Candy Stores near Pleasantville, NJ

15 locations found near Pleasantville

“Ordered taffy online from NJ to KS and I am beyond pleased at the speed of service and quality. I have been craving salt water taffy and I definitely picked the right place!”

4.6 Superb213 Reviews

“I had to break up with Almond Joy's. I tried Jagielky's take on them and fell in love ❤️. I have had a lot of great chocolate from all over the world, but this shop is my favorite in the USA. It's just great chocolate. And the staff are the best. I showed up 10 minutes before closing and they were counting out the till, and they happily welcomed me in, asked me what i liked, didnt rush me, and recommended some great options. I will 100% go back for more!”

4.7 Superb62 Reviews

“I don't get to Atlantic City often but when I do one of the first places I hit is its sugar

Dietary restrictions: If you're not supposed to have sweets don't even go you won't be able to help yourself

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes”

4.4 Superb198 Reviews

“Purchased a bunch of stuff from the store the other day to greet my incoming guests for Thanksgiving. It is a tradition of ours. Love the store! Love shopping local!”

4.5 Superb65 Reviews

“Without a doubt the best fudge money can buy. I tried the others and there is no comparison. Very pleasant helpful staff. I stopped at a competitors store and had to get the staff member off his phone.....and the fudge was not nearly as good.”

4.2 Good99 Reviews

“Very friendly staff.

There hasn't been a sugar-free tuffy for a few years. But various sugar-free chocolate creations!

Dietary restrictions: Lots of sugar-free chocolates.”

4.1 Good95 Reviews

“Went here with my parents on Tuesday June 11th 2024 as part of our long beach vacation. We stopped by historic smithville to browse the shops, and possibly purchase something. After being in the other candy stores and chocolate shops that are in the grounds, i was surprised that none of them had the harry Potter candy--- well look no more! There was plenty of Harry Potter candy in here! From chocolate frogs to gringotts coin candy, to chocolate wands, to butterbeer candy, to bertie botts every flavor beans, to the slugs. They also have other chocolates, including fresh ones in a chocolate covered pretzel, and other chocolate covered things. And more candy! I decided to get the jelly slugs, as it was hot out and didn't want the chocolate frog even though i collect the cards that come in it. Paid with cash, and went on my merry way. ate the slugs later in the car as a snack!”

4.1 Good84 Reviews

“The chocolate selection here is amazing. Everything is so fresh and Creamy. I highly recommend the peanut butter heaven and English toffee. Best place for a sweet tooth at the beach!

Dietary restrictions: They have sugar free options.

Kid-friendliness: Store has a wide variety of candies, fudge, and stuffed animals for children and adults alike.

Wheelchair accessibility: Accessible for everyone, including those in wheelchairs.”

4.1 Good73 Reviews

“Very friendly & respectful staff. I found this hidden gem ? on the Atlantic ave. It has little bit everything and prices are reasonable as well. When I m back in AC again, I will visit again.”

4.3 Superb7 Reviews

“I visited before the address was corrected on Google maps. We thought it had closed because we didn’t see it on the boardwalk. Thankfully, it occurred to me to call. That’s how we found out they had relocated inside of the Tropicana Casino. Once we found it, we were not disappointed. The associates were very friendly, courteous and helpful.”

4.1 Good25 Reviews

“I never actually have been in here but one day My fiancé and I were walking by and they were blasting Too Close by Next and for being a candy factory it was maybe too sexy of a song but it makes me and my fiancé laugh to this day”

3.6 Good44 Reviews

“I have been at both Chocolate Shops in Smithville, hands down the chocolate here was much better, it didn't have extreme sugar and the person behind the counter was really lovely!!!!
After being at both places, this is the one I will come back to.”

3.5 Good62 Reviews

“Such a fun store with awesome stuff! The owner is super friendly and the staff is great. Perfect place to visit while down the shore if you are looking for candy or other sweets or coffee. Great place. Be sure to visit!”

3.4 Good38 Reviews

“Another iconic ocean city saltwater taffy place. Not as large or variety as Shrivers but they have one important distinction. They sell smaller sized pieces of taffy which are what we personally prefer. You can get regular sized as well. Due to COVID protocols, other than taffy, all other pay by weight candies were empty. The price for taffy by the pound was a little more than Shrivers, $10.99 versus $10. We bought an assortment from each place to compare later. Also Fralingers not only sells their own brand of taffy but James brand as well. The store was not as crowded and had some nostalgic candies for sale such as clove gum and candy cigarettes. Knocking one star for lack of other types of candy available but still a great experience overall.”

2.8 Average37 Reviews