-
September 2024 by Nick
Really Really expensive for the memorabilia and packs of cards. He was rude and pushed me away multiple times. Cool memorabilia but too much money. Wouldn’t tell me how much my cards were worth.
-
August 2024 by Larry Ogintz
They have very good prices and the people are nice.
-
May 2024 by Gavin Stachowski
Hi Even Your Store Is Amazing! I’ll Definitely be back!
-
May 2024 by Kevin O'Connor
Best prices! Best Sports Card store ever
-
December 2023 by Michael Gross
Our younger son wants to start collecting baseball cards, so we stopped at Evan's on Black Friday. Our oldest bought his brother a complete set of Topps baseball cards and a Pokemon starter set for his younger sister. "Mom and Dad" purchased a binder for the cards to go in along with a box of sheets to hold the cards in the binder. Evan and staff were courteous, patient (especially on one of the busiest days of the year), and helpful with answers to our questions. We plan on coming back!
-
November 2023 by Thomas Quigley
Great selection of autographed sports jerseys, balls, cards,
-
September 2023 by Tony Powers
Nice selection with honest prices . Look for select specialty items and always asked any questions. This place is always happy to help so you are able to buy with confidence. Well done keep up the great experience. !!!!!!
-
August 2023 by Keara
The guy was nice. He gave me good advice. I just have a question, do you have any Mitch Williams, Sixto Lezcano, and/or Mark Lemongello cards?
-
June 2023 by Joe Mulholland
This store has deteriorated significantly over the years. At this point, the store has hardly any hobby boxes for sale, and the ones that are for sale are often Leaf or not in a popular sport - even brand new releases are often unavailable. Meanwhile, I've seen him go to the back and give a breaker a case of fresh product that has no boxes available at the storefront. Evan hardly acknowledges people that enter the store for minutes while he's talking with his core group.Recently, there haven't even been good single cards for sale. The only thing in the store is overpriced and random memorabilia, random unorganized cards that can be purchased for 25 cents each, and little else.For kids who want to collect cards or rip wax, there are so many better stores for them to be able to do that. I just can't recommend this store to anyone at this point, unless they want to spent hours going through 25 cent cards for the fun of it, are into products that no one else likes, or want to pay nearly double the price that a blaster box should.
-
May 2023 by Thomas Battista
I am not into card collecting, but recently moved and found some cards that are 30+ years old ….One Card in particular I thought would be worthy of selling after some research. If Evan’s didn’t want to buy it, that’s fine and acceptable. But don’t rudely dismiss a potential customer because you’re not interested in one particular card. He barely made eye contact and walked away rather rudely after two seconds of conversation.
-
December 2022 by Ashley Hitchon
One if only the fewest places that have singles laid out in three and four row shoe boxes for 25 cents each where you can still find star players in all sports. Love the variety of sealed wax products and packs for all sports. Just visited here today on 11/18/22 and the black Friday sale which starts at 9 am on black Friday looks great. Family oriented business with something for everyone at any age. My two boys love coming here. Definitely worth a visit if you have never been.
-
December 2022 by Scott Griffin
Great spot, loved being able to pick out my own .25 cards.... These boxes had plenty of top and well known athletes, well worth it. Evan even helped me pick out a few cards himself for a gift for my nephew that were all top notch. Fair pricing for everything here, took the guessing out of buying random packs and was able to get everything my nephew would have wanted and then some.
-
November 2022 by ALL Star Jersey Shop LLC
Been dealing with evan for years! Super helpful and 100% what this hobby is all about!
-
November 2022 by William Umansky Jr
Great product great prices Evan is awesome!! Best card shop/Ebay shop in NJ!
-
November 2022 by Mike Kellner
Honesty goes a long way.
