Thrift Stores near Bay Shore, NY

16 locations found near Bay Shore

“I like this place because I found good clothes and I still use them also found true religion pants really great place but I recommend going early to get good stuff”

4.2 Good30 Reviews

“Best thrift store I've been in. The place is small but Everytime I've gone in there, I've found amazing deals. The owner is very friendly as well. I plan to be a regular here.”

5 Superb22 Reviews

“Joel and Jennifer were so helpful and kind. Explained the prices which were very simple and fair. Will definitely be returning. This is the place to come if you’re looking for good deals.”

4.9 Superb74 Reviews

“The store was very clean and I enjoyed the store and I like the store and I like all the things they had there too and it was so cool to say and beanie babies and stuff too and video games stuff like that too”

4.7 Superb87 Reviews

“An amazing and fun place....my wife and I have been coming here for years and there is a huge selection for every taste and a very friendly staff. In the warmer weather they also host an outdoor flea market on a number of Sundays which is always fun and well-attended.”

4.6 Superb132 Reviews

“BettyAnn is an absolute jem & has the most unique beautiful trinkets of all kinds. Its like walking into history !! can not recommend taking a walk in & buying every single thing enough !!! 10/10”

4.5 Superb31 Reviews

“Lots of furniture and houseware stuff. It is a very big warehouse.no clothing. Lots of paintings, mirrors, lamps. I saw several armoire's. Lots of glasses, plates. Worth it to check out. Especially if you live in the area.”

4.4 Superb109 Reviews

“Spoke to Trish on the phone and she was very very nice. That's one of the first things I look for when doing any type of business. Believe it or not people like Brian and Trish are hard to come by.”

4.4 Superb55 Reviews

“Great prices and a nice selection for being a smaller thrift store. Always find something when I go in. I also appreciate the fact that the religious items are free. Also the ladies who work here are always kind and friendly.”

4.6 Superb6 Reviews

“This place is awesome and one of my favorite thrift shops to go to. The prices are great, the set up of the store is nice and the people that work there are very friendly. The one gentleman, I wish I knew his name, I think maybe tom but not positive, is so nice and helpful to all. If you’re looking for a local thrift to go to this is the one. Highly highly recommend.”

4.6 Superb44 Reviews

“I hate to review this shop because I consider it my "own personal thrift store". LOL. Not much traffic here . It's pretty well buried with very scant hard-to-make-it-here hours - thus a LOT of people cannot get here unless they live locally and are "in the know". So yeah: Ssssshhhhh. It's a secret ! That said : the bulk of what's here is ladies clothes , books and kids clothes. Not a lot of hard goods , collectible stuff , etc. Very basic- pretty small . Prices are fair-to-good-to cheap. So that's a plus. A tiny bit of men's clothes and a few random electronics and some decorative home items. If you are looking for the following , do NOT BOTHER TO COME HERE: comics, vinyl records, video games . Zero. None. This is a store that does not have a high turnover and donations seem low / slow. On the upside: the ladies that work here are sweet as can be and friendly. Not worth traveling here if you live more than 10 / 20 minutes away. LOOK for the sign they hang outside to see if they are "open", which is not very much.”

4 Good6 Reviews

“Always find something when I come in. Great prices and a nice selection for being a smaller thrift store. They always have some type of sale going on which is definitely appreciated. Not to mention the wonderful volunteers who work at the register. They are all so nice and helpful.”

3.6 Good25 Reviews

“Good prices, good selection of items, and I always find something when I come in. With that being said, the Children’s toys section is always a mess and there are a few workers who could be a little kinder.”

3.4 Good106 Reviews

“I found what I needed at a good price and good quality things, the customer service is excellent, they have friendly and trained staff, a very good shopping experience, I recommend buying at Sslvatiin Army Babylon.”

2.7 Average53 Reviews

“We made a great sofa purchase, along with home accessories, recently at Society of St. Vincent de Paul Long Island's thrift store in Huntington. We fell in love with the sofa's look and comfort -- and the great price. We were so pleased that we've returned again today for an additional sofa purchase. Our sales rep, Michelle, was fantastic.”

2.8 Average60 Reviews

“The employees are beautiful, hard-working folks who know their customers well. The donations are only as good as the donations they receive, so why criticize the selections? Not once have I visited and found a messy or disorganized establishment. These reviews shock me.”

3 Average103 Reviews