Jewelry Stores near Middletown, NJ

26 locations found near Middletown

“The best staff! So friendly and knowledgeable. They aren't there to rip you off either. If you need any help with watches or fine jewelry, don't go anywhere else! Simply the best and amazing customer service!”

4.9 Superb54 Reviews

“Updated Review. Previously left a lower review than need be. After two years of having my wife engagement ring there seem to be some small issues with the ring. I called Sean and let him know the issues. Sean's response was the following and I dont know if anyone could have been better. 1. Here is a fed ex label to overnight the ring back to us. 2. Renovated the ring at no cost to me. 3. Followed up with calls, emails, and pictures. 4. Did all of this when he didn't have too.I highly recommend this shop. Not only do they make the most beautiful jewelry, but their customer service 2 years after purchasing a ring from them has been unparalleled. Thank you Sean and team.”

4.9 Superb60 Reviews

“Simone’s jewelry is one of my absolute favorite places to get my pieces!! I love that it is family owned and everyone is so kind! I’m always greeted with a smile and treated like a VIP! Abby is my go to girl, but everyone there is just as amazing!”

5 Superb201 Reviews

“Excellent jewelry store. They do high quality work on your jewelry. Takes their time discussing with you all possible solutions. They all treat you like family. The entire staff was so friendly and welcoming. I will definitely be back to have all my jewelry repaired.”

5 Superb180 Reviews

“Fisher Diamonds recently repaired a gold link bracelet that had broken. Several years ago, they also reset my engagement diamond and prepared a new wedding ring and anniversary ring. Fabulous work! I trust the owners and am confident they provide high quality work at a fair price.”

5 Superb105 Reviews

“Kristina is exactly the jewelry consultant to represent Earth Treasures! She is extremely knowledgeable, friendly, caring and fun when helping her clients. She made many excellent recommendations on my jewelry, whether selling and/or buying.She was calm & positive that we'd find the exact pinky ring I wanted! I never felt rushed, instead just the opposite, I really enjoyed my time at Earth Treasures, thanks to Kristina!! Please let her know how much Iappreciated her expert advice!SincerelyPatty Bryer”

4.9 Superb198 Reviews

“Nicole & Gabby made my day !!!!!I love the store but having you two today just elevated my experience 10000 times moreThank you so much for your chic sense of fashion n beautiful souls ?I appreciate your store but most importantly I appreciate both of yours spirit”

4.8 Superb39 Reviews

“I had a great experience at Always a Bridesmaid..My daughter found her wedding dress there and I bought my MOB dress there too. Maria showed me beautiful gowns and she was so patient with me. Thank you to Maria and the rest of the staff for helping me found the perfect dress.”

4.8 Superb106 Reviews

“I recently had the pleasure of working with The Art of Jewelry on a custom pendant, and I couldn't be happier with the results! Not only did they do an absolutely amazing job with the craftsmanship, but they also managed to complete the work on a tight deadline, which was truly impressive. On top of their incredible skills, The Art of Jewelry team is one of the sweetest and most thoughtful groups of people I've ever met. Our conversations were such a delight, and it's clear that they genuinely care about their clients. I highly recommend The Art of Jewelry to anyone looking for high-quality jewelry and exceptional customer service!”

5 Superb66 Reviews

“I’d like to thank Johnsen Diamond for being the business they are.
It’s not often that you walk into a business and are treated as well as you are there.
They keep the store immaculate. They carry a huge variety of Jewelry including watches which is my favorite piece of Jewelry.
The no pressure approach that they have is very refreshing. I enjoyed being able to browse and when I was ready to start seeing stuff they were courteous and endearing. Imagine that a place not mentioning money within the first few minutes.
I’ve been in the store a couple of times and I’ve called a few times. Always being treated with respect.
I live in Freehold and there are many jewelers between my home and Little Silver NJ. For me they are the only jeweler I will do business with as long as I’m around.
I don’t want to play favorites so I will say that whoever you have assisting you I’m sure you will feel the same way I do. Completely satisfied.
Their Jewelry is beautiful. It’s worth the trip.
Thank You to Robert and the staff”

5 Superb51 Reviews

“I have worked with this family for over two decades. They are kind, professional, fair, and experts in their field. I highly recommend them for jewelry, including rings, watches, and custom pieces.Town and country store typically offers a range of jewelry items, including rings, necklaces, bracelets, earrings, and more. Here's a general review:Pros:1. Selection: Jewelry stores usually have various styles, metals, and gemstones, catering to different tastes and budgets.2. Expertise: Knowledgeable staff can guide you in choosing the right piece and offer information about gemstones and metals.3. Customization: Many jewelry stores offer customization options, allowing customers to create unique pieces tailored to their preferences.4. Quality: Reputable jewelry stores often sell high-quality items and provide certifications for gemstones and metals.Overall, a good jewelry store should offer a wide selection of quality pieces, knowledgeable staff, and a comfortable shopping experience. It's essential to research and read reviews specific to the store you plan to visit to ensure a positive experience.”

4.8 Superb15 Reviews

“You will not find a more honest and trustworthy individual proprietor of a precious metal and jewelry shop in the United States than Steve Friedman. A life long local resident of Long Branch NJ who is admired and loved by his new and repeat customers and the entire community. His character and personality is magnetic and he has a knack for remembering the names of every customer that returns to his store for subsequent visits. In my mind there isn't another precious metal and jewelry shop I will ever visit again.”

4.8 Superb59 Reviews

“This yoga studio/ crystal shop is amazing you can feel such good vibes as soon as you walk in. I love the knowledge of all the crystals and Betsy's readings are spot on she definitely has the gift. They have all sorts of classes and events its a must check out spot.”

5 Superb8 Reviews

“What a wonderful experience! I went to Jared to look for an engagement ring for my girlfriend without really knowing what I was looking for or how to differentiate diamonds. Alexander and Cora were very patient with me and talked to me through the whole process. We ended up finding the perfect ring and stayed within my budget. The team there is very knowledgeable and their customer service is exceptional! I will be going to see them again for my next purchase!”

4.6 Superb124 Reviews

“I couldn't be happier with the service I received from Sally at Nat's. I went there to get my Mother's wedding ring repaired and watch batteries. Sally was the nicest person and I love giving locally owned proprietors my business. Highly recommend.”

5 Superb14 Reviews

“In February I took my vintage 1665 Sea Dweller to Leonardo's for service. I was informed that it would have to go to the Rolex Service Center for evaluation for service. Leo spoke to Rolex and explained that I did not want the face or hands changed. After 6 weeks called, said they would service it, and get a new bracelet, and not change the face, hands or polish the case. It came back this week and is exactly as requested and looks great.
Leonardo's staff is excellent and helpful. I highly recommend them.

S.Wrigley”

4.6 Superb114 Reviews

“My sentimental necklace broke and I brought it in to have it repaired. Lee repaired it while I waited and was so kind. He has repaired other pieces for me and always a perfect experience.”

4.7 Superb57 Reviews

“I’ve been meaning to write this review for a while now. This is truly a family owned business you can trust with outstanding customer service. I came in to fix a very frail necklace and it was fixed within the expected time range. Make a long story short there was a mix up, which now I believe could have been on my side. They were absolutely amazing and ensured I felt comfortable with the options provided to resolve my issue. I’m in customer service so I truly understand what it takes to provide the level of service they did. I actually went back and purchased a necklace I didn’t need from them lol. Thanks guys, I’m sorry I didn’t write this review sooner (not that you asked but it’s overdue).”

4.9 Superb40 Reviews

“I have stopped by several times in the past year, for a watch battery, getting a ring prong fixed and getting a new clasp for my necklace. Whatever I needed, everyone was very helpful and friendly.”

5 Superb20 Reviews

“The owner Arne is 100% transparent and knows the business inside and out. Even if you don’t have anything to sell or looking to buy, it’s worth stopping in just to chat him up. We always leave him feeling all the wiser with all the information he freely shares. And yes, he is very kind as another reviewer shared. Definitely a gem of a find. Glad he’s in our community.”

5 Superb9 Reviews

“My fiancé and I had an amazing experience with Jay at Ashford and Grace. He designed both of our wedding rings from scratch. Jay understood what we were looking for in terms of size and style; and both rings were designed absolutely beautifully. His pricing is very fair and he is always available with open communication.”

4.8 Superb29 Reviews

“I couldn't have had a better experience with Bob and Bonnie. You get friendly service and very honest pricing for high quality products. I'm a customer for life and will be back every time”

4.6 Superb92 Reviews

“I like unique things and not made in China but by locals! This store is my favorite in whole town. I bought very cute card holder. And I am sure anyone can find some precious gift ? in good store for yourself or for your close ones.”

4.8 Superb22 Reviews

“Scott demonstrated exceptional expertise and patience throughout the process of selecting the perfect engagement ring for my fiancee. His attention to detail and understanding of our preferences made the experience seamless and enjoyable. Thanks to Scott's guidance, we were able to find an amazing ring that exceeded our expectations.”

4.5 Superb37 Reviews

“Family, that's the only way to describe the experience and service at Cornerstone. From the moment you enter the door and everyday after! Always the best customer service and great prices!”

4.6 Superb43 Reviews