My sister introduced me to Gencarelli's Pizza about 5 years ago. They had the best pizza back then and they still have the best pizza now. You will not be disappointed. The plain pie, so good!
March 2024
Ordered a slice to try their pizza, thin crust, it was good, warm & delicious. I ended up ordering fried Oreos, they were good, fresh & took a few because the store got busy. 6 restaurants in same location
January 2024
I can not stop trying different options of pizza. Best tasting in Newark their is. Im in love with the authentic taste, not watered down great sauce. Wow, good job. The price is beyond low for expensive taste like that.
