Toy Stores near Lancaster, NY

13 locations found near Lancaster

“I came to the Village of Lancaster on a whim, a last minute decision to do my Christmas shopping locally wherever possible. Bloomsbury Lane had just moved down the street and their sign hadn't been placed above the correct storefront yet. Upon my arrival I was greeted by a woman who I believe to be the owner or manager. She was FANTASTIC. She assisted me in shopping for all three of my daughters (almost teenaged, preschool, and toddler). The prices were "reasonable" as I would have paid a similar amount at a big-box store, but they offered to wrap my gifts as well which was an excellent and much-needed touch. I went to pick up all of the wrapped packages an hour or so later! I can't wrap well and honestly never have time until Christmas Eve, so it allowed me to enjoy my holiday so much more. I was so thrilled with the whole experience I sent my mom (from out of town) there later that day with my grandmother to do their shopping as well.”

4.4 Superb57 Reviews

“Kid to Kid is amazing!!!!!!! Snow boots, sweatshirts, hoodies, jeans and pjs all for $100 for my 3 kiddos. Plus cash back and a free book every month. Honestly, you can’t beat the prices!!!!!”

4.8 Superb177 Reviews

“Lots of fun with grandkids, it’s like the old 5 & dime stores of yesterday. Plenty of interesting items to browse. Lots to shop for all ages. We go with our grandkids once or twice a year, they love the toy section and riding the automatic horse for a dime!”

4.7 Superb227 Reviews

“Very nice store, and they had a lot of sets that I was looking for, and the wall was stocked. The store was clean and had a nice display. The staff were nice, but not overly welcoming. Other stores staff will ask questions on interests, etc.”

4.7 Superb43 Reviews

“Great selection of stuffed animals and toys, a little on the pricy side but tbh, I’d much rather support a local business for a few bucks more than gamble with an online seller. Lots of harder to find figurines and other toys that are usually only on Amazon.”

4.7 Superb120 Reviews

“Always a great place to find quality toys at an affordable price. Staff is knowledgeable, friendly and helpful.Love their outdoor display at Christmas. Makes my grandson happy and puts a smile on my face....great photo-op too!!!”

4.8 Superb73 Reviews

“Ollie's is somewhere you don't want to go unsupervised lol.

I found what I needed & then some.
Amazing assortment, great sales and once I sign up on their app I'll get an additional 15% off.

Gotta go people!!!! Happy customer”

4.3 Superb282 Reviews

“4 children plus 6 adults. Pricey but as for a family outing once a year...Worth it! Employees are wonderful so good with kids. Memories made that will last forever. We were a large walk in group and they took care of us well. So much fun. Will definitely be back.”

4.4 Superb123 Reviews

“A really lovely little shop right on main street at the corner of Olean. Just packed full of unique gifts and every day toys/games. If you can't find something here, then it can't be found.”

4.8 Superb49 Reviews

“Thats got to be the oldest best hobby shop left in western NY.They got more toys then toys are US,. cars,trucks, farm equipment , fire equipment,, models. May be little pricey but your not going to find it anywhere else. I spent hrs. In the store just looking. And always find something I'm looking for.”

4.4 Superb44 Reviews

“Meeting the owner is an absolute joy to hear him talk about the shop and the collectibles. Excellent ice cream and chocolates downstairs at Sweet Jenny’s. Sooooo many things to look at and enjoy. It’s about a 5 hour drive for me and I can’t wait to go back again.”

4.3 Superb52 Reviews

“I found the new location to still have the same charm as the old one. I found the owner to be very curious and helpful. Tons of toys, puzzles and board games to choose from.”

3.4 Good70 Reviews