Jewelry Stores near Old Tappan, NJ

30 locations found near Old Tappan

“Lori and Sose imagined my dream ring, before I even imagined it myself! Designing it from my own diamonds and somehow, during the process, found what I love and what I so desperately needed! It was such a cathartic experience of letting some beautiful things go so I could gift to myself a STUNNING ring that is ME! Totally ME! (plus a sexy bracelet I did not know needed to be on MY wrist!) When someone you love dies, and gifts to you jewelry that they loved and treasured, do you hang on to it because of THEIR attachment to it? Or do you dig deep, and realize that the person who loved you unconditionally, for 54 years, would want you to have something that YOU treasure, that YOU love, and wear every day that keeps their memory and their love close to you in your heart? My mom is smiling down from Heaven, she knows I needed this….and I am beaming too!!! Thank you Lori & Sose….Love you both! XOXO And a very special shout out to Sose’s parents, Mr. & Mrs. Massoyan, who are the cutest couple I have ever met, who made me feel like I was family too!”

4.9 Superb51 Reviews

“Exceptional experience every time. Went to Peter for several deals who is extremely knowledgeable and kind. We brought in many unique items each time and he was very thorough. He made sure to tell us exactly what each item was and how much it was worth. Would highly recommend and will definitely be returning for future business!
- Vincent”

5 Superb259 Reviews

“Have purchased jewelry from Silverman Jewelers quite a few times over the years. Quality jewelery, friendly employees and good prices will keep me doing business with them!”

5 Superb163 Reviews

“This experience was really good!!!Imani helped me choose the perfect ring my promise ring. Not only did she help me find a ring but even help me get a bigger diamond for a similar price. This is the best place!”

4.9 Superb278 Reviews

“I’m in town from Arizona for my best friend’s wedding and didn’t have a chance to have my rings cleaned before coming. I popped into D’or after a quick Google search and they were fantastic! The gentleman helping me showed me the process and inspected my rings to ensure everything was secure before cleaning. With the care and attention to detail he showed for a quick cleaning, I can only imagine how wonderful he is to work with for actual jewelry shopping. If you’re in the market for a jeweler, I’d highly recommend checking them out!”

5 Superb150 Reviews

“Abe is an extremely nice guy, stopped in to get new batteries in my watches and tighten the clasp on my necklace. He was extremely nice, and quick. He did it all free of charge. Abe’s a great guy, I will definitely be back, and he will be my go-to for anything jeweler related!”

5 Superb62 Reviews

“I had a ring resized and Marie was so helpful. A very friendly place with reasonable pricing. They had my ring done in no time! I will definitely use them again.”

5 Superb97 Reviews

“By far the best jeweler I have ever met in my life. The meticulous detail and the quality products and diamonds is unmatched. I highly recommend anyone looking to do custom work or their watches or their jewelry and speak to Ramie. I had my watch bevel customized with diamonds and it looks fantastic!”

5 Superb165 Reviews

“Always a great experience every time I go into this Jeweler. The owner and staff are always very helpful and extremely down to earth and knowledgeable. Everything from making a purchase of a piece of jewelry, to getting a link removed from a watch, it is always worth the trip.”

5 Superb92 Reviews

“I went in to have a watch looked at. Joe took the time out to look at it and solved my issue. That’s professionalism. I highly recommend Pangea to everyone that needs a good jeweler”

5 Superb79 Reviews

“I went to Sandy because my friend referred me and I needed a special gift for my daughter. I didn’t have a “regular jeweler” and now I’m happy to say I do. Shopping with Sandy was such a great experience and will be back soon!”

5 Superb47 Reviews

“Lindsay helped us a few months ago and we didn’t buy. But she left such an amazing impression that we had to come back. The service can’t be beat. The quality of rings/jewelry is truly some of the best. We are collectors and had a hard time picking because of the amazing selection. Lindsay was here again and not only did she remember us, but she remembered what we were looking at before. She knew our style and we never felt pressured. It’s rare to find a combination of amazing service, amazing jewelry and amazing prices. When you go here ask for Lindsay and she will take amazing care of you.”

4.9 Superb78 Reviews

“Nash, Joanne, Luisa, and Roshelle were incredible! The most amazing service I’ve ever experienced! I got to the Jeweler and they opened the store up last minute to help me out, definitely went above and beyond 10/10!”

4.9 Superb97 Reviews

“My fiancé, PJ, created my stunning engagement ring with Mike’s help. He was very helpful, informed about jewelry, and provided excellent guidance while my fiancé was designing my engagement ring. He also made the process incredibly stress-free by keeping my fiancé updated on its progress. I strongly recommend and put my trust in the Mahtani family for any jewelry needs!”

5 Superb100 Reviews

“Skydell Designs redid my original engagement ring and made it into the most amazing piece of jewelry I own . It looks like a completely new piece that is modern and stunning ! Looking forward to wearing it for many years to come. Thanks so much Jordan!”

5 Superb45 Reviews

“They exceeded my expectations. Not only did they resize my ring in just 10 minutes, but they also cleaned it, leaving it looking shiny and brand new right before my eyes. The staff was friendly and upfront, making the whole process enjoyable. I'll definitely be back for our wedding band. Highly recommend for quality service!”

4.9 Superb67 Reviews

“excellence beyond belief! right when i'd given up all hope that genuine customer service was extinct, i discover this oasis! thank you for a Perfect Experience!”

4.8 Superb56 Reviews

“What a wonderful experience with Edward and his wife. They are so warm and professional! Edward took an old piece of jewelry and made it into a stunning piece. I totally trust Edward and his work. He also repaired some pieces beautifully.”

4.9 Superb37 Reviews

“My family and myself have been going to Amir Jewelry for a while. Bashar is a great man with excellent customer service and great design skills! He custom made my fiancés engagement ring. If you want great customer service with incredible designs, Amir Jewelry is the place to go!”

5 Superb31 Reviews

“Billy has always gone absolutely above & beyond. My family loves to Shop, get cleanings, and get our best pieces from WESTCHESTER JEWELRY. Thank you always Billy.”

5 Superb123 Reviews

“I have been going here for years, when Vincent was the owner and am happy to be going still with the new owners. They always greet you with a smile and "how can I help you". I've had repairs done and watch batteries. Recently I had a ring worked on and it looks like the day I received it. Beautiful. Thank you, Ryan
Wishing you all the best and continued success for many years.”

4.8 Superb79 Reviews

“Judy was so nice. She provided great customer service and made me feel like I was talking to one of my friends. When you stop at Zales at The Palisades Mall, ask for Judy. You will love her. She made my jewelry buying experience wonderful.”

4.8 Superb71 Reviews

“We’ve used Burt exclusively for over 30 years. He is honest and trustworthy. Always the highest quality at great prices. Service is above and beyond. Wouldn’t go anywhere else. Michele is an added plus!”

4.9 Superb35 Reviews

“An easy and positive experience getting rid of some unused jewelry that was collecting dust. Was also able to sell a silver bar that a family member gave to us as a gift. We came on a Sunday and were able to make an appointment quickly. Employees were friendly and professional.”

4.8 Superb106 Reviews

“What a great place! If you have something you need to sell, they'll give you a great price, if you're looking to buy something, you'll find wonderful items there plus there are auctions monthly where new items always turn up. The people that work there are super nice and helpful. It's a wonderful experience l.”

5 Superb39 Reviews

“There's no words to "thank" Marsel's Jewerly store enough for the compassion, patience, and professionalism over the past months. My dear son passed away 06/2022, and it has taken until today to complete addressing his jewelry box. No matter the cost, it was all priceless to me because it wasn't many pieces.but precious none-the-less.. Before passing along, some items needed cleaning, batteries, and approximate value. I addressed this at Marsel's through several visits of weeping. It was heartfeltly amazing how I was met with such unwavering human kindness. I immediately knew I was in the right place to carry out this difficult task. The pricing is fair and not a ripoff. I would recommend Marsel's to anyone. You won't be disappointed.”

5 Superb20 Reviews

“At ERIC JEWELRY, you are not just a customer, you feel like a guest in a friends home. 5 STAR SERVICE, Courteous and Friendly! A cut above the rest. The store is beautifully decorated and the staff is polite and knowledgable. They seem to have something for every budget. An exquisite selection of gold, diamonds, watches and gems. Thank you Eric Jewelry… you’ve gained a customer for life.”

5 Superb26 Reviews

“I cannot speak highly enough of our experience dealing with Chris. It was one of the most pleasurable shopping experiences I’ve had. We gave Chris and his team our idea for a custom ring and he and his team exceeded expectations. His communication throughout the entire process was spot on, and he welcomed all questions and changes as they came. They have two lifelong customers as a result!”

5 Superb20 Reviews

“Joshua gave us awesome piercings! Very professional, friendly, and PATIENT. If you go on a Saturday, expect delays to your appointment (mostly because of picky customers who think they know better than the expert). But if you’re lucky, you’ll get Joshua, who’ll bring a smile back to your face and leave your ears looking gorgeous. We’ll be coming back for future piercings, thank you! ✨”

4.8 Superb60 Reviews

“I’m so happy I was led to this store to find a gift. The selection is amazing filled with unique items as well as new age or metaphysical favorites. I’m used to going into Manhattan to purchase crystals so I’m very excited to know the store is so close to my home. Stephanie was a joy to interact with. She treated me and all of the customers visiting with patience, kindness and interest. I also deeply appreciate that everything has prices on them… no need to try to figure it out or play the changing price game. That means a lot to me. I also appreciate that although the store is well stocked (see photos), it’s organized and clean.I will undoubtedly become a regular customer of this shop.”

4.9 Superb65 Reviews