-
October 2024 by Nick Gambino
Eric Cincotta of American coin and stamp of Merrick, NY is an expert in his field. I have great appreciation for Eric Cincotta’s patience and expertise. I highly recommend American coin and stamp.
-
October 2024 by Theresa Carrano
I would personally like to thank Eric Cincotta from American coin and stamp of Merrick, N.Y. Eric is a wealth of information and truly an absolute stand up businessman. I cannot express my gratitude for the time he spent explaining the process of coin collecting. The kindness that Eric Cincotta exudes shows he’s knowledgeable, trustworthy, and truly an expert in his profession.
-
October 2024 by William Vontoussaint
First let me start with Eric, went out of his way to explain and educate me on my dad's stamp collection, even sharing with me the collector my dad was. But most of all he was honest and straight forward when explaining things to me, making me feel safe and comfortable dealing with him. His staff was even nicer to me, making my over all experience awesome... I highly recommend them for all your treasure's...
-
October 2024 by Brian B
I had a very pleasurable experience with both Eric & Patrick. Honest, knowledgable, & more than fair. Such an easy & smooth deal , I returned the following day for another transaction.
-
October 2024 by Brian
It was such a nice experience. Eric was very nice and very knowledgeable. It was a pleasure dealing with him. He helped me out with some baseball memorabilia and even taught me about some coins while I was there. Definitely worth the trip for me.
-
October 2024 by MAKSYM
Nice store
-
September 2024 by Aaron Drucker
This was a great experience. Eric is thoughtful , clear and very easy to talk to. You can tell he is not only knowledgeable but passionate about what he does . He educated us about our coins and currency. It was quite a learning experience for us. Don’t hesitate to go in- they are always willing to see what you have and I feel are extremely fair. I will be using them again in the future for sure !
-
August 2024 by Sam Sam
This was my 1st time at American Coin & Stamp. Eric and staff was so friendly & knowledgeable. It was a pleasure doing business. Awesome experience!!
-
August 2024 by Michael Longworth
Couldn't be happier! Eric is so knowledgeable and a pleasure to deal with. All expectations exceeded! Thank you for you time your honesty and for teaching me a lot about stamps!!
-
August 2024 by TiffTiff Will
Today, I indulged in the most amazing encounter with Eric & Patrick. Simply a dynamic duo! Both are extremely knowledgeable from the most simplest coin to the most rare. I, personally felt like a kid in a candy store, only it wasn’t candy. I was immersed in coinage history and luckily to be inculcated by the best. You must go! Now! These guys know their stuff. You won’t be the slightest bit disappointed.
-
July 2024 by Jimmy Hennessy
The owner of this family owned business couldn’t have been more polite and reasonable about the value of my stamp and coin collection. I highly recommend this business.
-
June 2024 by Sandra Muoio
This shop is filled with great items and low prices. The owner is extremely knowledgeably, helpful and personable. We will definitely be back.
-
May 2024 by Tire Kicker
I inherited a large stamp collection with no knowledge of the hobby or understanding of value. Eric suggested I come down so he can take a look and educate me on both. He spent over two hours with me looking through 30 stamp books and explaining how value is determined and also teaching me about the history of many of the stamps.
A natural concern going into this is that someone will take advantage of the situation but that is exactly the opposite of my experience with ACSB. Not once was I pushed into accepting a low ball offer or mistreated. Eric let me know his thoughts on what the collection was worth and I left with a great education. This was exactly the experience I was hoping for. Thank you Eric, you are a true professional!
-
May 2024 by Joseph Litman
Very packed
You can barely walk in the store
Very cool inventory
-
May 2024 by April Giorgio
Very helpful and honest
