Thrift Stores near Farmingdale, NY

23 locations found near Farmingdale

“My boyfriend and I live in Farmingdale. We walk to Main Street all the time. The Farmingdale Thrift store on Main Street is under new management and is amazing. We always stop in when walking on Main Street. 90% of the time one of us or both of us end up buying something. The items are in great condition and the prices are great! Definitely pop in when you’re in the neighborhood!”

3.7 Good54 Reviews

“This place is run by angles on earth, they take care of as many people as humanly possible they clothes and feed anyone in need and this world is a better place for having the Long Island trading post friends and family is spreading the world with take care of your neibor s and anyone that is in need attitude. God bless us all xoxo”

4.8 Superb69 Reviews

“Cute little thrift store in the heart of oyster bay village! Staff was friendly and helpful. Everything is neatly organized and not overrun with products. Found some great finds like a crock pot, boots and firefighter toys for my son. They accept credit cards!”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“We donated clothes and household items to the Trading Post and the staff is WONDERFUL. They take the donated goods ,sell them and use the funds to help those in need. It's a great place. Help them to help others.”

4.4 Superb43 Reviews

“I have been a patron of this shop for over 50 years, have found the best!!! Prices are unbelievable. New items daily. Ya never know what you will come upon. Treasures!”

4.7 Superb47 Reviews

“i loooove this store. i come weekly and there is always something fresh and new. great clothing section and great finds behind the jewelry counter! worth a trip!”

4.4 Superb70 Reviews

“The most charming shop ever— dont let the size fool you, there’s enough amazing things inside to keep you looking and looking. The jewelry selection in particular is rather inspired, as are the singing clocks.

6/5 stars if that were possible. i’ll definitely be back”

4.3 Superb36 Reviews

“Having lost a lot of weight, I needed clothes for a wedding. A neighbor said "Go to Canny". They helped me get an Italian Wool jacket and slacks, all for $20.00. Amazing! Now I won't go anywhere else for clothes! I love these women. I hope everyone reads this. I want them to STAY in business. From DrBHappy, Westbury, NYFrom DRBHAPPY (It's on my license plate)”

4 Good27 Reviews

“Great prices and a nice selection for being a smaller thrift store. Always find something when I go in. I also appreciate the fact that the religious items are free. Also the ladies who work here are always kind and friendly.”

4.5 Superb6 Reviews

“What a wonderful thrift store.. clean . Neat. Organized. And great finds. It is split in two departments. The help is wonderful. You will want to spend hours just looking at everything. Definitely bring your donations to community thrift.. it goes to a great cause.. and if you have any extra shopping bags laying around they would greatly appreciate it.”

3.9 Good47 Reviews

“Take a peek! I've found Pyrex and pampered chef practically new, along side of classic finds that bring back memories of my childhood. There's always something different in there.Profits benefit local animal rescues”

3.9 Good12 Reviews

“The staff working there are very friendly, caring and approachable. The items are neatly organized and the items are sold at a very reasonable price. Love the shop”

4 Good9 Reviews

“The ladies personalaties and it's for a good cause to help the community. It's a good place for donations and maybe find that thing you've been looking for.”

3.8 Good10 Reviews

“Very nice, small thrift store. Excellent prices, very good merchandise and a friendly, easy to communicate with, staff. Really enjoyed shopping there. My wife purchased about 14 items; every thing was 50% off.”

3.8 Good4 Reviews

“Always find something when I come in. Great prices and a nice selection for being a smaller thrift store. They always have some type of sale going on which is definitely appreciated. Not to mention the wonderful volunteers who work at the register. They are all so nice and helpful.”

3.7 Good25 Reviews

“This store has some hidden gems. I've gone numerous times and been pretty pleased with my findings. Young ladies at counter are sweet. At the end of the day keep in mind it's a thrift store, not a hi end store.”

3.7 Good131 Reviews

“Place is really great! Saw some of the other reviews, not sure how people were displeased. I thought the staff was helpful and kind. Selection was large and fantastic! I came with my girlfriend, and we both found something here!”

2.8 Average37 Reviews

“I love this savers, Marlon, Nora and Cheryl are the best!!!! They are always very helpful and always so nice. They greet everyone with a smile, and if you have a hard time at the register they are more than happy to help you. They are top tier! Marlon, Nora and Cheryl are always approachable not like some of the other employees. Patrick is the best store manager of any of the savers I have gone too. Cheryl is an absolute doll, and has so much patience even when she is super busy . When she is working her area is very organized.”

3.4 Good138 Reviews

“We made a great sofa purchase, along with home accessories, recently at Society of St. Vincent de Paul Long Island's thrift store in Huntington. We fell in love with the sofa's look and comfort -- and the great price. We were so pleased that we've returned again today for an additional sofa purchase. Our sales rep, Michelle, was fantastic.”

2.9 Average60 Reviews

“Solid thrift spot! Two floors. The top floor is pretty sparse — go there for home goods, a tiny selection of books, linens & kids clothes. Usually I skip that floor. The bottom floor is where it’s at — adult clothing, shoes, furniture. There are three small dressing room stalls (not super private) if you really need them. When it’s cleaned up, everything is organized by color. Sometimes it gets pretty messy, but that happens at thrift stores! Generally well taken care of and nice workers. They do play a lot of worship music but maybe that’s just a Sal. Army thing? Not sure. No restrooms FYI. LOTS of sales, though, especially on holidays!”

3 Average61 Reviews

“Loads of stock in every department. Some prices were high and for that I'm giving them a 4. They have special sale days where they get 2.99 for almost every ticket color less than 24.99. The staff was helpful as well.”

3 Average111 Reviews

“This thrift store is a little gem. Ive been there three times in the last two month with my two cousins and we love it. First of all it is huge! They have clothes for men, women and kids. Modern and vintage and i guarantee that if you have the patience to sift through the clothes you will find some nice labels and useful clothing. It is a thrift store so i am not understanding some of the other comments on this site and I’m wondering if we’re even talking about the same place. Their prices are very good and they have sales all the time. Depending on the color of the ticket, you can get 25% 50% or 75% off the ticket price. I brought home some really nice items had them dry cleaned and are using them. Cousins and I will be back !!!!”

2.9 Average182 Reviews

“Great place, nice little food court, some arcade games, little flea market, card bazaar.

If you check often you can get some really good deals on the clothes. Some better finds than a lot of the other thrift stores.”

2.7 Average171 Reviews