-
October 2024 by Marco Gervasi
Neighborhood gem. Phenomenal quality dry aged meats. Everything we’ve ordered has been excellent!
-
September 2024 by joy skii
People here are nice, the owner is friendly
-
June 2024 by Rajan Silberman
A local family run establishment with great quality food and service. Not to many places exist like this anymore highly recommend.
-
January 2024 by TARA ANDERSEN
Always welcoming when we walk in it feels like family. Food looks appealing and delicious we've liked everything we tried. Highly recommend this butcher!!!
-
January 2024 by DMA Waits (DMAW)
I wandered in here after picking up something from one of the neighboring stores, I'm so glad I did! The service was amazing, the sandwiches are HUGE, delicious, and very well made. Im looking forward to going back and trying other things. 10/10
-
January 2024 by Colleen Dietz
Super nice!!!
-
January 2024 by Christopher Locke
Pete Jr. is a really swell and fair guy. He was very patient in explaining how he prepares and prices certain meats. Love this place and will definitely be going back. Keep up the good work guys ??.
-
December 2023 by Kim Bergendorff
Only there once but friendly service and good food
-
December 2023 by Bill M
We have been going to Pete & Pete since they opened. We continue to come back year after year. Everything including service is outstanding. Looking forward to our fresh turkey.
-
October 2023 by Amanda S
My husband and I love this butcher! Everything is always fresh and taste delicious!
-
July 2023 by lil Clark
They have the best baked chicken ever. I go there just for the chickenMust try their dry age burgers
-
July 2023 by Caroline B.
Everyone I know who lives in Islip highly recommends this butcher shop! The owners are so charismatic and polite - they remember their customers by name! The service is always outstanding and the food is DELICIOUS! Their prepared foods are divine and the meat is always so fresh. They also have beef marrow bones for your dogs and will even cut them into smaller pieces for you! I highly recommend this place!
-
March 2023 by Ruben Friedman
The owners are lovely people. The food is always top-notch. They deliver quickly. Peter, one of the owners, will tell you how best to cook everything.
-
November 2022 by Richie L.
I have been passing by this establishment for years and not realizing it was there. Then I was shopping for a nice local Butcher and I came across IMM. Who's j had Great Yelp reviews. I wanted either a rib roast or steak to enjoy with my wife. I met Pete who by the way is the Most Professional,Cordial Gentleman I've come across in retail in a Long Time! Pete took his time to show and explain the different cuts and prices of the Meats I was interested in and MORE!! I finally made a decision on 2 T Bone stakes approx 1-1/2" thick that looked incredible. I explained I couldn't BBQ where I live now and Pete gave me probably the simplest instructions on cooking the steaks on a cast Ironman and then into a super Hot oven for no more than 10mins total and he was on the Freakin $. Thanks Again Pete!! You have a New Customer. They also have Freshly prepared side dishes,homemade salads,Dry Aged Meats and plenty of BBQ sauces,mustards,ketchups and condiments for sale also. But the Best part of the visit was the saw dust On the floor for that Old School Butcher Shop Feel. It brought me back to the the days of going to the butcher with my Grand Parents and Parents. I Highly Recommend trying this Family Owned and Run Business at-least once. I'll Bet like myself you'll Appreciate their Welcomes when Entering and Professional No Attitude Service !!!
-
November 2022 by R D
Best steaks around maybe even ever.
