Sporting Goods in Carthage, NY

2 locations found near Carthage

“My family moved to Fort Drum over the summer in 2023. Having reptiles and a love for plants, I was bummed when there was no privately owned stores near me. I really enjoy the drive to Carthage over Watertown and was so excited when a friend told me that Simons Agway in Carthage was Re-Open! So, I took a stroll finally and was VERY IMPRESSED! They have everything, if not more then I needed! Frozen mice, feeder fish, aquarium fish, gardening, plants, live animals/reptiles, fishing equipment, etc. I also am impressed they do not upcharge the way big retailers do. Very great place, even just taking a stroll through if you want to check out what they have.”

4.8 Superb49 Reviews

“Good experience. Pete's an honest man and a straight shooter. You don't have to guess about his views... he's up front and honest about them. I respect the man and always enjoy doing business with him.”

4.6 Superb17 Reviews