-
August 2024 by Dave Johnson
I have so much love for this place! This store is AMAZING for any wrestling fan! Especially 80's and 90's wrestling nostalgia. Figures, T-Shirts, magazines, and more! The Owner, Tommy, was really good to me! I really appreciate the deals he did! This particular day was $15 WWF/WWE Jakks figures. Well worth the two hour drive! As a big wrestling fan I can say this is probably my new favorite store. Thank you again to Tommy! I highly recommend this store for all wrestling fans. Check Facebook and Instagram for list of hours and be sure to stop in soon!
-
August 2024 by T&C 4L
Awesome store full of great wrestling items and the owner and staff are very friendly and easy to deal with. Highly recommend checking it out!!
-
August 2024 by Matthew Siti
Wow, where do I start? I went here for my first time today and I was blown away. It is the type of place I could spend hours picking around; there is so much rare and unique merch to check out. Were you looking for a sealed Ultimate Warrior frisbee and kite set? Look no further. An autographed Brooklyn Brawler figure at a great price? Again, you're in luck. Racks of carded ECW figures? You're in the right place. This is in addition to tons of wrestling-related magazines, comics, figures of all eras, hundreds of wrestling VHS/DVDs, loads of autographed memorabilia, replica belts, wrestling pogs(!)....the list goes on and on. The best part is they have seriously great prices. The owner was very knowledgeable about his inventory, easy to talk to. and seemed genuinely nice. No high pressure sales techniques. Willing to work with you on prices. Basically, the best kind of collectible store owner. Maybe one of the coolest things about the owner is how kind he is to children. Since it was my first time there, I was a little nervous bringing my six year old there, as some collectible store owners can be (understandably) finicky about having kids in there store. This guy immediately showed my kid how to get free turns on his (awesome) Wrestlefest arcade. At one point my kid knocked something over and the owner didn't say a word. I know a lot of places where my kid would have gotten at least a light scolding from an owner, but not here. He even gave my kid a free figure as we were leaving. The bottom line is that in addition to all the awesome and varied merch for sale at great prices, it's a small business owned by a nice guy. This is the type of place the collecting community should be supporting, even if it means driving a little out of your way. Well worth the trip.
-
July 2024 by john Barrett
Enjoyed the place at first, bought from and sold to Tommy, been buying and selling for years, you expect to take a hit financially when you sell to a toy store but he’s always been fair…..until this week. The woman who now works for him is a complete scam artist…..I told Tommy I had 5 crates full of WWE collectibles, he said “bring them in I’ll buy them when I made it clear I wasn’t looking to sell out low. I brought a giant box of stuff, two complete sets of WWE Elite figures, a bunch of assorted WWE figures including several chases, and a mint condition complete set of attitude era cards. I also had about 20 POPS that I knew he wasn’t interested in, they just happened to be in the box, along with several unopened NJPW figures I wasn’t trying to sell. She offered me 90 dollars for everything, without even looking at what I had, insisting I throw the Pops! in as well. I made double what she offered on the cards alone, and sold the rest for a grand 15 minutes down the road. She even completely damaged the packaging on a box set of 4 WWE figures because she couldn’t understand why you “couldn’t see the figures.” I gave two stars because they have some cool stuff to buy and Tommy’s been cool in the past, but he completely lost my business hiring scam artists who assume your on hard times and try to purchase things for Pennies. I expected to take a hit, and I did, sold my stuff down the road and got 9 times what she offered, woulda been more if she didn’t damage my stuff. If you need to sell anything, make this a last resort.
-
March 2024 by Brandon Sims
I’ve ordered some signed memorabilia from this store a few times over the years and I’ve always been happy with the products they send. My last order hit a bit of a snag but I reached out to Tommy and he promptly corrected the issue. If you are looking for unique wrestling memorabilia then the Wrestling Collector is your place. Their Facebook pages are also chocked full of nostalgia from the “Golden Era” of wrestling.
-
March 2024 by John Kramer
Shysters and frauds. Don’t order anything from them, you’ll never receive it. Look how many people they’ve defrauded out of money.
-
February 2024 by Logan Parker
Tommy is an amazing person and owner of this great store. (Yes we share the first name) this store has a ton of rock and wrestling items, I always end up buying something awesome! thanks for always having something cool dude!
-
February 2024 by Stephane Gauthier
Made an online purchase on August 31, 2023. They never sent me anything. I started trying to contact them a couple weeks later and never managed to reach them. Contacted via Messenger, sent email and even phoned their store, no answer. 5 months later, still nothing, and no way to reach them. I'm a wrestling promoter, and this store is scamming people online, and I will let other promoters and wrestling agents know about this the best I can. And by the looks of the other reviews, seems I'm not alone. DO NOT BUY FROM THEM!
-
February 2024 by Tommy Hall
Tommy is an amazing person and owner of this great store. (Yes we share the first name) this store has a ton of rock and wrestling items, I always end up buying something awesome! thanks for always having something cool dude!
-
January 2024 by Donald
It's not possible to give them negative reviews. I preordered an item in 2022 that was slated for a summer 2023 release and here it is 2024 and I still have not received anything!! Asked for my money back but read the fine print because they refuse to! They only offer store credit.
Inquired about the item in June of 2023 and they still don't know when it will come in! DO NOT BUY FROM THESE PEOPLE, GO TO RINGSIDE COLLECTIBLES!
-
January 2024 by Mark Bowness
Still never received my order when I kept trying to contact them on Instagram. They decided to delete me from the page . Next will be to contact any wrestlers they have lined up for autographs the best i can and let them know how the store does buisness I plan to keep reviewing this site every month since it seems I'll never get my purchase.
-
January 2024 by Donald Farnam
It's not possible to give them negative reviews. I preordered an item in 2022 that was slated for a summer 2023 release and here it is 2024 and I still have not received anything!! Asked for my money back but read the fine print because they refuse to! They only offer store credit.Inquired about the item in June of 2023 and they still don't know when it will come in! DO NOT BUY FROM THESE PEOPLE, GO TO RINGSIDE COLLECTIBLES!
-
January 2024 by Lorenzo Gonzalez
MY MAN TOMMIE ALWAYS DELIEVERS!!! Greatest wrestling store in the East. Extremely professional and knowledgeable owner hell I got into wrestling because of him. Gives the best prices and deals for anything you could ask for pro wrestling and has given so much to his community and the people around him. He runs ISPW, 80's wrestling con, and the superstore itself The Wrestling Collector!! Amazing store and once in a lifetime items. I've never been disappointed anytime I've went to Tommies. Truly the best!!!!
-
December 2023 by John Jesse Jeffords
I haven't been able to visit the shop in person yet but I made my first purchase recently and the quality of my order was excellent! I'll try to make it in to shop in person sometime for sure!
-
December 2023 by Brandon Michael
There a bunch of fraud scammers stay far away from this site and buy from ringside collectables there actually legit and trustworthy unlike these frauds. I’ve spent hundreds of dollars to never receive my orders or hear any response’s what’s going on with my orders. I took the risk buying from them outside of buying from ringside collectables which I shouldn’t have and paid the price for it smh. Don’t let wrestlingcollectorshop rob you for your money like they did too me and other people absolutely pathetic of a site!!! bunch of frauds, I now know why they don’t have a option to leave a review on there site and don’t let these other phony review comments fool you there dummy accounts made by them to make there selves look good.
