Thrift Stores near Centereach, NY

16 locations found near Centereach

“The store is ok and has a lot of good buys but if you don't go on discount days and don't buy discount colors, they are over priced. I found a bowl that is exactly the same bowl at the dollar store which I bought for 1.25 and island thrift had it for 3.99. Guys you need to do your research and I don't know who is pricing your stuff but you will lose a lot of customers. I heard SAVERS is opening nearby so get your act together. I only go in on discount days! However, I did find some drinking glasses that made up for the ones that broke and it was a steal. So not all bad. P”

2.9 Average157 Reviews

“Best thrift store I've been in. The place is small but Everytime I've gone in there, I've found amazing deals. The owner is very friendly as well. I plan to be a regular here.”

5 Superb22 Reviews

“Joel and Jennifer were so helpful and kind. Explained the prices which were very simple and fair. Will definitely be returning. This is the place to come if you’re looking for good deals.”

4.9 Superb74 Reviews

“An amazing and fun place....my wife and I have been coming here for years and there is a huge selection for every taste and a very friendly staff. In the warmer weather they also host an outdoor flea market on a number of Sundays which is always fun and well-attended.”

4.6 Superb132 Reviews

“The store was very clean and I enjoyed the store and I like the store and I like all the things they had there too and it was so cool to say and beanie babies and stuff too and video games stuff like that too”

4.7 Superb97 Reviews

“When you go I recommend that you ask for Patricia. She is a very kind person. She listens to you and tries to help you in any way she can. If she needs help, whether it be food or things for her children like Pampers, formula, etc.! ! The only thing I would like is for her to be a lady with white hair. She is very rude to people. I feel like she is racist. She doesn't try to help you..!! That's why I recommend that you ask for Patricia, she is a charming woman...!! I give her 5 stars x Patricia because she helps me and many people. and thank you very much Patricia God bless you you have a good heart for everyone”

4.4 Superb53 Reviews

“Lots of furniture and houseware stuff. It is a very big warehouse.no clothing. Lots of paintings, mirrors, lamps. I saw several armoire's. Lots of glasses, plates. Worth it to check out. Especially if you live in the area.”

4.4 Superb109 Reviews

“This place is awesome and one of my favorite thrift shops to go to. The prices are great, the set up of the store is nice and the people that work there are very friendly. The one gentleman, I wish I knew his name, I think maybe tom but not positive, is so nice and helpful to all. If you’re looking for a local thrift to go to this is the one. Highly highly recommend.”

4.6 Superb44 Reviews

“Local hidden treasure! The employees are warm, helpful and hilarious. Shopping and a show! You’ll find old and new items of every category for reasonable prices. There is something for everyone. I can’t wait to go back.”

4.1 Good32 Reviews

“Dropped off clothing and blankets and bedding. Friendly service. I didn't get to go inside but it looks like they offer a lot. Glad to see things go to where they can help”

4.1 Good12 Reviews

“This place is selling very expensive things, and it is supposed to be a place to help the community. We are going through times of an economy that is not good, so one seeks help buying used things, but they often have them at store prices. .”

3.3 Good10 Reviews

“It is super good, they sell the clothes by the pound, the pound costs $3 dollars, the place is small but there are clothes in very good condition and new, among other things, such as shoes, bags, etc., I highly recommend it.”

3 Average4 Reviews

“I dont like the new layout of the store. Makes the 1st floor look so messy and disorganized.Pricing guide and colors of the day or of the week confuses me.Otherwise clean place”

3.4 Good59 Reviews

“I love going to the Salvation Army I just wish they were a little more organized there's no way of knowing what sizes are in the clothes until you take it off the hangers no but nothing is in any kind of organization especially in the men's wear”

2.9 Average44 Reviews

“Nicest Savers on Long Island. Extremely clean and well organized. Every item is on a hanger. Someone is always around to help. I went to make a return and they went out of their way to be helpful with it. Really went the extra mile. It’s already insane that a thrift store takes returns, so they could have been a lot less generous with me.”

3.3 Good115 Reviews

“I've been stopping in here frequently, mainly looking for cast iron. I've found several pieces, some that I'd call vintage, others I'd call modern users. I've yet to figure a system to which color price stickers are 50% off for any given day, just that Wednesday and Sunday have the most "on sale." Prices for the stuff I've been watching for have always been reasonable to cheap. Wish the staff members' English were better. But that could also be phrased as "wish I had paid attention in Spanish class!" (For the record, my Nonno spoke a Sicilian dialect of Italian and almost no English. I will NOT jump on that "English is our language" far right bandwagon!)”

2.8 Average129 Reviews