Hotels near Callicoon Center, NY

“We had a wonderful stay at Callicoon Hills! A buddy of mine and I were in town for a run of Phish shows at Bethel Woods. We've been through this a million times: we scramble to find a hotel when they announce tour dates, everything is flying off the shelves with people booking travel, and we never really have a chance to research our stays. Callicoon Hills was probably the best surprise we've had in 30 years of following the band. The grounds were BEAUTIFUL (be sure to check out the short trail behind the barn), the staff was accommodating and knew us by name by the time we checked out, and we had a blast bonding with the other guests, most of whom were in town for the shows, as well. The room was small but comfortable - there's enough to occupy you throughout the rest of the property that you're only in there to bathe and sleep, anyway. We didn't do much but lounge by the pool, but the hotel is as close to things as anything else in the Catskills. Had we known that the space was so awesome, we would have stayed longer. I will definitely seek them out the next time Phish plays Bethel.”

“We stayed at Rest Co a month ago and had the time of our lives! The rooms were impeccably clean and beautifully decorated. The grounds were teeming with nature, and we even spotted some running deer. The sunset was one of the best I've ever seen. And to top it off, the bar and restaurant exceeded our expectations. We can't wait to come back!”

“The Yarra was a perfect getaway spot! The rooms were very efficient, cozy, and well maintained. We ate dinner there the first night of our stay and it exceeded our expectations. Sonja and Bridgett were friendly and helpful and made us feel so welcome?. I highly recommend The Yarra!”

“Only stayed one night and really wish it was more. What a great find! This is a quaint, cosy and comfy inn. Every necessity was provided and rooms were very comfortable. The entire inn is tastefully decorated and spotless. Staff were very friendly and really helpful. Highly recommend.”

““Mountain Minimalism” that is super charming and was the perfect gateway a little over two hours from NYC! Spacious, designed rooms with balconies that overlook the golf course and sunsets at The Inn. Great walking/hiking trails to Lake Florence and stop by the boathouse. The guest lounge in the barn plus two different fire pits are good hang out spots any time of day. If there’s a fly fisherman enthusiast with you, then this is a perfect place for everyone to find their spot in nature. Great in winter even with the restaurant’s limited hours since Roscoe is a short drive away… and then I’m sure this place will shine even brighter in the summertime. Note - they are new having just opened in April 2023, so bring your water bottles, snacks, toiletries and hair dryer if staying in a room at The Inn. My fingers are crossed for a spa/pool in the future ??A big thank you to my travel agent, Bethany Rinehart @rineharttravels IG, for finding this gem!!”

“An awesome little motel and restaurant with some of the best cooks. The food was amazing, the location remote, peaceful, and relaxing. Irish Colin is the best host, and an excellent conversationalist. Highly recommended, secluded getaway!”

“If you like a quirky place to stay, with lots of charm, this is for you! We do not like chains, and we also do not like the hipster vibe. Unfortunately, it's supposed to be undergoing a renovation and will probably change, but for now it's our kind of place to stay. The family that owns and runs it is lovely. The son helped us with multiple eating and hang out suggestions, and the mother was such a delightful host at breakfast. It was unforgettable for us, as we explored Bethel Woods.”

“I am writing to provide feedback on my recent stay at the Reynolds House Inn. I believe it is important to share my experience in order to help improve the quality of service and accommodations provided by your establishment.Firstly, I would like to express my gratitude for the kind and professional assistance I received from the staff. The lady who answered the phone was very sweet and accommodating, despite the inn being in the process of transitioning from a closed state to a slow opening for the upcoming season. She worked with me to find a suitable room for myself and my children, ensuring that we had two beds and a bathtub, which was a must for our stay.However, I must bring to your attention some concerns I had regarding the overall condition of the inn. The exterior of the building appeared to be in disrepair, which initially made me hesitant to call and book a room. The front porch, in particular, seemed unsafe to walk on and was in desperate need of attention.While the room itself was clean and appeared to have been recently painted, there were some issues with the bathroom. The bathtub had a dirty and rusty appearance, making it unsuitable for bathing my children. The drain also showed signs of rust and water stains.I understand that the inn is going through a transitional phase, but I believe it is important to address these maintenance and cleanliness concerns to ensure a positive experience for future guests.Thank you for taking the time to review my feedback. I trust that you will address these issues promptly and make the necessary improvements. I look forward to the opportunity of staying at the Reynolds House Inn under more favorable conditions in the future.”

“We stayed at Kenoza Hall for our mini moon and had a lovely stay! Everything from the grounds to the rooms and food were top-notch. We could tell the staff truly enjoy their jobs and were so kind and helpful in answering any questions we had during our stay! Highly reccommend!”