Thrift Stores near Pleasantville, NJ

16 locations found near Pleasantville

“This is a great thrift store! I love to put together outfits from things I find here and I always get compliments on them! You can find lots of cute nicknacks and great furniture for your home! Great things for great prices and the owner is a great person. Always willing to bargain and always giving a helping hand to people in need. If you like thrift stores or need furniture you gotta check it out!”

4.8 Superb40 Reviews

“Despite living close by, I had never been to this store until yesterday. And I'm happy I went! I bought the most beautiful fabric that I plan to use for a home interior project, for $10.The women working were kind and professional. They were chatting with a friend about holiday plans and the whole experience felt very cozy.”

4.6 Superb46 Reviews

“I love this thrift store! We live in VA but for several years we come up from time to time and stop by here. I always find nice things. It’s very compacted but there’s treasures and the folks are nice.”

4.7 Superb34 Reviews

“This is me and my sisters favorite place to thrift we always find the best things!! I never leave empty handed and everything is at an amazing price. This place is amazing!”

5 Superb9 Reviews

“I just love this shop. Since they’ve moved locations to 801 Wesley Ave ,they are now a block away from my condo. I shop a couple times a week and I’m always amazed at the bargains I find. Staff is super friendly and this shop is supporting a great cause 🎉❤️😎”

4.8 Superb36 Reviews

“This is a really great thrift store. I have gotten many things brand new things here, socks, shoes coats, pillows, tons of clothes for the family and electric appliances. I always get a great deal and it’s good to know I’m helping the community when I shop here. They have different sales every week which helps.”

4.6 Superb21 Reviews

“Loved the experience in this little treasure trove! The owner and her mother were sweethearts and were amiable with both regular locals and visitors. I left with beautiful home decor pieces though they had clothing, jewelry and unique collections. Reasonably priced too.”

4.7 Superb19 Reviews

“The cleanest, most organized thrift store I've ever been in. Wednesdays 4 colors 50% off! BRING YOUR OWN BAGS NOW! No bags unless you want to buy a reusable one for $1.49 and they're small.”

4.2 Good58 Reviews

“I went to Could Be Yours during Indian Summer weekend at Ocean City. I just LOVE this place!!!! I had been there other years and I remembered how much I liked it. I knew I had to definitely make a visit to Could Be Yours Consignment. Helene has beautiful stuff and many clothing items are brand new with tags still attached. I actually came both days during the weekend because I just needed to find more clothes I could use. The best part is I only spent $90.00 total. The prices are absolutely amazing and designer clothes. Wish she was back in PA near me.”

4.1 Good53 Reviews

“Some of these reviews seem to be from when Alcove was at their former location but I am writing this review since they moved to Risley Square in Galloway. I am an AVID thrifter, perhaps to a fault. This is by far my favorite in the area! Though it’s small, it’s so easy to sift through items. I have found everything from a folding lap tray to a beautiful pair of heels for a wedding to a Halloween decorative tray. The staff are mostly volunteers and they are so lovely and helpful. They use CLOVER app so you get $5 off every $50 spent. Love Alcove! And their mission!”

4.1 Good21 Reviews

“Pretty solid thrift store, even if it's on the smaller side. They have a nice selection of clothing, home decor, shoes, household items, and bits of misc stuff.Their prices aren't as good as they used to be so I would definitely recommend finding out their sale days and going then.Staff is friendly and the store is well-lit and clean.Overall I would happily recommend this thrift shop and frequent it often.”

3.9 Good8 Reviews

“Miss Audrey has done a good job with my vest for a minimum charge of US$10.I have a great experience & am very happy with 2 pockets she sewed inside of my vest. See screenshotSept 19, 2023”

4 Good26 Reviews

“Hard to see from main road. In a shopping center next to sand and stone massage. There's two areas. One has some household items and jewelry, the other has clothes and seasonal items. There's a rack of books and dvds. A few kid's books And movies, but I didn't see kid's clothing. Take credit cards over $25 (I think). For the Saturday after thanksgiving there was a sale on clothing.”

3.9 Good36 Reviews

“Love this thrift shop. Always clean with a good selection. A designer clothes section as well as lots of brand new clothes. Lots of collectables. Decent amount of furniture, as well as brand new mattresses. Clothing is sorted by type, size, and the shirts are even sorted by color which I like quite a bit. I think pricing is fair and they usually have sales on certain items posted. There's a good sized dressing room to try things on.”

3.8 Good36 Reviews

“I was just there yesterday and got 2 pairs of shorts for my toddler for $1!!! This is by far the best thrift shop! The lady who was working was extremely nice! They have tons of great clothes and other stuff!! I highly recommend them ?”

3.6 Good32 Reviews

“This is one of the bigger Goodwill Stores that I have been to. Very clean and organized. Impressive amount of vinyl records- but please, GW, don’t put stickers right on the covers! So difficult to get off of the cardboard and leaves a residue. We know they are $1, no need for stickers.”

3.1 Average127 Reviews