-
February 2024 by Matthew S.
They raised their prices and now are giving smaller portions the true American way. Chicken Parm and pasta- are significantly less food. And to top it off managers is always rude and unhappy.
-
February 2024 by TJ Lacalamita
Great pizza and the service is excellent!
-
February 2024 by sidney dulman
Since the Greek place and the menu change the place has really went down hill. Last 4 times I have been there I have gotten sick and thrown up from the pizza over the last 6 months. Definitely do not recommend. On top of that was charged 16 dollars for 3 slices specialty or not that is ridiculous considering a pie is that price or less most places. This is not a 5 star restaurant, I shouldn't even give it 2.
-
January 2024 by Patricia Siano
Pizzas to go for a family gathering! Delicious and great customer service!
-
January 2024 by Wall 2 wall
Good pizza !
-
October 2023 by Joe Bohunicky
Love this place! Now to be fair I have only eaten the Lamb Gyro here. But once you have the lamb gyro not sure you’d want to try anything else. Just kidding I’m sure their other offerings are equally mouthgasmic. The gyro is in a pita the lamb is sliced thin and super tasty, the Tzatziki sauce is incredible, they only put tomato chunks and thinly sliced red onion on it with the Tzatziki and mmm mmm is it delicious!
-
August 2023 by Stefan H.
First time here ordering lunch for 12. Giving a generous 3 star rating. Looks like half the restaurant is Cicero's pizza and the other half a Greek restaurant, hence the two signs out front. I ordered a standard for me, an eggplant parmesan what I thought was a hero, but ended up being a sandwich! A lot of bread and not much eggplant. The sandwich upset my stomach, which is not good and doesn't usually happen. Idk if it was the sauce or the eggplant. Even before my upsetting my stomach, I didn't really enjoy the sandwich and I wouldn't order it again. Can't speak to the other $200 worth of food that was ordered. Maybe their pizza or Greek food is better.
-
August 2023 by Jeff B.
This place does large pizzas and personal pizzas very well. It also does great mozzarella sticks, and great veal and chicken parm heros!!!
-
May 2023 by Lolita M.
Just ok. I added a star because of the service. The food left much to be desired. While the gyro lacked in meat, they over compensated with and entire onion! The gyro I ordered was meager. The Greek lemon chicken soup was bland. For the price of just a meager onion souvlaki with a dash of meat (no fries) and a small bland soup for $17, I will not be returning. The atmosphere is cool. It's got an industrial air to it. I have not tried the pizza and probably won't any time soon as I have buyer's remorse on this meal. Service was great tho. If only the food matched....
-
May 2023 by Nathanael Cruz
Excellent service and great pizza!! Definitely coming back!!
-
May 2023 by raizza villanueva reyes
I am only posting a review so that businesses could improve. I ordered 4 items around 8 pm on May 4. Calamari, chicken fingers, penne+grilled chicken+broccoli, and garlic knots. The Pros: They do a good, fried calamari. It's decent. The garlic knots were decent. Size portions were decent. The Cons: Chicken Fingers had fries inside the box. Unfortunately, all fries in the box were stale. The penne+grilled chicken+broccoli barely had any flavor. I was looking forward to it, but it was a letdown. I felt like half of what I ordered was leftover food or undercooked.I want local businesses to do a better job at serving local customers because in other parts of the world, businesses show that their customer service and food services are top priority. If you want Rockland to be better, it is important for everyone to do their best.
-
February 2023 by JR Nollido
This place is nice. Plenty of tables and seats. Cool bar area. I take my daughter here for lunch with her grandma all the time. Menu is nice. Decent prices for the food. I'll Def keep coming here. Great atmosphere. Great food and pizza.
-
February 2023 by Meital Scheflan
The food was disappointing and the staff was rude. My family and I used to order from Cicero’s all the time (for many years) but after our last experience, we will never order from them again.
-
December 2022 by SRP132016
Good pizza , but overall, the place is dirty. If the windows, floor and rest room areas are so dirty,what might be going on in the kitchen? If I had seen the dirt on the walls and floor and woodwork in the restroom before I ate, I would never have ordered. Lesson learned. Won’t be back
-
October 2022 by K M.
Ciceros pizza is delicious and affordable. The staff is always pleasant and helpful. There are also other restaurants you can order from if you don't want pizza. Give them a try.
