Gift Shops near Fishers Island, NY

20 locations found near Fishers Island

“Loved my experience here at the Foxwoods location. The store is very clean and organized with all displays easy to easy.The staff were so nice, and so helpful!Thank you again!”

4.9 Superb46 Reviews

“I always come here when my girlfriend wants to look for stuff but recently her ring stopped fitting. So I asked if they had any necklace chains. Even though they weren't sure. The cashier/manager (not sure what he was) tried to find one and wanted to keep it a secret so I could surprise her. Eventually he said he couldn't find one but right before be left my girl got distracted by crystals and the manager man pulled me aside and handed me the chain. And told me take it and said take it. 10/10 she was extremely happy with the gift and store.”

4.9 Superb54 Reviews

“It was a great experience. They have an amazing range of products! Lots of handcrafted beauties, folklore, and cultural crafts from Northern Europe. I enjoyed all the Scandinavian and Celtic products in there! I myself bought a Scotland patch and a Celtic Triskelion necklace. Very pleased! We were walking around in there for a good 30 minutes.. or more! The vibe is amazing and I highly recommend you check it out!”

4.8 Superb96 Reviews

“First time visiting Nest and was thrilled to find a hidden gem of a gift store. Candles, jewelry for every taste, unique decor items, handbags and clothing. The store smells so nice (from those candles and diffusers) and the atmosphere is very inviting. It appears they put out new inventory all the time. Worth a visit!”

4.8 Superb30 Reviews

“Our favorite store at Olde Mystic Village! If you like things to decorate your yard, this is the place to see! The items are reasonably priced and the staff is friendly and helpful. Stop by when vacationing in Mystic!”

4.8 Superb51 Reviews

“I had a soap making class with Linda. She is so kind that I felt like we knew from years.The class was excellent, she taught me a lot. From which oils, fragrance, temperature, SAFETY, everything. I had a great experience and at the same time was super relaxing and enjoyable.Definitely, I will come back for more workshops. Thank you, Linda ❤️”

5 Superb14 Reviews

“There's something for everyone here. A decent collection of shirts for purchase as well as shot glasses, posters, and various other souvenirs. The ladies working the back desk are nice and helpful should you have any questions!”

4.8 Superb10 Reviews

“I had a really bad day before I entered this store of the funniest stuff ever. Now my day is lit! I also bought some laugh material for later. And some badges, pins, coloring books. Loved shopping here!”

4.9 Superb10 Reviews

“Even if you aren’t into Harry Potter or nerd culture, you have to stop in this place! Their drinks are superb and the entire shop is whimsical and full of magic. If you are into HP, you will love all the drink names and all the items on display. I can’t wait to visit again and try more of the drinks!”

4.6 Superb72 Reviews

“I bought a 24 inch Alice tea Party nutcracker which they shipped to me because I live in california! It came broken but I paid to ship it back! We were all disappointed it came broken but they took care of everything for me and sent me another gorgeous one and reimbursed me for my shipping cost to return it! I let them know this one arrived safely ! I appreciated they handled everything so speedy ! Thanks again ! Your new friend In California Claudia”

4.6 Superb69 Reviews

“I love this store. The owners are beautiful people and the store has such a sense of peace. Great quality clothes and so much other stuff to check out. Great place to visit”

4.5 Superb25 Reviews

“This is my husband's and son's favorite bookstore. When we visit Mystic they actually go every day! They have all kinds of good reads for every interest. Recently, it was expanded to include two large rooms. The front room features new releases and popular, classic novels among others. The room proceeding it features academic subjects such as politics, history, economics, etc. The atmosphere provides a sense of calm, which coincides nicely with the already relaxed atmosphere of Mystic. Before the store itself is a statue of a whale, a hallmark that can be found throughout Connecticut, just as shell statues can be found throughout New Jersey. With beautiful editions of books of every variety, you will not be disappointed!”

4.2 Good45 Reviews

“We wandered in on our trip to the Shoppes of Old Mystic and LOVE this place. They had the coolest, most unique items for dog and cat lovers and even for my little whale loving nephew, there was a SUPER COOL book. I highly recommend this store if you have little ones to keep entertained while on vacation. For babies and toddlers, there are adorable finger puppet card board books in the back, little ones from the ages of 3-10 would like all of the plastic toy animals, and the plush stuffed animals of EVERY kind. I highly recommend this and several other shoppes in Old Mystic.”

4.2 Good54 Reviews

“Me and my boyfriend visited the area and had an absolutely lovely experience with everyone here. We ended up coming in 3 times in the same day for gifts for family and friends and everyone was so nice and friendly and remembered us every time. They gave great stuff for anyone you can think of and A+ customer service. Totally totally recommend!”

4.3 Superb23 Reviews

“Nice spot for all things anime and manga, They have a good mix of items to select from. The interior is pretty cool and had life size statues of some classic characters. They have a food section with everything from Japanese ice cream, to Udon noodles, and snacks. There's even a small corner arcade with free, playable, old school games.”

4.3 Superb38 Reviews

“I highly recommend checking out Mystic Aquarium. Prices are lower if you purchase tickets in advance than on the day of visit. The online system is easy to use, but there are also kiosks at Mystic Aquarium to purchase your tickets. Mystic Aquarium has plenty of parking and it is free. It is right next to Olde Mistick Village.They have a huge variety of animals and exhibits, but beluga whales caught my attention. They are interesting animals and I could watch them all day. We spent a few hours exploring the whole aquarium and saw a sea lion show.”

4.1 Good19 Reviews

“Walked into the store. Kind of hoping to get something for my dad and we walked out with more than we thought we would. The prices are pretty reasonable especially for what you're getting and the ladies were pretty nice even though I think the young one was a little upset that we asked to feel the heaviness of the money clip. The selection was perfect and I love that they even had some candy from Ireland and the price was just right. I would definitely be back”

4.1 Good57 Reviews

“After spending an unexpected extended stay at the hospital for the birth of our child I placed an order as soon as I got home. The delivery of chocolate covered strawberries, a bouquet and a card arrived WITHIN THE HOUR. This may be the fasted delivery I have had in A LONG TIME and I greatly appreciate it. The product did look as it was advertised but of course my wife loved the card the most because she is very sentimental. Thank you to the owners/delivery driver of this location.”

4.1 Good62 Reviews

“I was on my way to MA and stopped in this general store. I'm so glad I did. I picked up tons of food items to sample when I get back home. I loved the decor and the staff was friendly. I'll be back.”

3.9 Good119 Reviews

“Unique "men's" provision store which offers a variety of interesting and unique products, but not necessarily only for men. I enjoyed browsing the store with my "man" and ended up getting a great birthday gift for my son. They have lots of nautical themed items, along with books, clothes and more. It's definitely worth a stop in.”

3.5 Good63 Reviews