-
December 2024 by Perry Nusbaum
An honest place in a sea of total jerks permeating our beloved collectibles industry. If you are looking to sell Paul is as straight as they come - and has a ton of inventory. If I had an extra $100,000 and just wanted to rip for days I’d go back and hook it up.
-
January 2024 by jersey k1d
Paul is Incredible! Top-notch services and pricesHe is personable and has plenty of knowledge when it comes to the trading card businessThis is a MUST stop for all those who have a passion for cards and memorabilia
-
December 2023 by Jaysin Hernandez
THANK U FOR THE MEW PACK
U GUYS ARE THE BEST AND U GUYS MADE MY DAY
-
September 2023 by Anthony Nici
I have always enjoyed this hobby shop. It’s by far the best one in orange and rockland county. They have a great selection of sports cards and especially the hockey cards, which is what I like to collect. All that is Missing is a wall of new comic books!!
-
September 2023 by luke cappa
Paul is a great guy and runs a great business. out of all the cards store locally to me BP sports cards is my go to. i really recommend going here.
-
June 2023 by John Woods
The cards were great, service was good, I got a Mickey Mantle for $200, a free Sandy Koufax, and almost 60 more cards for free. Also a Rickey Henderson rookie card!
-
April 2023 by Tom Mythen
Always provided insight and fair pricing on all products when visiting the store. Noticed the inventory is well stocked compared to other shops in the area.
-
March 2023 by Dooms Dave
Great shop! An Awesome Selection for a wide variety of products and interests. Sportscards, Memorabilia, Pokémon, Magic and even Paintable Minatures for D&D/Warhammer etc. This Shop has something for everyone. Fortunate to have this as my local spot! The owner Paul is a really good dude and fun to talk to, I find myself hanging around well over an hour just chopping it up.. One thing I've also noticed is that Paul goes out of his way to help customers both old and new. He has a vast knowledge and understanding of the products he sells, making what could be a overwhelming experience, a fun and easy one. When comparing online, this shop's prices are extremely fair and sometimes even better. A+++ I highly recommend this shop. -Dave S.
-
March 2023 by Matt K
Best card shop around. BP always has a great selection and prices. The owner is very knowledgeable, honest and friendly.
-
February 2023 by Danny Earl
This place is great and the owner is awesome. I buy Warhammer boxes and paints from here every now and then, and the owner is always helping me find specific things I'm looking for, as well as answering any questions I may have. Highly recommend this place.
-
February 2023 by Gary Mills
Absolutely perfect. Prices were very good for boxes and packs, the gentleman was very open about his pricing both buying and selling. I bought 3 topps chrome boxes, took my wife to 2 wineries and bought 3 more booster boxes on my way home. I will Absolutely be coming here when topps 2023 baseball is released and would recommend this shop to anyone else.
-
January 2023 by Victor Calderon
Traveled from about an hour away and was extremely happy and satisfied with my purchase. Cannot wait to come back! They had an amazing selection of pokemon cards and packs which I was in the market for.
-
December 2022 by Pete & Karen
Went there with no clue of worth of items and Paul took the time to explain worth of each piece sold. Very , very honest and fair..Would highly recommend store to any one looking to buy or sell Memorabilia!!
-
December 2022 by Chris Verdi
My favorite place.. best and most honest prices!
-
November 2022 by Adam Flores
I've known the owner of this place for quite some time and he is incredible to work with.Once upon a time, I brought over an entire team of Yu-gi-oh! players and he ran tournaments weekly for us on the blink of an eye. He always answered the phone and was always willing to work with us.The team changed drastically over time and shifted online during COVID but I have not worked with a better or more honest TCG store owner to date.
