-
March 2024 by MariaR
This restaurant is quaint t and beautiful. I have had the pleasure of dining there twice and was never disappointed. Next door they sell pies and cakes and they are super delicious.
-
March 2024 by AngelaD
I had french onion soup and short rib pot pie. The onion soup was excellent. The pot pie was tasty but it needed more beef in the filling. It was largely vegetable. My husband had seafood bisque and loved it. He had a mixed shellfish over linguini dinner that was very good. You pay for bread in this restaurant and it was just so so.
-
March 2024 by DrRight
Had a great time, love the restaurant, but the grilled chicken was over cooked this time, required a steak knife to cut through, it is usually tender, perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. With that said, a great restaurant, highly recommend it!
-
March 2024 by MartyM
Excellent food and service. The restaurant is very clean and the wait staff are all very friendly. We arrived about 30 minutes early so we went to the bar to have a drink while we waited for friends. My wife ordered a frozen mudslide and when she finished her drink the bar tender asked if she wanted another drink. She said no and he took the blender and dumped about a half a drink in the sink. I think he should have poured the balance of the drink into her glass instead of throwing it out right in front of us. He might have gotten a better tip if he did.
-
February 2024 by JudyL
Always love going to the Cooperage Inn. Our server made us feel very welcome and offered great suggestions. They did not rush us out once we were done which was very much appreciated. We were down on LI visiting family. Great place o go any time of year !
-
February 2024 by EllenF
From the moment we entered the Cooperage Inn we felt a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The wait staff were so friendly and pleasant. The food was outstanding. We started off with cocktails, ultimate Bloody Mary which was garnished with bacon, pepper, cocktail onion, sweet gherkin and a shrimp and a bacon rimmed glass for my husband and the North Fork Blueberry Collins for me. Both were excellent. For the appetizer we shared the ahi tuna - delicious!! Their seafood bisque was the absolute best we ever tasted. My husband had the NoFo short rib pot pie. He was moaning the entire time. The short ribs just melted in his mouth. I had the Marinated Grilled Flat Iron Steak - cooked rare just as I ordered. It was amazing! We were so full we couldn't finish our meal so, of course we took it home along with the Tartufo for dessert. Prices were average with a good restaurant but not overpriced. We will definitely be back. We recommend it very highly!
-
February 2024 by MarieS
Everything on the menu is consistently wonderful. From seafood to pork chops to a wonderful paella, great desserts and drinks as well. Staff are very helpful and friendly. Nice place to come to chill.
-
February 2024 by WendyF
We love coming to the Cooperage. The food is always exceptional. Usually the service is much better. This time the server took our order. The staff delivered the food and that was it until the check. Not once did they come and ask us how everything was or if we wanted anything else to drink. This wasn't a normal experience.
-
February 2024 by A2jr
We got there early so not many people. Service great .. I had the Seafood platter, excellent. My better half had the short rib, also excellent. Deserts were nice size, bigger than I could finish . Thumbs up to the short rib egg roll. And bloody mary. Would go there.
-
February 2024 by GeriM
The table we requested was perfect for our dinner with good friends! Our waitress was smiling and animated and our dinners were perfectly delicious. The table was cleared promptly between courses and our friends enjoyed the experience very much! It was a success!
-
January 2024 by stevi
Lovely evening. Restaurant Week. Server was delightful in every way. Place is the epitome of old fashioned charm. Food was generous and although not as outstanding as usual still delicious. Those eggplant fries!!
-
January 2024 by KPAPJ
Absolutely perfect as always! Celebrating my dear " second " mother's birthday . Jodi was our server and couldn't have been more attentive or kind! Seafood bisque was spot on ! Crab cake and flat iron steak were just right!
-
January 2024 by VincentM
The overall decor needs an update. Service was not great. Made mistakes on our salads, forgot our apps and cooked a steak that was supposed to be medium rare well done. Other steaks at the table ordered Medium and also well done. The good news was management offered another meal and comped us the steak that was over cooked. Unfortunately I wouldn't go back again.
-
January 2024 by DeckDad
Nice to venture to the North Fork off season. Easy to get a reservation, and better to enjoy the cozy, quiet atmosphere of the Cooperage Inn. Service and food were just as good as we've had during the Summer. Enjoyed the Tower for 2 as an app, more like a main course for 2. Followed with seafood linguini in a nice roasted garlic scampi sauce. Finished with strong, very hot coffee, but no room for any of the delicious looking desserts. Then out into the chill to grab a pot pie to go at a great price with the discount for dining.
-
January 2024 by DAK55
We really enjoy the food and atmosphere. This is one restaurant we continue to go to because the food is always great. Great deal on pot pies and Key lime pie at take out location.
