“Extremely kind. I was visiting my hometown for only a few days, and they let me purchase a vintage fire extinguisher on a day they were closed. They didn’t even have to bother with me, and they chose to be kind. As a result, I showed a local vise collector a picture of a vintage vise I happened upon while there, and he purchased it from them. Thank you again for being awesome!”
“Previous reviews have already said it best — the only issue with this store is that there’s never enough time to see all the treasures it has to offer. You know the feeling you got as a kid when you hit the road for a vacation? That’s the feeling I get when I drive to Unshredded Nostalgia. Plan to spend as much time as you can here. Incredible variety and quantity of quality items, friendly staff, convenient location. Love this spot!”
“Bought this $21 Bracelet here. When I was there the beautiful lady was very very helpful!!! (͠≖ ͜ʖ͠≖) I was staying in Tuckerton from July 14-16, 2023… I stopped by THIS Store on Sunday 7/16/23”
“Lots of inventory. Clothes, stuff for baby, gifts for women like candles and bath products, Brighton, whole room of Vera Bradley which isn’t my taste but obviously must be popular given the space allocated to it. They have gifts for men too. We will be back for gifts for sure.”
“I travel an HOUR every time I need a gift. Was worried after they moved but i end up liking it just as much! If not more! The boat they are in is friggen awesome. Ecclectic selections. Something for everyone really. Love this store”
“The art studio is a fun way to spend an afternoon with friends doing a small holiday craft or a bigger project like chalk painting furniture. Whether you're shopping or crafting, the owner (Karen) gives the same undivided attention and dedication to helping customers find what they're looking for. A true asset to the barnegat area.”
“The cutest antique store on the island. Owners are super sweet and the collection is enjoyable to explore (not overwhelming & cluttered like most antique stores). So many treasures to explore here! I’ll definitely be back next summer.”