Gas Stations near Sandyston, NJ

22 locations found near Sandyston
View Map

“We're locals so this is our favorite gas station. It's got super friendly people. It's a family run place, and everyone is always really nice. Shell gas stations can be a little expensive. But this place always has a decent price. With the Shell Fuel Rewards (free program) they often end up being cheaper than Quick Chek.”

4.3 Superb11 Reviews

“Best filling station on this side of the river. Everyone here is Friendly, courteous, efficient with maintaining flow on a small number of pumps. We live in PA so the savings in gas is worth the extra drive time. The main building is pretty neat, some may say it seems like a gnome home even. They have regular and diesel pumps- fair pricing for NJ, one of the cheaper I’ve found along 206 and 15 corridor. Also available is ice and firewood if you are headed up this way camping. Usually a stop here means we are either close to home or headed out on a journey- glad to make it when we do. Thanks Wally’s!”

4.2 Good15 Reviews

“This station is in a very convenient area. Although they are a tad bit pricey on their products and fuel..they still come in handy when you need something and don't want to travel to get it.”

4.4 Superb8 Reviews

“Reasonably priced like everybody else on the street. Didn't have to wait for a pump and the gas station attendant was pretty quick. Didn't go inside but what else can you want for a quick gas'n'go?!”

4 Good27 Reviews

“I go here often. The prices are a little high but it's a convenience store and that is what you pay for, the convenience of the item. The staff is awesome and helpful.”

3.9 Good30 Reviews

“It seems like the prices for all 5 gas stations here, just across the NJ line are usually identical. Valero often gets you in and out more quickly since they're about 100 yards further away from the interstate.”

3.9 Good22 Reviews

“They make the food fine, but definitely grab some condiment packets if you asked for any on the sandwich. They forget one thing on my sandwiches pretty much every time and it’s just… sad? Learn how to read pls”

3.9 Good17 Reviews

“Until today I have been an AMERIGAS customer. Their customer service is just horrendous. After AMERIGAS missed thRee deliveries, my house in New Jersey was freezing up. My son snd I were shivering cold and the pipes were about to break. I made one call to Andrew at Fairclough Fuel and he said. "I'll have team to your house in 20 minutes". Then he did exactly that. My house is warming up, the shivering is gone, my pipes did not burst.... I've only written two or three reviews on Company's in my life.... (see my review on Amerigas)....If I could give Fairclough Fuel more stars than there are in the galaxy.... I would. You don't know me, but I would be so pleased to hear that other Amerigas customers move their account to Fairclough as well. It would warm my heart like Andrew warmed my house.”

4.1 Good7 Reviews

“Best prices around for gas in Sussex County ....same price for credit as cash purchase! The attendants are quick to fill...no major waiting time; there are 4 aisles here where you can enter either way,depending on location of your gas cap.?”

4.2 Good5 Reviews

“Store is very clean, best prices for cigarettes, lots of snacks,drinks and a few slot machines you can actually win on!! Bobby the manager is always so accommodating proffessional and kind. Great little store for on the go needs. Never have to wait!”

4 Good7 Reviews

“I have been voming here since i was a little kid and some new owners took over the store recently and they are extremely nice they have made the store even better made it look big and there's more changes coming to that store they told me and im super exited to see them changes asap ? ? gas price is way cheaper and best in town”

4 Good5 Reviews

“Cheap gas. They pump it for you. Never had a bad experience here. Great service, never had to wait to get gas pumped or to get a receipt. Attendants are pleasant. This is my go-to gas station bc it’s the closest one to 84 with those NJ prices :)”

3.8 Good6 Reviews

“New gas station $3.07 for regular. So much cheaper than across the road (by $.32) which is a lot. The attendant washed out windows he was just super happy and really a nice guy”

3.6 Good31 Reviews

“I stop here everytime I go to Milford. Reason is because they are one of the few places that sell my flavor of Hersey's ice cream in pint form. They have 2 or 3 video slot machines. Very friendly cashiers.”

3.6 Good14 Reviews

“This location is right off Exit 1 when you first enter NY but the station is actually in NJ. For those that are out of state, all stations in NJ are full service. The location was fairly clean and I didn't have any issues using the bathrooms. If you have a group of people I would not recommend using this location as a bathroom stop as they only have one unisex bathroom.”

3.5 Good28 Reviews
3.4 Good7 Reviews

“Quick service, staff are very efficient in getting cars through. Often has the best price in the area, and one of the few stations in the strip that charges the same price for cash and credit.”

3.4 Good24 Reviews

“Pros:-Short wait, rarely ever has a line-Price- changes constantly based on OPECCons-Pump speed is adequate but falls short of the big chains like Sheetz and wawa. (They could consider replacing the autoinjectors to speed up gas delivery)-Screen on pump 3 is cracked and on occasion Pump 2 won't give a receipt (probably out of paper).”

3.2 Average5 Reviews

“We stopped here after a hiking trip to get some snacks and a drink. The store is clean, staff is extremely nice and helpful. Tiny store but well stocked, has an area with a microwave, and provide utensils.”

2.7 Average10 Reviews

“I don't know if this place can follow directions but when a customer asks for only $25 on a GasBuddy card, don't forget to not set the programmer of your full service pumps and let it roll to full at $38 when they finally came back to check on us. When we told them all they could say is 'thats the way our pumps work and that they swore they set it."(i watched out the back window closest to the gas fill-up side.) I know a bunch of years ago we stopped at a BP gas station somewhere nearby and much like that time this time we intentionally wanted to slip into Jersey for gas coming from Port Jervis and heading into PA. However, i made the suggestion to find that BP but the driver said he had activated a special GasBuddy deal. Maybe if he would've listened to me this whole mess wouldn't have happened. He was traveling almost on fumes for most of the time down from Kingston (Ulster Co.). I was surprised just how close you are to the NY-PA-NJ border - a lot closer than the BP supposedly just down the road. The road was in New York state, but once we turned into the parking lot, i was watching on a map on my phone and we had traveled into Jersey- and all that without a sign in sight not on the toad and nothing in their business or sidestreet.) After collecting the receipt, i mentioned to my brother that that's the way Citgo always treats people, but i still dont know if thats the full truth because km comparing two gas businesses near each other in the Tristate corner of NJ.”

2.8 Average19 Reviews

“I love coming to this gas station. They are conveniently located right off the highway, they have good gas and Diesal, they offer Propane (with a filling station), have cheap cigarettes, good (fresh) coffee, but best of all there has always been nice people working there and the current manager is the best. He treats all his customers with respect, is very personable and great with people. I've been to many gas stations, but not many where I actually look forward to returning!!”

1.8 Poor5 Reviews

Related Categories