Shoe Stores in Ithaca, NY

5 locations found near Ithaca

“Great shoes and great staff. I accidentally forgot my backpack in the store and one of the staff members went out of her way to bring it next door to Chatty Cathy (I mentioned I was going there after). 10 stars!”

4.9 Superb73 Reviews

“I regularly visit Benjamin Peters and am always impressed with the experience. The customer service is exceptional, with Sam, the owner, and Mickey offering personal attention and genuine care. They are up-to-date with the latest fashion trends, and stock a wide selection of stylish options for both casual and business clothes.What truly sets them apart is their honesty; staff provides sincere feedback on what clothing suits you best, ensuring you leave with pieces that enhance your style. My friends from all over, big cities and small come to shop here for a reason : good service and up-to-date clothes that fit. I highly recommend.”

4.7 Superb53 Reviews

“I bought my very first pair of SB Dunks here 5 years ago! Great people. We are truly lucky to have such an amazing skate shop in this area! Keep up the great work!!”

3.9 Good52 Reviews

“The salesperson at this place was honest and informative about winter boots and shoes. The prices were reasonable too, overall it's a great store for shopping winter shoes.”

3.7 Good42 Reviews

“I respectfully disagree with other comments saying prices are expensive. I think some people associate used clothing with Salvation Army prices.
Although there is some truth to that, a lot of the clothes are brand new or in great condition. The store is kept clean, clothes are well organized and smell way better than any thrift store I’ve been to.
I prefer to keep all my clothes than sell them….so I can’t comment on how they pick what clothing to buy from you.
However, I’m sure they don’t deliberately refuse your clothing or pay you less because they want to.
It’s a resell business. I also think some people might not fully understand the concept of how that works.
The workers have always been so polite. Which probably isn’t always easy working in retail customer service! It’s worth checking out.”

3.2 Average108 Reviews