Thrift Stores near Rockaway, NJ

“I always find a major gem when shopping here! The place is organized and clean - there are always workers tidying up and keeping things orderly. Some of the sizes are in the wrong spot but it's not enough to keep me away! The staff is helpful and kind. This is my favorite thrift shop in the area.”

“Worth visiting again and again!

The book barn is exactly that an old barn filled with lots of used books at great prices.

Finding what you want: The shop is well organized a labeled. There is a lot to choose from, yet I wouldn’t come shopping with a specific book in mind and hope to find it. As with all thrift store shopping it’s better to have general idea of the types of things you want and see what you find. Maybe you will find that specific book look you are looking for and that will feel like a huge win!
Everything is pretty well organized and I’ve found the volunteers very helpful. When you first walk in you will see books on cooking, classics, crafts, music, and gardening, etc. (the volunteers are always making improvements so this may change). From there the middle aisle is organized by author and then the 3rd aisle has books on travel, sports, self help, and religion, etc. There is a room for children’s books, fantasy books and teaching (great for teaching your kids at home).

Explore! There is more! The shop has been expanding making room for more books, as well as games, puzzles, CDs, DVDs and Christmas decor. These back rooms may not be heated so come mentally prepared and be glad that the main part of the shop now is! No more flipping through books with your gloves on and trying to stay warm!

Donating: It’s easy to donate bring your books while they are open. The donation spot has its own door. I usually pop my head in a make sure they are ready before unloading multiple boxes of books. If you are coming from a distance with books to donate call ahead. There has been few occasions when the store is closed or not accepting books and you might not know this until you arrive so call before making the trek. While the volunteers take all books donated not all the books get shelved, some books are thrown away. You can walk around and see the type of books they take. So before you unload your crate of childhood books from the 60s that no one has heard of save yourself the hassle. (I’ve never volunteered there I’m just making assumptions from visiting over the last 15 years.)

Bargain Barn: The Bargain Barn and the Book Barn or two different things with their own hours. If you come and they are both open you can enter the Bargain Barn by going past the cashier at the book barn. But you do pay at each place individually. The Bargain Barn has clothes, jewelry, and housewares. Last I checked they do not take donations on Saturdays.

When to visit: It’s worth visiting when both the Book Barn and Bargain Barn are open if you enjoy thrifting. It’s definitely busier on Saturdays and the aisles are tight so it’s hard to pass by people. Go on a week day if you can or come early.

So go check it out the prices are great and the proceeds go to charities! What’s not to love?”

“Best thrift store. While chains like Goodwill and Savers raise prizes past brand new, you can find gems and good brand clothing and basically anything here for probably a buck or two. If you’re buying outside, a nice employee will eyeball the stuff you want and take cash. Cheaper than garage sales. I’m so glad I live close by now.”

“This small store is well run and easy to find. Plenty of goodies to be found inside, including designer labels and unique trinkets. The volunteers are so friendly and know the store like the back of their hand. How do they fit so much into this space? Added bonus: proceeds go to much-valued volunteer services in the region ($40,000 last year) .. so your retail therapy will really help the community!”

“A hidden gem! Pretty reasonably priced beautiful items. Shopped in the 5$ sales rack, shoes are 50% off right now. Can follow them on IG @taylorsconsignment for any updates on special hours etc. Offers tailoring services on the 2nd floor. Very kind owner”

“FYI: There is a 3 bag/box limit per donation.I want to say that every experience I have here is good but I unfortunately can’t. I still think it’s a decent thrift store and I always buy something from them. I also really like the woman who usually works the front and I have always found the prices to be fair. There are some great deals on houseware, clothing, and Vera Bradley. The store has a 3 bag/box per donation limit that isn’t advertised until you go to the back to donate the items. I do not donate frequently but try to give them quality material when I do. Today I tried to donate 3 bags of clothing and shoes plus an additional small box of housewares (silver plated serving dishes and Pyrex cookware). They accepted the bags of clothing but wouldn’t allow me bring in the housewares box from my car. The woman in the back was rude and aggressive with her delivery of this rule and just unkind. I was taken aback given that I drive out of my way to donate here instead of a Goodwill/Salvation Army - thinking that a small thrift store would appreciate this more. I understand that everyone has an off day but when rules for donation aren’t explicitly advertised, some grace and tact would be useful for when someone unknowingly tries to donate outside the rules.”

“PROS: amazing thrift store. They have a variety of everything and the prices are great! The staff is very nice and the parking is plentiful! CONS: it closes early at 4:30pm which is unlike all other thrift stores OVERALL: great place to come to, just make sure you come early”

“It's an excellent place where you can feel in family, they love to help others and share their food with the people that need it. They love to share Bible promise's and pray for many people... I love to help in this place too.”

“It’s hit or miss with thrift stores these days—some items are ridiculously expensive while originally expensive items are priced really low. Today I found two things I needed for a good price and I’m happy I stopped by :) Brand new Sterilite cake carrier for $5 and a glass butter tray for $3 ?? Store was very organized and clean, not overstocked and pouring off the shelves. Glassware and kitchenware was fun and easy to look through.”

“What a gorgeous consignment shop. They do such a beautiful job with, not only curating lovely things, but then presenting them in such a way that you walk away inspired with home decorating ideas of your own... Prices are reasonable for the treasures being offered... Worth stopping by this one regularly!”