shipment as we were going to a wine tasting gathering on Friday with some of my WSET3 and WSET4 certified enthusiasts and colleagues on unique volcanic appellation wines and the Arinto was a perfect fit. The wine showed up Thursday, in perfect shape and I am very looking forward to trying it and letting everyone know where i picked it up! Thank you again Ash! I'll be back! Cheers!”

4.5 Superb46 Reviews

“Great prices, friendly staff! Wasn’t sure of what I was really looking for. I asked the guy for help and he suggested a nice wine that paired perfect with dinner!”

4.3 Superb44 Reviews

“Everyone who rated this place and said how great it is, is absolutely right! This store is located in the shops at East Wind and is truly the best place to go to find unique wines at excellent prices. Stacy helped me when I went in, and all of her selections were delicious. She was so knowledgeable about every wine in the place and told me some of her favorites, which I did buy, and I am so happy I did. If you want to find a special wine to take to friends or family, this holiday, I highly recommend going here. I brought a couple of the bottles to a recent holiday party, and everyone loved them! I will definitely go back to stock up on more, and look forward to learning more about their unique selections. They also have an email list for upcoming events that they host at the shop. I am so happy I went in and found this place, and I know you will be too!”

5 Superb51 Reviews

“Great spot I love all the local beers they got, so nice to have a spot they has all the Long Island flavors. Cans, bottles and on tap to fill the bottles, the people who run it are very friendly and informative. Bravo”

5 Superb25 Reviews

“Came here last minute before they closed last night and the owner made the experience 10/10. Super nice guy, very helpful and also funny. I live in Bay Shore but I’ll definitely be back again when I’m in the area. Best liquor store around!”

5 Superb52 Reviews

“Nice relaxed atmosphere with a big selection of cigars, pipes and hookahs, plus some beverages and lotto as well. The owner is cool too, even has a big couch with a TV if you want to chill and smoke a cigar. Would recommend for all your smoking needs.”

4.9 Superb24 Reviews

“Definitely the place to go!! If they don't have it they will get it!! Especially for the frequent neighborhood customer's "The Cat" Says Go here for your Drinks ? ???”

4.8 Superb33 Reviews

“Have been buying from Russ for a long time and he never ceases to amaze with his vast knowledge of all the collections and vintages from hard liquor to wines… always a pleasure talking shop with him … he is truly a gentlemen and a scholar … there are many good people in business but his customer service is bar none”

4.7 Superb92 Reviews

“Bansum Wine & Liquor is the best spirits store in the area. If you’re into store picks and limited releases, this is your store. Great staff, prices, and selection.”

4.7 Superb141 Reviews

“The best liquor store I’ve been to on LI by far. It’s a really clean and cozy store design, and everything is organized neatly so you can find exactly what you’re looking for. The best part of this liquor store is the owners. The knowledge they have on the products they sell is why I come back here. Every time I come I ask for their recommendations on a new bottle to try and it has always been amazing. There’s nothing worse than getting a bad bottle of booze, I shop here with confidence knowing I’m getting good liquor at good prices.”

5 Superb36 Reviews

“Love this little store. They have great prices and a nice selection. The owner is so nice (he always carries out the box to my car) and his staff (who I think might be family) are super nice. Welcome to the neighborhood!”

5 Superb31 Reviews

“The new owner is very friendly, and if you ask to get a certain type of beer in he will try and get it in. The selection is way better then before as is the cleanliness...Before it was like I was intruding in on the last owners living room or something haha”

4.7 Superb52 Reviews

“Absolutely the best liquor store around, since moving to sound beach I tried the rest when I moved in and this is the only one I came back to.

Nicest staff, always straight up in with pricing being labeled on each bottle, never had an issue! Barbara is a gem of a person and has given me wonderful experiences each time I need help.

In regard to a previous review I saw: Imagine giving a store a bad review because they wouldn’t spot you a couple bucks; SAD.”

4.8 Superb72 Reviews

“Here is the only store in Suffolk area where I can find reasonably priced Yamazaki Whiskey. The price is unbelievable among bricks and mortar. The owner is a very nice person. If you like whiskey, you will not be disappointed.”

4.7 Superb34 Reviews

“Lucky was awesome! I needed kegs at the last minute and he came through for me. I will definitely be back for all my beverage needs, they have a huge selection I can't find anywhere else”

4.7 Superb58 Reviews

“A LOT of variety with plenty of wines to choose from. From everyday favorites to high end dream-wines, you're sure to find something you'll enjoy. And the staff are very helpful with assisting in making a selection. Best wine store I've been in since... a long time. Don't let their size fool you! ?”

4.8 Superb59 Reviews

“I love this Bevy. They have the best selection on the entire Island. Bruce, George and Mikey are complete gentlemen and make sure the store is a friendly and safe place to shop. I would recommend their selection of Polish beers!”

4.8 Superb64 Reviews

“The owner was so accommodating. He ordered my favorite rum from Guyana, El Dorado - 15 years old. I also got good prices on the staple Don Julio and a case of wine. Great service and great prices. Check them out.”

5 Superb7 Reviews

“Nice people, great selection of brews foreign and domestic. Very helpful Ladies. Helped with 2 cases as I have limited mobility.I definitely will purchase again. Added bonus gasoline is pumped for you at no extra fee. Great spot in Wading River.”

4.9 Superb41 Reviews

“Best liquor store around and the nicest people work there, so if you want good prices and excellent help then go here, I can’t say good enough things about the store except I’d go out of my way to go to this liquor store!!!”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“I started coming to Swiftway shortly after turning 21 MANY years ago because it's close to where I was living. I moved away some years ago now but whenever I'm back in the area this is where I go for beer. Fantastic selection!”

4.6 Superb100 Reviews

“Always greeted by friendly staff behind the counter. Great selection across the store. Carries good variety and the prices are really good. They bring in new items but also keep bestsellers in stock!”

4.8 Superb45 Reviews

“This is an awesome shop. Great selection, excellent service, and reasonably priced. I use a cane and I have never had to ask for assistance; they immediately offered it. Astrid is especially wonderful! And they deliver!!7/2/23. I used their delivery service. It was easy, the delivery prices were reasonable, and I received it 20 minutes before they said I would! It’s a truly wonderful wine shop!”

4.6 Superb35 Reviews

“Great selection and competitive prices. The staff are there to help if you want to purchase unfamiliar beverages or mixers. Parking out front for a short walk with other small shops for food and such.”

4.8 Superb49 Reviews

“Very friendly owner, definitely has the cheapest prices in the area. I recommend all my friends and family here, large wine and spirit collection. Would definitely stop by if you're looking for a good deal on some naughty water 😉”

5 Superb12 Reviews

“Sweet, clean & neat neighborhood store! Staff always kind and patient. I always forget the wine I get my boss for Christmas & they help me figure it out? Great with suggestions too!”

5 Superb9 Reviews

“Friendly, courteous service. Fair prices and a wide and varied inventory. A knowledgeable staff. And, if you are a regular, the staff not only knows your name but, also, your beverage preferances.”

4.8 Superb24 Reviews

“Nice liquor store with exceptional knowledge from the owner and the manager. Very friendly environment. Will definitely return to give this 5 star store my business.”

4.6 Superb43 Reviews

“This place is back to being my go to liquor store! Several years ago I started going somewhere else because it started going down hill (rude staff, not helpful, didn't seem like they were keeping up with appearance, etc.) , but I recently remembered this place is under new ownership the last few years, and I really like the location of the store, so I started going back again to give it another try. What a difference! The store is very clean and it's easy to find what you're looking for. The staff are always friendly and helpful! They offer good recommendations when you need them, but also know how to leave you alone when you're just browsing. A lot of people I know say they have good sales too. Personally I don't often pay attention to them because I usually already know what I want. There is a decent wine selection and the prices for everything are very fair.”

4.7 Superb39 Reviews

“My favorite liquor store! Asked for a specific brand of bourbon, and they had it in stock the next week at a very affordable price. I've been coming here for years!”

4.5 Superb62 Reviews