Convenience Stores in Afton, NY

3 locations found near Afton
View Map

“When I was a kid, my friends might steal a candy bar from the shelves. Now I go in before work and if Sheila's working, the best breakfast pizza in town steals my heart (quite literally). Try a slice, or even a breakfast sandwich, if you're feeling frisky that day. You won't regret it.I swear, if she ever retires, Sheila should get a huge bonus and a reward for all the time she spends at this place. I really think she's there more than she's home most days of the week.. month.. even year. Incredible work ethic.”

3 Average2 Reviews

“Everything is wildly over-priced, and now they aren't even open 24 hours for the first time in over 15 years. Honestly, the place has gone downhill since Mirabito bought it. Hope to see another change of owner sooner rather than later. Employees seemed much happier working for Xtramart than they do now working for Mobil, and that says a lot to me about a place.”

3.2 Average5 Reviews