-
August 2023 by Suzanne Sanschagrin
I love shopping at The Cow Over the Moon. It’s like taking a step back in time with toys my friends and family played when I was young.I’ve purchased many presents fur my nieces and nephews here and they always love them.
-
June 2023 by Adit Babureddy
Brian is incredibly knowledgeable and one of the friendliest in the business! My go to for old school baseball cards, autographs, and memorabilia. Highly recommend him for any sports collectors or hobbyists. Best store on Long Island by far
-
September 2022 by brb b.
Really cute toy store. A huge selection of everything the kids could want: puzzles, action figures, coloring, legos, etc. everything was neatly organized, the AC was working, and the store employees were nice. The prices were reasonable as well.
-
August 2022 by spencer starr
Been going here since I was a kid and has an amazing selection. Brian is very knowledgeable as well.
-
August 2022 by Tiffany Van Winkle
Amazing toys, signed jerseys and great staff!
-
February 2022 by setmarnjbc
All kinds of awesome stuff here!
-
November 2021 by Dennis C.
Best toy store I have seen in ages. I will be back. It's a grandfather's place to buy! Got many good items for a fair price
-
April 2021 by Norman Kaufman
I had ordered a photo from Amazon and found out that the photo was sold out. Brian went out of his way to secure a better photo from another distributor which happened to be at a much higher cost photo than the original I had ordered from Amazon. He ordered it for me and had it framed for me since the other photo was paid for and out of stock. He went out of his way to satisfy me for an important birthday gift. Wonderful customer service and made this birthday a wonderful day. Thank you Brian! I definitely will return to his store.
-
January 2021 by KZ Sports Marketing
We live on the south shore of Long Island but we don’t mind making a trip to Huntington Village and visiting this local toy store.The store has a little bit of everything including Sports Memorabilia. Bobby, who is one of the owners, is a great guy. He always goes above and beyond for anything I need.
-
March 2020 by Adam Garyn
Great selection of autographs for all collectors and cards Bryan is great store owner and has also toys for sale I will be back.
-
January 2020 by Jesse Wemyss
Wide selection of special toys for my nephew's Christmas gift. Knowledgeable of items on display...A+++
-
October 2019 by IA
Lovely toy store, kind and helpful proprieters! I loved the calico critters blindbags :)
-
October 2019 by Amy E.
Very helpful and have a wide assortment of toys! Every time I have called to check if they have a toy they always do. Asked for some help picking out a gift and apparently the worker knocked it out of the park because the birthday boy loved the new addition!
-
August 2019 by Jennifer McAuliffe-Comitz
awesome stuff, great prices and Brian is so nice and informative !
-
August 2019 by Fox E.
I prefer Pig Under The Sun, but this will do. There's nothing at all wrong with this little family owned toy store and if you see some of the negative reviews here - especially when they're telling you to go across the street - you have to assume they were written by the toy store across the street, which has a lot of fake positive reviews. I don't know why more isn't done about this as it is really obvious. Anyway it's a good toy store but prices are high. You get to check out the toys in prison - I mean in person - and see what you're getting, so it's better than ordering online and worth a little extra money. And they were perfectly friendly to us when we were browsing through here along with all the other stores down in Huntington.
