Pet Supplies Plus Amherst - Sheridan offers a wide variety of products for pets, including natural and made in the USA options. Customers appreciate the helpful and friendly staff, who are always available to assist, whether it's carrying heavy items or providing grooming services. The store is noted for its cleanliness and organization, making shopping a pleasant experience. Many customers enjoy the convenience of online checkout and curbside pickup. The self-serve dog wash is a favorite feature, and overall, visitors have had positive experiences, often planning to return for more shopping or services.
Knowledgeable staff. Many pets to choose from, especially shelter cats looking for good homes.
October 2025
This location is well organized and the staff is incredibly helpful. I also appreciate where they've got the adoptable kitties by the window so they can sunbathe and watch the outside versus some of the other locations that have them against a wall.
October 2025
Everyone that works there is so nice and friendly, makes it nice to shop there!!
