Jewelry Stores near Jefferson Valley-Yorktown, NY

24 locations found near Jefferson Valley-Yorktown

“I went here to get some bracelets shortened and they were very honest about what could and couldn’t be done! Kind people; every experience I’ve had makes me feel like they were very trustworthy and fair. Will be going back here again and again.”

4.3 Superb41 Reviews

“All I can say is EXCELLENT in every aspect, friendly, customer service, I dropped off a ring for repair and it was ready the next day. I would recommend this store to everyone who needs jewelry or needs jewelry repaired. Overall GREAT experience.”

5 Superb229 Reviews

“We needed a quick jewelry repair and D’Errico totally came through. Also, so in love with the ring I purchased. Definitely going to buy more! Also, everyone was so helpful, knowledgeable and approachable.”

4.9 Superb108 Reviews

“Myron provided excellent service! He helped me design my wife’s engagement and wedding band. He took time and showed interest to understand my vision and preferences. She loved both rings.”

5 Superb58 Reviews

“Stuff is a bit pricey, parking is limited, but occasional streetside sales are fun to browse through. Promotes local ( Westchester based) vendors. Really neat shop.”

5 Superb43 Reviews

“What a great experience dealing with the entire family at Genesis Jewelers! Everyone was so accommodating and very helpful in making sure my purchase was exactly what I wanted. I needed a last-minute gift to give to my daughter on her wedding day. They custom made a diamond pendant necklace and had it ready by the next day just in time for the wedding! It came out absolutely beautiful and my daughter loved it!”

4.7 Superb136 Reviews

“Natasha did such a nice job piercing my ears! She made me feel comfortable and provided her input throughout the process, I highly recommend getting your piercing done by her!”

4.7 Superb39 Reviews

“Lori is an angel. Over the phone she guided me to a beautiful gift and even sent photos before the purchase. She went above and beyond in so many ways. Highly recommend!”

4.7 Superb24 Reviews

“I love everyone that works here! Very knowledgeable and helpful. They have so many beautiful items too. From statues, pictures to jewelry. Baptism clothing, Communion clothing and gifts, etc. I highly recommend checking this store out.”

4.7 Superb56 Reviews

“What a beautiful store! Needed a special gift for a birthday and was hard to choose. Jennifer was extremely helpful in every way! Highly recommend this business for high quality gifts and exceptional customer service.”

5 Superb24 Reviews

“I have been going to Celtic Aer for years and it is a great place to shop. The staff and service are amazing. I have found many gifts there for my family and friends. It's a great wee shop with a big selection of wonderful gifts, food, and more.”

4.8 Superb43 Reviews

“I can't express my gratitude enough to Robert and the team at Elephant's Trunk. They truly saved the day for me! With a last-minute event suddenly on my agenda, I found myself in a scramble for a tuxedo, and they went above and beyond to accommodate my needs.

Coincidentally, my office is located just a short distance away, and when I urgently searched for nearby tuxedo rental places, Elephant's Trunk popped up. From the moment I walked in, Robert greeted me warmly and immediately got to work on finding the perfect tuxedo for my event.

Robert's expertise and professionalism were evident throughout the entire process. Despite the tight timeframe, he guided me through the selection process flawlessly, ensuring that every detail was just right.

I want to extend a sincere thank you to Robert and the entire team at Elephant's Trunk for their exceptional service. While my experience was nothing short of fantastic, I want to stress the importance of planning ahead whenever possible. Nonetheless, if you find yourself in need of a tuxedo rental, I highly recommend paying a visit to Elephant's Trunk. Thank you once again for everything!”

4.7 Superb64 Reviews

“They did a great job with my Tuxedo rental. The salesman (Robert) walked me through all my options, offering advice as needed, made sure everything fit well, made adjustment/replacements when needed, and made me feel like they cared whether or not I looked good at the event. In the end, you couldn't tell I was in a rented tux. And, it cost less than my previous Tux rental at another place nearby.”

5 Superb7 Reviews

“Today I discovery this hidden gem, love the unique products from clothe, accessories and jewelry. Very clean store, unique merchandizes, great customer service and love that the street closed off to cars, you can walk around on the street and enjoy the great restaurants near by. They have plenty of street parking and they are always are adding new items.”

4.8 Superb24 Reviews

“The owner adjusted my watch band, and would accept no payment. I even had to go back to get it loosened a bit. It was a really nice experience, especially in this day and age when high quality customer service is rare…keep up the good work!”

4.9 Superb22 Reviews

“I needed a new wedding ring when my old one experienced a trauma, so after reading about Matero on Nextdoor Neighbor, I decided to try them out. I was just a "Lookee Lou" but both Steve and Sue were attentive, interested and pleasant as I wandered from case to case, looking at all the shiny things, without a clue as to what I wanted. They never lost patience, and dug out anything I wanted, which was a lot. They colored diamonds with sharpies to show me different colors and never showed frustration. I dragged my husband back, having changed my mind about what I wanted completely, and they were as gracious as ever. After long discussions, I decided to add stones to my engagement ring and make it a "set" with my new wedding ring, but of course I had questions about colors, sizes of stones, sizes of rings, etc. Steve was unfailing patient and very helpful in his suggestions, from type of stone, to colors of stones to sizing (because I have a finger that swells and shrinks all within the same day,) all of which were absolutely on target. I would have made some unfortunate errors without his help. We now feel like family and I got THE most gorgeous rings, simply by adding two stones to my brilliant cut diamond, and making an attractive diamond/colored stone band to match. I am thrilled and would never go anywhere else. Steve WANTS you to get what you want and he wants to make sure you are satisfied. And happy. They are consummate professionals, with seemingly endless knowledge about stones and jewelry. They are patient kind, cordial, welcoming and always gracious, as if nothing is too much trouble. I suspect some people, myself included, are, but you'd never know it. We love them (and my rings)!”

5 Superb30 Reviews

“This store is absolutely mind blowing, everything in there is just absolutely beautiful!! There are items for everyone and I promise you will have a blast just looking through the store. BEWARE you might spend your entire paycheck there, the jewelry is irresistible. I went a couple days ago to get my prom dress and the owner of the store was the sweetest lady ever and completely understood my vision. I highly recommend visiting you won’t regret it :)”

4.8 Superb28 Reviews

“The Mexican Shack is the most amazing jewelry store I've ever been in. While the jewelry, gifts, souvenirs are wonderful, it's the people that started this business and kept it going all these years that make it an extraordinary experience.Steve and Mary (the owners) are incredible. They take the time to find what's right for you and they get to know you in the process. They put love and care into each customer's experience and I will miss them dearly.Marianne and Beverly are incredibly kind and their customer service is outstanding. I have also had the most pleasant experiences with them.Robert is the jeweler that made the many pieces of jewelry I wear and his work is out of this world. His talent is magical and I'm so lucky to own some of his pieces.Thank you all very much for providing such exquisite jewelry, gifts, top notch customer service and unforgettable experiences. Every. Single. Time. You'll be sorely missed!”

4.8 Superb53 Reviews

“I wish I could give this shop 100 stars. I came in with a very specific and unusual engagement ring idea. I showed Bridget a reference picture and described what I was looking for and she took it from there. She sourced the stone I wanted (not an easy job), designed the setting, had the ring fabricated, and delivered every single thing I asked for. She kept me in the loop the entire time with amazing communication and in the end, the ring arrived better than I had imagined, within my budget, and on time for a Valentine's Day proposal as Bridget had promised. Amazing, amazing, amazing.”

4.6 Superb35 Reviews

“We have been coming here for years. I have had earrings and 3 wedding rings re-set into yellow gold with additional small diamonds added. This trip was because I stupidly took my rings off and lost them in a parking lot for a few hours. When I (so thankfully) found them they had been run over and bent. I immediately took them here and again was so blown away by the professionalism, service, attention to detail, and very fast turn around time. I brought my rings in on a Saturday morning and they were fixed, checked, and polished by Monday morning so I could have them back before Thanksgiving. They are back to brand new and so shiny! I could not recommend this jeweler more - he is fantastic and we will be coming here for all our needs in the future. I recommend him to everyone I know!”

4.4 Superb20 Reviews

“Dan is the best! He has fixed, updated and resurrected several fine jewelry and costume pieces for me that belonged to my mother and grandmother. He always has a creative solution at a reasonable price. If his hours don't work for your schedule, you can simply make an appointment. This local Croton resource is worth his weight in gold.”

4.5 Superb20 Reviews

“Great customer service. Nice people willing to help. Good selection of quality jewelry and less expensive options as well. They helped me this time to replace the pins in my watch band. Thank you so much.”

4.2 Good20 Reviews

“Hi, just walked into Kay jewelers in Jefferson Valley, New York/Yorktown and had the most amazing customer service experience that I’ve ever had in my life and I say this with so much confidence. As I am a nurse and work for the public and an experience, what real Care should feel like. Melissa went above and beyond to help me track down the engagement ring that I needed helped me to activate my approved key credit card called a store at another location to confirm they had the ring and the size I desired and assure me that everything will be OK. Thank you so much Melissa for making my day. This gift is the gift that will keep on giving when I anticipate a :-) to put in my partners heart ❤️”

3.8 Good22 Reviews

“Dee at Anthony Jewelers and been helping me upgrade an older ring. She's been patient and accommodating when the first band was too thin and the second too thick. We now found the perfect setting for my diamond! Great jeweler! Highly recommend!”

3.2 Average21 Reviews