-
November 2023 by Sarah Gagliardi
Awesome place
-
November 2023 by J H
Great selection of classic games including some rare items. Staff was attentive and nice to chat with. Definitely recommend a visit if you’re into retro gaming.
-
October 2023 by Emily Dowd
Amazing glad this game store sell old school video games to earlier 90s to 200ths and mostly VHS tapes
-
September 2023 by Matthew Sanges
I will absolutely not hesitate to reco this place to anyone looking to buy or trade their retro games & hardware (modern gaming is also available but obvs not their main focus).Frank and Henry were chill and considerate — and they pay far more than Jay St or other stores, which initially drew me in.For a guy like me with a great deal of social awkwardness — like the cliche I am — I was perfectly at ease being there, unlike certain other game stores. Place looks professional AF too definitely the classiest game store I've been in.They sell on Instagram and eBay too if you want to check that out.
-
September 2023 by Nicholas Wilsey
Bought a used Nintendo DSi from these guys. They had it cleaned up so it was almost new. The battery has outstanding life, far surpassing my expectations. They gave me a great deal. Very patient and friendly as far as customer service.
-
July 2023 by Ryan Ferguson
Frank & staff are extremely knowledgeable, friendly & passionate about what they do. They go out of their way for their customers to make sure they are completely satisfied and they maintain an amazing stock of games.10000% recommend
-
July 2023 by G. Goolihan Grims
Never been in person yet (some day maybe) but done hundreds of transactions online and it's always great start to finish. Frank is awesome and easy to work with. ~Matt
-
June 2023 by Jared Vibert
Nice local game store. Owner and staff are very knowledgeable with Magic as well as with video games.I believe the owner has a beard? I went in a few times and he always took time to chat with me when I was browsing, even though he had an immense amount of work to do.The store has a nice selection, I appreciate the variety of games as well as the option to buy slightly damaged or incomplete games. Gives you the opportunity to buy and play a game that you don’t want to spend full used market value for.The owner also keeps the place clean and rotates inventory. Seems like he knows what he’s doing.
-
June 2023 by PR TechGuy
Nice store, organized, and good selection. Prices are pretty steep. Higher than eBay. Some are like ?. I'm a seasoned collector and know prices well. I was there in March 2023 and was disappointed by the pricing. I know them from conventions. The owner and employees are nice, just the pricing is too, too high.
-
June 2023 by Ted Paniccia
Owner is super nice and has pretty much anything you’re looking for! Highly recommended for retro gamers!
-
May 2023 by Joseph Snyder
Awesome place. Awesome staff. Wonderful selection. It's a classic games showcase. I cant say enough good things about it.
-
April 2023 by Tasha Brown
Owners and workers are amazingly knowledgeable. We always find so classic game we can't believe they have. Last time we went they had a TV with a Nintendo built into it. I'm an 80's baby and I'd never even knew they made such a thing. It's worth the trip for sure
-
April 2023 by J P
Awesome shop with so many games from current to old consoles! Some are a bit overpriced, but they are collector's items at this point. They also have trading cards and the staff is very knowledgeable. I will visit again!! ^_^
-
March 2023 by Jim Carroll
I recently sold my game collection to Forgotten Freshness and had a thoroughly positive experience. The store is well-kept and has an incredible inventory of retro games, consoles, and gaming-adjacent items (fantastic amiibo collection!) - it was hard not to immediately turn the sold collection into a new set of retro games!Before selling my older games and consoles to Forgotten Freshness, I visited a couple of local stores and shopped around online. At the other local stores, the reactions ranged from indifference to outright hostility. The online interactions were positive, but having to ship the games across the country introduced a ton of extra risk and expense.Forgotten Freshness made me a fair offer that was comparable to the best offers I received online, while also doing business in an open, honest, and friendly way. Their team was clearly familiar with most of the games in my collection, gave me a fair assessment of the condition of the items, and were open and clear about how they priced their offer.If I were in the market for retro games (or even more recent consoles - they have an exceptional Switch collection!), this is where I would start shopping, and the same goes for trying to get a fair value for a collection. While I was at the store, I heard the owner field multiple calls/emails from users looking for rare titles, and he clearly knows his business and does what he can to keep his customer base happy. Great store and transaction all the way around. Thanks again!
-
February 2023 by Saxon Searl
I’ve gone here a few times now with my brother and I must say this is an absolutely phenomenal shop. Always looks good, everything is neat and orderly and with their more recent changes it’s always looks better every time I go. All the games and their prices are conveyed nicely and are pretty damn fair. The owners are always nice and willing to take time to explain any questions you might have and always seem very passionate about their store and the products they serve. Absolutely a 10/10 I will be going here any time I’m on the hunt for a good game, card, figure or system.
