-
March 2024 by Jay Bloch
Response to owner: yes, raw pizza definitely wasn’t for us. As I stated in my previous review, We each ate a slice from the outer edge. There were 4 of us, so 4 slices went. Not 5. When you bussed our table you could see a 5th slice on a plate that was cut into, raw, and left on the plate since it was inedible. Literal dough. Why would we give you back slices and not take leftovers with us when we payed over $30 for a single pie?We didn’t want it cooked to our “liking”. We wanted it to be cooked. In general. If that’s “how you make that pie” then I’m concerned for anyone else that wants to order it. You also didn’t address the fact that we waited 40 min for 1 pizza. Again, after waiting that amount of time, we shouldn’t have needed you to put it back in the oven and wait additional time to get something that was edible.We stopped in to Beniamino's for the first time and after being served raw pizza, we will not be back.The complimentary bread was great and we were off to a good start. We ended up waiting around 40 minutes for the pizza, only for it to be raw in the center. I didn't get a chance to take a photo of it after the slices were pulled apart.We each ate a slice from the outer edges and as we got to the center, the dough was not cooked. My brother informed the waitress and she responded that they were going to put the pizza back in the oven for us. We declined. After waiting an overly long time for a single pizza and then not even being able to eat the whole pie, we needed to leave.It also seems unsanitary to take a pizza that was out on our table that we had taken slices from and put it back in the oven.We paid for the pizza and we left. We're not the kind of people to fight over customer service and demand a refund or refuse to pay. However, it seems like this would've been an appropriate time for the staff to offer to comp the meal.
-
February 2024 by Nick Fulton
If you are local and need some place to satisfy that good pizza craving, excellent option. The staff are unmatched in delivering quality food and experience while it's a great option to eat before grocery shopping.
-
February 2024 by ryan
Great food and staff, very welcoming. If you are around and are looking for pizza or anything else definitely check this place out!
-
November 2023 by Sean McShane
Great food …great people !!!!
-
October 2023 by Richard Sidler
They have some very tasty slices! ?
-
October 2023 by MATCH611
Service was very good. Staff very friendly. All Food courses were delicious and came out hot, fresh and was delicious! I had the Bianca ? chicken with cavatappi special. Amazingly tender chicken and the sauce was exquisite! Atmosphere was OK but bathroom was neglected and needs a lot of work cosmetically.
-
October 2023 by Eric B.
Average at best. Bread and crust in pizza the best part of lunch. Server was great. Super nice
-
September 2023 by R F.
What a fun and lovely family-run restaurant! The decor is simple but the folks running it are as genuine as they come -- three brothers and their father and their colleagues dish up a huge selection of pizza by the slice, as well as pastas, salads, heroes, calzones, and some amazing cannolis and deserts as well! The service is incredibly friendly and warm -- you'll feel like one of the regulars after just coming in once. The pizzas were very delicious, with a perfect crust and toppings that tasted like my nonna was in the kitchen! Try this place -- Youse gonna love it, capisce?
-
September 2023 by John Smith
this place is so dang good !! I always hit it when i am around ! family owned such a good vibe whenever you walk in !! so friendly i cannot recommend this place enough !! God bless Beniamino's and God bless America!!!!!!!
-
September 2023 by Chris Best
The food and service are always amazing. Me and my family love coming here. ❤️ ? ? ?
-
September 2023 by Gregory Koch
Great pizza, friendly, prompt service. They seem to know all their customers , super friendly, but even if you're visiting for the first time they're still super friendly. The pizza is awesome too. And they have this giant giant calzone or whatever it is, some say burrito, that can feed six to seven people. Or one, if they're up for a challenge. Would highly recommend.
-
September 2023 by Gregory K.
Great pizza, friendly, prompt service. They seem to know all their customers , super friendly, but even if you're visiting for the first time they're still super friendly. The pizza is awesome too. And they have this giant giant calzone or whatever it is, some say burrito, that can feed six to seven people. Or one, if they're up for a challenge. Would highly recommend.
-
August 2023 by Chuck Mound
2020-Skillman, NJ. You have a taste of Brooklyn Pizza in your backyard. This Pizza was amazing during my visit for the Pizza Hunters App for the Somerset County Pizza Tournament. This could be one of the Best Plain Slices around. The hint of garlic. As you ho through the slice is
-
August 2023 by simona ariton
I got my slices to go and when I got home I realized they were burnt.
-
August 2023 by Martin L.
We met a guy in a supermarket who raved about the pizza and Italian food at this place. So after a weekend , I decided to try. I walked in and ordered a slice of pizza to eat and a sub to go. The young man said the sub would take about 15 minutes. So I got and ate my pizza. Pizza was ordinary at best, kind of bland, nothing like NY pizza as the guy recommending it said.Finished my pizza while waiting for the sub, and waiting, and waiting. 28 minutes after ordering I got my sub. The entire time there was no more than one customer and myself eating in at the place. Walk in folks picking up take out orders repeatedly. I do not know what their backup of call in orders was. The sub sandwich was kind of skimpy on meat and very bland also. I come to notice that the sub had no salt, pepper, oil , vinegar or oregano, but it's called an Italian sub. BTW, they charge you to use your credit card, another surprise.
