-
August 2023 by Pam S.
Friendly owners, clean rooms, and very quiet! A beach and play park is within walking distance of the motel. Melinda shared tips of places to go. It was amazing!
-
July 2023 by Elizabeth Navarra
Owner-managed and retro-vibe. A block from the beach. Great place to stay for families, couples or even singles to get away from it all.Rooms: Retro-vibe. Roomy with efficiencies.Nearby activities: Vineyards, garden centers, boating, kayaking, bike-riding, beaches, fall harvest fun, lovely North Fork towns.Walkability: Easy 1 block walk to the beach.
-
April 2023 by Hannah Aitchison
I came to the North Fork area on very short notice for a sudden and very unexpected funeral, and had virtually no time to make arrangements. Fortunately, the Mattituck Motel was available, very convenient to the funeral home, clean, cozy and comfortable and had all the amenities I needed to make the stay as easy as possible under the circumstances. Kerry and his wife are wonderful, friendly folks (and major vintage car enthusiasts - bonus!) who made my stay as easy as it could be. Wish I could have hung out longer just to talk cars! I would absolutely recommend this cozy, quiet spot and can only imagine how nice it would be to return in the summertime to visit the beaches and everything this beautiful area has to offer.Rooms: Kitchenette, great water pressure (never underestimate that!), SmartTV with Netflix etc, comfy bed, immaculately cleanFood & drinks: Great local restaurants nearbyNoteworthy details: Close to the shore
-
December 2022 by Andrew Grey
Fantastic service at the Mattituck Motel! Friendly, kind, understanding and generous staff. They were so helpful in making our trip as enjoyable as possible. Will absolutely be staying in here when in the area. Better than ANY AirBnB!!! Thank you!
-
December 2022 by Dave Ward
Fantastic owners here they stayed up late as we drove in from Florida it was late anything we asked for they furnished very old school 3 blocks from the beach shopping 4 blocks away will definitely stay with you again hope your both
-
July 2022 by C8274GUjonathanz
Very responsive helpful owners. Provided beach chairs, beach passes and umbrella along with whatever was needed to enjoy the stay. Close to restaurants (great recommendations from owners) and to the Peconic Bay beaches.
-
April 2022 by Matt V
The standard room with its old fashioned, homey decor was delightful. We slept well in the comfy bed. Melinda, who checked us in, recommended Case’s Place, just a short scenic drive away, for a casual seafood dinner with a water view. We enjoyed the delicious food and local wine.
The room was quiet. The curtains on the windows were pretty but too thin for the outside porch light coming in. We forgot to mention to Melinda we unscrewed the outside light bulb to solve this. Then the room was good and dark.
We woke up to birds singing.
The town is quaint and breathtaking in spring with all the colorful blossoms. We spotted a couple of deer next door.
Thank you for a short but sweet stay!
-
March 2022 by Steven E.
Great place to relax and have a good time Kerry owner is great Always there to help your needs highly recommend
-
December 2021 by Betty Boop
Clean walk to private beachOwner really nice
-
December 2021 by Diane Erwin
A gem! From first phone call to make the reservation to departing morning, owners were over the top awesome.We had an efficiency room, two queens,sitting area and kitchenette. Spotless clean. Mid century decor, cabin like feel. Grounds are tucked away from the east end of Long Island weekend hustle and bustle. Absolutely enjoyed our stay.
-
December 2021 by Diane Trang Pham
Owners are sweet and trying to accommodate their customers. The place is old, but more clean then franchise hotel. Is not pretty because in this are only have cottage feel. But really highly recommend and I would come and stay again for longer period. They have full kitchen too if need to and a BBQ area too.
-
December 2021 by Rhonda Boone
Well maintained. Nice rooms and a quick 4 minute walk to the beach. Definitely will stay here again.
-
October 2021 by Debi F.
I happened upon the Mattituck Motel because my Airbnb fell through, and I am so happy that it turned out this way. The motel is on a quiet street, just a few blocks from the beach. They have beach passes for your car. Use them, ticketing is quick. The grounds are well maintained, there is a barbeque, lounge chairs for hanging out, and the location is perfect for activities, restaurants, and beach hanging.Kerry and Melinda are the nicest people. I felt welcome and at home immediately. The rooms are comfortable, each one has a kitchen, so I don't have to go out for every meal. I thought the beds were comfortable, the kitchen was stocked with pots and pans. If I needed anything I just had to ask. The towels were nice and everything was very clean. I plan to come back as soon as possible. I highly recommend the Mattituck Motel for any length of stay. It really felt like home.
-
December 2020 by Joseph Binelli
A perfect place to stay
-
December 2019 by Nicole P
4 night minimum policy in the summer....extremely disappointing especially for a local.
